Boeing: Corporate Welfare At Its Best!

There's a good book, easily understandable, "The Great American Jobs Scam" by Greg LeRoy, about corporate tax dodging and the myth of job creation.

When you hear JOB CREATION and TAX BREAKS, run like hell because they don't work!
American taxpayers are left holding the bag while the already wealthy reap the benefits.....just like the phony Casino rhetoric.  

Boeing is just one egregious example:

Ralph Nader. (photo: unknown)

Letter to Boeing's Boss: Squeezing Workers for Corporate Welfare

By Ralph Nader, The Nader Page

29 December 13

Jim McNerney, CEO
The Boeing Company
100 North Riverside
Chicago, IL 60606

ear Mr. McNerney:

The squeeze that you and Boeing are putting on your machinist workers' pensions, pay scales and your stance on other labor issues regarding the assembling of the new 777X airliners is unseemly for several reasons.

 

First, consider your pay this year of $21.1 million, a 15 percent increase from the previous year, and much higher than your predecessors. That sum does not demonstrate a moral authority to require sacrifices from your workers at a time of rising Boeing sales and profits, dividend increases, cash hoard, and another notorious $10 billion stock buyback. I say notorious because stock buybacks per se do little for shareholder values and a lot for the enlarged stock options of top executives.

 

Second, you're holding an auction for your long-time workers jobs in other states, inciting a bidding war whereby states are giving away taxpayer assets to lure your 777X assembly factory with huge tax holidays and other subsidies. Washington state outdid itself with a new law, signed by Governor Jay Inslee with the largest state business tax break package for Boeing in history. The tax escape law "will give Boeing and its suppliers about $8.7 billion in tax breaks between now and 2040," according to the Citizens for Tax Justice (CTJ) calculations. CTJ adds that "Boeing has managed to avoid paying even a dime of state income taxes nationwide on $35 billion in pretax U.S. profits."

 

Boeing also received tax advantages from the federal government, including $1.8 billion in federal income tax rebates on its $35 billion in U.S. profits between 2003 and 2012.

 

Third, in 1997 the Justice Department allowed Boeing to merge with McDonnell Douglas, making Boeing the only manufacturer of commercial jet planes in the United States - a domestic monopoly, justified by the only other foreign competitor - Airbus Industries in Europe. Another valuable gift by Uncle Sam brought about by your company's Washington lobbyists.

 

Fourth, recall Boeing's contract with the Department of Defense for the initial phase of Air Force's KC-46 aerial tanker program that provoked sharp criticism by Senator John McCain in July 2011 for the excessive burdens on American taxpayers from cost over-runs in a supposed "fixed price" contract. In a letter to Department of Defense Undersecretary Ashton B. Carter, Senator McCain wondered "why under a fixed-price, relatively low-risk contract, taxpayers may have to pay 60 percent of any overrun within that band - up to $600 million."

 

A book could be written about the Boeing company's strategy for externalization of a variety of its costs onto innocent, defensely people - whether workers or taxpayers. Boeing's systemic campaigns for corporate welfare are shameful. Your company is one of the major corporate welfare kings in America, running a close race with the champion - General Electric. As CTJ wrote: Boeing "employs an army of site location and tax consultants, whose job has been to blackmail states into giving Boeing lavish tax breaks." These include sales and property tax breaks which drain communities' ability to provide for school and other public facilities (http://www.goodjobsfirst.org/corporate-subsidy-watch/boeing).

 

Fifth, there is the gigantic subject of your outsourcing to foreign suppliers, in particular Japan where your technology transfers, damaging the longer term viability of U.S. competitiveness in the aerospace sector for short term gains favoring Boeing, merit thorough examination by the Congress.

 

As you know Boeing's foreign outsourcing brought your company considerable quality control and delay troubles with the Dreamliner.

 

You need to read the 2005 report by the Defense Science Board about the hollowing out of domestic capability in the electronics industry from this kind of overseas outsourcing migration by U.S. companies.

