Tell Eliot Engel: "Limited Strike" == "Act of War"

Tell Eliot Engel he must acknowledge that a "limited strike" is an "act of war."
Sign the petition 

On Sunday, Bernie Sanders was on Face the Nation. CBS employee Margaret Brennan asked Bernie about Trump’s aborted strike on Iran, and then chastised Bernie for referring to the aborted “limited strike” as “war,” to which Bernie strenuously objected. You have to watch a clip to get the full effect. But here is a transcript of the exchange:
 
MARGARET BRENNAN: He was just doing a limited strike.
 
SEN. SANDERS: Oh, just a limited strike - well, I'm sor-ry. I just didn't know that it's okay to simply attack another country with bombs with just a limited strike - that's an act of warfare.

On a normal planet, Bernie Sanders would deserve zero credit for the observation that a “limited strike” is an act of war. Can you get an A in Algebra outside of Lake Wobegon for knowing that two plus two is four? Can you patent the Sun? But apparently Planet Washington is not a normal planet: the top foreign policy Democrat in the House has not yet won this most trivial insight. Here is Eliot Engel, Chair of the powerful House Foreign Affairs Committee, talking to Jake Tapper of CNN the day after the aborted strike:
 
JAKE TAPPER: "You think the President needs to come to Congress to get the authority to strike Iran if he wants to?"
 
ELIOT ENGEL: "Oh, absolutely. I think the President needs to come to Congress if ... going to war with Iran. I mean, individual strike, we don't want to tie the President's hands. But in terms of going to war, we're a co-equal branch of government, it's very important that Congress have a say in it." 
 
According to Eliot Engel, Democratic chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, an "individual strike" on Iran does not equal "going to war." If we're "going to war," the President needs to come to Congress for authority, Congress is a co-equal branch of government, and it's very important that Congress have a say in it. But in the case of an "individual strike," the President does not need to come to Congress for authorization, Congress is not a "co-equal branch of government," and it is not very important that Congress have a say in it. In the case of an "individual strike," Congress has no business trying to prohibit,” because that would "tie the President's hands."
 
This is basically the same worldview that CBS’ Margaret Brennan was trying to push on Bernie Sanders: an “individual” or “limited” strike is a nothingburger, “wafer thin,” not something that Congress should concern itself with.
 
As an individual, Eliot Engel is entitled to his own personal views, like any other American. He voted for the Iraq war, when most Democrats were against it. He voted against the Iran deal, when most Democrats were for it. He voted to keep sending cluster bombs to the Saudi regime to use in Yemen, even after Obama stopped doing it.
 
But as Chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, Eliot Engel is representing House Democrats to the White House on key issues of war and peace. There was a small classified briefing for “Congressional leaders” in the White House Situation Room on Thursday, the day of the aborted strike. Eliot Engel, as Chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, was at the meeting, supposedly representing the views and interests of House Democrats, not his own personal views. We don’t know exactly what Eliot Engel said or didn’t say in this meeting, because the meeting was “classified.” But we do know that Eliot Engel told Jake Tapper on national TV the next day that an “individual strike” was no big whoop. It’s hard to imagine that Eliot Engel was better than that in the secret meeting.
 
And this is why it’s urgent that Eliot Engel must change his line on this if he’s going to continue serving as the Chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, and concede that an "individual strike" is an "act of war."
 
Urge your representatives in Congress to tell Eliot Engel that a “limited strike” on Iran would be an act of war requiring specific prior Congressional authorization by signing our petition. 

Thanks for all you do to help make U.S. foreign policy more just, 

Sarah Burns, Hassan El-Tayyab, and Robert Naiman
Just Foreign Policy

If you think our work is important, please make a donation to support it.
http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/donate

© 2019 Just Foreign Policy

CounterCurrents: Teaching Torture In The Homeland, NYT Not “Descending” Into Propaganda, Our Supposed Democracy, Europe's Refugee Crisis and the Warped Morality of David Cameron

Dear Friend,

If you think the content of this news letter is critical for the dignified living and survival of humanity and other species on earth, please forward it to your friends and spread the word. It's time for humanity to come together as one family! You can subscribe to our news letter here http://www.countercurrents.org/subscribe.htm. You can also follow us on twitter,http://twitter.com/countercurrents and on Facebook, http://www.facebook.com/countercurrents

In Solidarity
Binu Mathew
Editor
www.countercurrents.org

Time To End The Refugee Shame 
By Gauri van Gulik

http://www.countercurrents.org/gulik040915.htm

A solemn moment of silence. The world over, this is the traditional response when lives are cut short by tragedy. It has also been a common response to tragedies in Europe and off its shores which have ended the lives of thousands of refugees and migrants. Not killed by bombs in Syria, but killed while making terrifying journeys in search of safety and better lives in Europe. But the scale and rapid succession of these tragedies calls for breaking the silence


Europe's Refugee Crisis and the Warped Morality of David Cameron 
By Colin Todhunter

http://www.countercurrents.org/todhunter050915.htm

UK Prime Minister David Cameron this week said "as a father I felt deeply moved" by the image of a Syrian boy dead on a Turkish beach. As pressure mounts on the UK to take in more of those fleeing to Europe from Syria and elsewhere. Cameron added that the UK would fulfil its "moral responsibilities." On hearing Cameron’s words on the role of ‘morality’, something he talks a lot about, anyone who has been following the crisis in Syria would not have failed to detect the hypocrisy


