Articles posted HERE.
Larry Summers' Citigroup Problem
Could a possible conflict of interest derail the former Treasury secretary's appointment to run the Federal Reserve?
| Thu Sep. 12, 2013
"Citigroup is a behemoth on Wall Street, and constantly subject to Fed regulatory actions," says Craig Holman, the architect of Obama's 2009 ethics rules and currently a government affairs lobbyist for the consumer watchdog Public Citizen. "I would expect Summers would have to recuse himself quite frequently." He adds, "Recusal can be expected to be so frequent as to hinder Summers' ability to carry out his job as Fed chairman."
The Obama administration has granted dozens of ethics rules waivers since 2009, but they have mostly gone to lower-level appointees with limited conflicts of interest. Were Summers to be granted a waiver, according to Holman, it would be the most significant one yet.
If appointed, Summers might have to remove himself from consultations on penalties levied against Citi for things like sketchy foreclosure practices and inadequate anti-money-laundering protections. Nor would he be able to vote on post-financial crisis rules that Congress ordered the Fed to draft, including restrictions on CEO pay and guidelines for how much emergency capital Citi has to keep on its books. (The Fed board votes on all regulations, mergers, and applications to form new banks; it has voted 20 times so far in 2013. Penalty decisions are often delegated to staff or regional reserve banks, but the board consults on them.)
Neither the White House nor a spokesman for Summers would comment for this story.
Summers' potential conflict of interest wouldn't incapacitate the Fed. The six other governors on the Federal Reserve board would still be able to vote to approve regulations. And Obama's ethics rules wouldn't block Summers, who is a former director of Obama's National Economic Council, from having a say on broader regulations mandated by the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial reform law that affect the biggest banks, including Citi. This would include the Volcker rule, which is supposed to limit high-risk trading by commercial banks.
But it's difficult to see how working "on a rule that affects only Citi and its largest competitors" wouldn't constitute a potential conflict of interest for Summers, says Marcus Stanley, policy director at the advocacy group Americans for Financial Reform. Michael Greenberger, an expert on financial markets and professor at the University of Maryland school of law, agrees: "Whatever he does for everybody, he does for Citigroup."
"Even if there's not a formal conflict," Greenberger adds, "there is an appearance of conflict."
Citi isn't the only Wall Street entity that has hired Summers. He also has done consulting work for a number of smaller financial firms, including the hedge fund D.E. Shaw and the venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz. If he gets the job, he'd have to step aside if they have business before the Fed. (Summer has also made money giving speeches at top financial firms, including JPMorgan Chase, Merrill Lynch, and Goldman Sachs, but speechifying is not considered employment under Obama's ethics rules.)
Yellen, the other main contender for Fed chair and the underdog in this race, has no Wall Street hang-ups. She has spent the past 20 years at the Fed.
Holman says Summers' potential conflicts of interest should trouble the White House. "You'd expect that if he represents a behemoth and has to recuse himself so frequently, that should be a factor in considering not appointing him." But Sanford Weill, the architect of the merger that created Citigroup and its chairman until 2006, is not worried. On Tuesday, he noted that that he has "unbelievable confidence" in Summers' ability to do the job.
Summers' potential conflict of interest wouldn't incapacitate the Fed. The six other governors on the Federal Reserve board would still be able to vote to approve regulations. And Obama's ethics rules wouldn't block Summers, who is a former director of Obama's National Economic Council, from having a say on broader regulations mandated by the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial reform law that affect the biggest banks, including Citi. This would include the Volcker rule, which is supposed to limit high-risk trading by commercial banks.
But it's difficult to see how working "on a rule that affects only Citi and its largest competitors" wouldn't constitute a potential conflict of interest for Summers, says Marcus Stanley, policy director at the advocacy group Americans for Financial Reform. Michael Greenberger, an expert on financial markets and professor at the University of Maryland school of law, agrees: "Whatever he does for everybody, he does for Citigroup."
"Even if there's not a formal conflict," Greenberger adds, "there is an appearance of conflict."
Citi isn't the only Wall Street entity that has hired Summers. He also has done consulting work for a number of smaller financial firms, including the hedge fund D.E. Shaw and the venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz. If he gets the job, he'd have to step aside if they have business before the Fed. (Summer has also made money giving speeches at top financial firms, including JPMorgan Chase, Merrill Lynch, and Goldman Sachs, but speechifying is not considered employment under Obama's ethics rules.)
Yellen, the other main contender for Fed chair and the underdog in this race, has no Wall Street hang-ups. She has spent the past 20 years at the Fed.
Holman says Summers' potential conflicts of interest should trouble the White House. "You'd expect that if he represents a behemoth and has to recuse himself so frequently, that should be a factor in considering not appointing him." But Sanford Weill, the architect of the merger that created Citigroup and its chairman until 2006, is not worried. On Tuesday, he noted that that he has "unbelievable confidence" in Summers' ability to do the job.
If You Liked This, You Might Also Like...
See How Citigroup Wrote a Bill So It Could Get a Bailout
Citigroup lobbyists drafted a bill to allow more risky dealings by taxpayer-backed banks and—what do you know?—the House financial services committee passed nearly identical legislation.Today's Most Interesting Argument Against Larry Summers as Fed Chair
His only strong point is crisis management, but that's the one thing that barely matters at all.6 More Reasons Larry Summers Should Not Be Fed Chair
There are a number of reasons the former director of Obama's National Economic Council shouldn't be nominated to head the Federal Reserve. But he would be particularly bad on financial reform.How to Fire People the Citigroup Way
For Pity's Sake, Let's Not Nominate Larry Summers to Run the Fed