Robert Reich hit the nail on the head!

Please consider subscribing to RSN and supporting independent media to provide the FACTS you need to make informed decisions.

Portrait, Robert Reich, 08/16/09. (photo: Perian Flaherty)

David Brooks' Utter Ignorance About Inequality

By Robert Reich, Robert Reich's Blog

19 January 14

ccasionally David Brooks, who personifies the oxymoron "conservative thinker" better than anyone I know, displays such profound ignorance that a rejoinder is necessary lest his illogic permanently pollute public debate. Such is the case with his New York Times column last Friday, arguing that we should be focusing on the "interrelated social problems of the poor" rather than on inequality, and that the two are fundamentally distinct.

Baloney.

 

First, when almost all the gains from growth go to the top, as they have for the last thirty years, the middle class doesn't have the purchasing power necessary for buoyant growth.

 

Once the middle class has exhausted all its coping mechanisms - wives and mothers surging into paid work (as they did in the 1970s and 1980s), longer working hours (which characterized the 1990s), and deep indebtedness (2002 to 2008) - the inevitable result is fewer jobs and slow growth, as we continue to experience.

 

Few jobs and slow growth hit the poor especially hard because they're the first to be fired, last to be hired, and most likely to bear the brunt of declining wages and benefits.

 

Second, when the middle class is stressed, it has a harder time being generous to those in need. The "interrelated social problems" of the poor presumably will require some money, but the fiscal cupboard is bare. And because the middle class is so financially insecure, it doesn't want to, nor does it feel it can afford to, pay more in taxes.

 

Third, America's shrinking middle class also hobbles upward mobility. Not only is there less money for good schools, job training, and social services, but the poor face a more difficult challenge moving upward because the income ladder is far longer than it used to be, and its middle rungs have disappeared.

 

Brooks also argues that we should not be talking about unequal political power, because such utterances cause divisiveness and make it harder to reach political consensus over what to do for the poor.

 

Hogwash. The concentration of power at the top - which flows largely from the concentration of income and wealth there - has prevented Washington from dealing with the problems of the poor and the middle class.

 

To the contrary, as wealth has accumulated at the top, Washington has reduced taxes on the wealthy, expanded tax loopholes that disproportionately benefit the rich, deregulated Wall Street, and provided ever larger subsidies, bailouts, and tax breaks for large corporations. The only things that have trickled down to the middle and poor besides fewer jobs and smaller paychecks are public services that are increasingly inadequate because they're starved for money.

 

Unequal political power is the endgame of widening inequality - its most noxious and nefarious consequence, and the most fundamental threat to our democracy. Big money has now all but engulfed Washington and many state capitals - drowning out the voices of average Americans, filling the campaign chests of candidates who will do their bidding, financing attacks on organized labor, and bankrolling a vast empire of right-wing think-tanks and publicists that fill the airwaves with half-truths and distortions.

 

That David Brooks, among the most thoughtful of all conservative pundits, doesn't see or acknowledge any of this is a sign of how far the right has moved away from the reality most Americans live in every day.

The President on Mass Surveillance
The New York Times | Editorial
Excerpt: "Even as Mr. Obama spoke eloquently of the need to balance the nation's security with personal privacy and civil liberties, many of his reforms were frustratingly short on specifics and vague on implementation."
READ MORE

Supreme Court to Decide Fate of Warrantless Cellphone Searches
Al Jazeera America
Excerpt: "At issue is a 40-year-old high court ruling allowing warrantless searches of items people are carrying when they are arrested. Lower federal and state courts have differed over whether the ruling should apply to increasingly sophisticated cellphones and smartphones."
READ MORE

A Mexican Revolution Against Drug Trafficking
Agence France-Presse
Excerpt: "Self-defense groups made up of Mexican farmers and other local people have taken over another town that had been overrun by drug traffickers in the restive state of Michoacan."
READ MORE

250 Bottlenose Dolphins Captured, Prepared for Slaughter in Japan
Hawaii Reporter
Excerpt: "Five separate pods of Bottlenose dolphins were driven into Taiji's infamous killing cove yesterday and held overnight."
READ MORE

Many Remain Wary of W. Va. Water as Smell Lingers
Ben Nuckols, Associated Press
Nuckols reports: "The smell lingers - the slightly sweet, slightly bitter odor of a chemical that contaminated the water supply of West Virginia's capital more than a week ago. It creeps out of faucets and shower heads."
READ MORE

Charles Pierce | Blue Dog Blues

Charles Pierce, Esquire
Pierce writes: "Is there something about actual progressive populism that simply won't sell in rural districts? Most of the progressive ideas the last time we had a Gilded Age came out of rural districts. Bob LaFollette didn't grow up in Queens, after all. I believe the time for selling out principles is probably over."
READ MORE

A Major Victory for Snowden and NSA Reformers
Ryan Lizza, The New Yorker
Lizza reports: "It's reasonable to suspect that the modifications to the N.S.A.'s telephone-metadata program that Obama announced on Friday are simply cosmetic changes meant to short-circuit the pressure for substantive reform."
READ MORE

What Obama Didn't Say in His Speech on NSA Spying
Zoe Carpenter, The Nation
Carpenter writes: "The really significant parts of Obama's speech were the things he did not mention. He did not call for a full stop to the bulk collection of communication records, only a transfer of ownership. Instead, he endorsed the idea that data about millions of Americans should be stored and made available to intelligence analysts."
READ MORE

Elizabeth Kucinich | Calls Intensify for Obama to Fulfill Campaign Promise on GMO Labeling
Elizabeth Kucinich, Common Dreams
Kucinich reports: "A morning press conference offered a beacon of hope for farmers and activists on Capitol Hill today as members of Congress and 200 organizations demanded Obama fulfill his 2007 campaign promises to label GMOs."
READ MORE

Sometimes 'Nazi' Is the Right Word
Etgar Keret, The New York Times
Keret writes: "People in Israel use 'Nazi' when they want the most vicious curse possible, and it's usually directed at someone they perceive as belligerent. ... As the son of Holocaust survivors, I find it particularly rankling."
READ MORE

Senator Wants to Force Low-Income Americans to Show ID for Their Food
Alan Pyke, ThinkProgress
Pyke reports: "Food stamp recipients will have their grocery store humiliation compounded by having to show a photo ID in order to buy food if Sen. David Vitter (R-LA) gets his way."
READ MORE

Reader Supported News | 19 January 14 AM

It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News

A BRIGHT SPOT ON FUNDING: While donations have been difficult to come by recently our core of "Sustainer Subscribers" is actually growing nicely. A Sustainer Subscriber is a monthly donor of $10. or more. As a Sustainer Subscriber you get no fundraising emails. It's easy to become a Sustainer Subscriber, just go to the RSN Donation page and sign up for a monthly donation of $10. or more and we do the rest. We look forward to having you on board. / Marc Ash, Founder Reader Supported News

Okay, I'll make a donation.