When Brinda Karat Became Emotional In Kandhamal 
By Binu Mathew

http://www.countercurrents.org/mathew040915.htm

Why such a strong woman like Brinda Karat became so emotional in Kandhamal? It is a story that needs to be told and it will tell the the state of Criminal Justice System in Kandhamal


Teaching Torture In The Homeland 
By Elizabeth Hayes

http://www.countercurrents.org/hayes040915.htm

We need to find a way to teach our children, and each other, because the corporatocracy has taken over the state schools from kindergarten on, and all too few are strong enough to pass through without being deformed into their oh-so-useful cogs


U.S. Has Now Retrospectively Joined Fascist Side in WW II 
By Eric Zuesse

http://www.countercurrents.org/zuesse040915.htm

At a commemorative celebration in Beijing on Thursday September 3rd, marking the 70th Anniversary of China's freedom from the aggressor Japan ending World War II in China, the United States conspicuously avoided siding with its former WW II ally China, which had been one of the pro-democracy Allies during that war, and instead retrospectively switched sides, to the former fascist Axis powers, Japan itself, and also Germany


Our Supposed Democracy 
By Steve Dustcircle

http://www.countercurrents.org/dustcircle040915.htm

In this country, we really don't have open choice. All choices are closed, the choices those in charge have given us. It's like parents who would ask would the kids in the back seat rather be grounded or abused. Of course, the kids would prefer neither, but if the choice had to be made, they'd choose the lesser of the two evils


NYT Not “Descending” Into Propaganda 
By Robert Barsocchini

http://www.countercurrents.org/barsocchini040915.htm

The New York Times says in an article today that, although the US won’t join the majority of the world by signing the treaty banning cluster bombs, it has “abided by its provisions”. Glenn Greenwald published an article in response documenting that, in fact, the US “continually violates all” of the provisions of the cluster bomb treaty, “systematically and as a matter of policy doing exactly that which the treaty expressly bans.”


The Sheena Bora Murder In The Context of A Culture of Free Market Greed 
By Vidyadhar Date

http://www.countercurrents.org/date050915.htm

The sensational murder case concerning Indrani and Peter Mukerjea, corporate figures, needs to be seen in the wider context of a society created by neoliberalism. A culture of free market greed and neoliberalism has created a world in which psychopathic personality traits are rewarded, says Paul Verhaeghe, a widely respected psychologist and professor of psychology at the university of Ghent

RSN: An Ancient Fish Is Running Out of Time, NYT Claims US Abides by Cluster Bomb Treaty: The Exact Opposite of Reality,

It's Live on the HomePage Now: 
Reader Supported News

---

Glenn Greenwald | NYT Claims US Abides by Cluster Bomb Treaty: The Exact Opposite of Reality 
 
Glenn Greenwald, The Intercept 
Greenwald writes: "In December 2009 - just weeks after he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize - President Obama ordered a cruise missile strike on al-Majala in southern Yemen. That strike 'killed 35 women and children.' Among the munitions used in that strike were cluster bombs, including ones designed to scatter 166 'bomblets.'" 
READ MORE

US Clerk Jailed for Refusing to Issue Marriage Certificates to Gay Couples 
Steve Bittenbender, Reuters 
Bittenbender writes: "While Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis was jailed on Thursday for refusing to follow the orders of U.S. District Judge David Bunning, her deputies processed a license for James Yates and William Smith, who had previously been denied one five times, after the clerk's office doors opened on Friday." 
READ MORE

New Cellphone Surveillance Safeguards Imposed on Federal Law Enforcement 
Carrie Johnson, NPR 
Johnson writes: "The Justice Department says it will beef up legal requirements for using cell-site simulators, an increasingly controversial form of surveillance technology that secretly gathers data about mobile devices." 
READ MORE

Police Officer Indicted for First-Degree Murder in Death of Unarmed Teenager 
Jon Swaine, Guardian UK 
Swaine writes: "A police officer was in custody on Thursday evening after being indicted with first-degree murder for the fatal shooting of an unarmed black 18-year-old in Virginia earlier this year." 
READ MORE

Stephen Colbert Mocks Jeb Bush for Using Late Show Appearance for Fund-Raising 
Daniel Kreps, Rolling Stone 
Kreps writes: "Republican presidential candidate Jeb Bush recently sent out an email to supporters trumpeting his visit to the inaugural episode of Late Show With Stephen Colbert and also announcing a contest where, for $3, donors could win a VIP trip to the taping." 
READ MORE

When You See That Drowned Syrian Boy, You Should See the United States' Shameful Failure 
Amanda Taub, Vox 
Taub writes: "The death of any child is devastating. But these children's stories are particularly painful to read about, because they carry a reproach for readers like us: We let this happen. We left those innocent children to this fate." 
READ MORE

An Ancient Fish Is Running Out of Time 
Chris Hunter, The New York Times 
Hunter writes: "From an evolutionary perspective, the pallid sturgeon is a thing of beauty." 
READ MORE

---