 

For starters read the current copy of The American Conservative magazine's cover story titled "Japan's Plan to Unmake Boeing," describing the full assistance of Boeing. No doubt, if your further cruel downward pressure on your machinists culminates in your destroying their union local and their jobs by leaving the state of Washington and going for example to the anti-union state of South Carolina, there will be further public inquiries. Such as how perverse incentives provided by your suppliers in Japan and elsewhere have furthered job losses here and accelerated your company's technology transfers perhaps beyond the tipping point against the U.S. national interest.

 

Sincerely yours,

Ralph Nader



The rest of RSN's thought-provoking articles:

Noam Chomsky: Governments are Power Systems, Trying to Sustain Power

Natasha Lennard, Salon
Excerpt: "Governments are power systems. They are trying to sustain their power and domination over their populations and they will use what means are available to do this."
READ MORE

Charles Pierce | Judge Rules on NSA From Under His Bed

Charles Pierce, Esquire
Pierce writes: "Let us congratulate U.S. District Judge William Pauley III. It cannot be easy issuing an important ruling while hiding under your bed."
READ MORE

Ezra Klein | Why Shouldn't You Just Pay the Individual Mandate?
Ezra Klein, The Washington Post
Klein writes: "Most people don't buy insurance because they expect to need it. They buy insurance in case they need it."
READ MORE

UN Hopes for South Sudan Reinforcements Within 48 hours
Louis Charbonneau and Michelle Nichols, Reuters
Excerpt: "[The United Nations] hopes to begin receiving within the next 48 hours critical reinforcements of military hardware and personnel for its overstretched peacekeeping mission in South Sudan, which is on the verge of civil war."
READ MORE

Philly's New Land Bank: Will It Give Blighted Communities a Boost?
Jake Blumgart, YES! Magazine
Blumgart writes: "The city is home to more than 40,000 vacant properties. Now neighborhoods are hoping a new public entity can help them bounce back from the post-industrial blues."
READ MORE

Ken Butigan | Conscientious Objectors Needed Now More Than Ever
Ken Butigan, Waging Nonviolence
Butigan writes: "In our time of permanent war, the Edward Snowdens and Chelsea Mannings are showing us how powerful conscientious objection still is."
READ MORE

6 Crimes Against Nature Perpetrated by the Factory Farms
Martha Rosenberg, AlterNet
Rosenberg writes: "While many procedures on factory farms are cruel, some practices ... are truly crimes against nature."
READ MORE

 

 

Robert Reich | Don't Succumb to Defeatism About the Affordable Care Act

Robert Reich, Robert Reich's Blog
Reich writes: "Whatever happened to American can-do optimism? Even before the Affordable Care Act covers its first beneficiary, the nattering nabobs of negativism are out in full force."
READ MORE

John Nichols | Congress Chooses Austerity Over Job Creation and Economic Growth
John Nichols, The Nation
Nichols writes: "Most members of Congress were pleased with themselves Thursday. They agreed to agree - crossing lines of partisanship and ideology - on an austerity budget that, as Oregon Congressman Peter DeFazio has noted, 'won't create jobs, get the economy back on track, or meaningfully cut the deficit.' That's not the worst of it."
READ MORE

Benefits Ending for One Million Unemployed
Annie Lowrey, The New York Times
Lowrey reports: "An emergency federal program that acts as a lifeline for 1.3 million jobless workers will end on Saturday, drastically curtailing government support for the long-term unemployed and setting the stage for a major political fight in the new year."
READ MORE

Strange Bedfellows: Pat Buchanan and Putin
Harold Meyerson, The Washington Post
Meyerson writes: "While Buchanan's pugnacity in the culture wars has long since ceased to be news, his latest entry is jaw-dropping nonetheless. Writing last week on a right-wing Web site , he announced he'd found a new star in the paleoconservative firmament: Vladimir Putin."
READ MORE

Homeless Couple Gets a Home on Christmas Eve, Thanks to 'Occupy' Group
Scott Keyes, ThinkProgress
Keyes reports: "For many couples, the thought of living together in a 96-square-foot house sounds awful. But for Chris Derrick and Betty Ybarra, it's a Christmas miracle."
READ MORE

Global Warming Will Intensify Drought, Says New Study
John Abraham, Guardian UK
Abraham reports: " ... what matters most in our day-to-day lives is extreme weather. If human-caused climate change leads to more extreme weather, it would make taking action more prudent."
READ MORE