Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Citizen United. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Citizen United. Show all posts

Saturday, October 29, 2016

RSN: Bernie Sanders | Here's What I'll Do the Day After the Election




It's Live on the HomePage Now: 
Reader Supported News


Sure, I'll make a donation!

FOCUS: Bernie Sanders | Here's What I'll Do the Day After the Election 
Bernie Sanders. (photo: AP) 
Bernie Sanders, The Boston Globe 
Sanders writes: "I am currently working as hard as I can to see that Donald Trump is defeated, that Hillary Clinton is elected president, and that Democrats gain control of the US House and Senate." 
READ MORE


 am currently working as hard as I can to see that Donald Trump is defeated, that Hillary Clinton is elected president, and that Democrats gain control of the US House and Senate. The day after the election, working with millions of grass-roots activists, I intend to do everything possible to make certain that the new president and Congress implement the Democratic platform, the most progressive agenda of any major political party in the history of the United States.
That agenda includes overturning the disastrous Supreme Court decision on Citizens United, raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, expanding Social Security, breaking up “too-big-to-fail banks,” making public colleges and universities tuition-free for the middle class, and rebuilding our crumbling infrastructure. It also includes pay equity for women, a new approach toward trade, aggressive action to combat climate change, raising taxes on the wealthy and large corporations, lowering prescription drug prices, a significant movement toward universal health care, and major reforms in our criminal justice and immigration systems.
If this election has taught us anything, it is that the American people are sick and tired of the economic, political, and media status quo. They are tired of a rigged economy in which millions work longer hours for lower wages while 52 percent of all new income goes to the top 1 percent. They are tired of billionaires like Trump and large profitable corporations not paying a nickel in federal income taxes while the middle class pays their fair share to support governmental services. They are tired of a corrupt campaign finance system that allows billionaires like the Koch brothers, Sheldon Adelson, and others to spend hundreds of millions to elect candidates who will represent the wealthy and the powerful. They are tired of corporate media that focus on political gossip and look at elections as personality contests, rather than provide for a serious discussion of the major crises facing our country.
The anger and frustration of the American people, all across the political spectrum, is palpable. They want a government that represents the needs of working families and not just billionaires. They want bold action to rebuild the shrinking middle class, not inside-the-beltway palliatives written by corporate lobbyists.
At a time of massive political discontent, when millions not only are contemptuous of the major political parties but also are actually giving up on democracy, we need a new administration that has both vision and courage. We need vision from the top to point the way toward a new America that is more inclusive and egalitarian — which boldly addresses income and wealth inequality, poverty, and the needs of the uninsured. We need an administration that has the courage to take on the powerful special interests — corporate America, Wall Street, the insurance and drug companies, the fossil fuel industry — who stand in the way of real change and whose greed is destroying this country.
There is no moral excuse for the top one-tenth of 1 percent owning as much wealth as the bottom 90 percent, for one family (the Waltons) having more wealth than the bottom 42 percent of our population, for the number of billionaires increasing by ten-fold since 2000 while we continue to have the highest rate of childhood poverty of almost any industrialized country on earth.
There is no rational reason why we remain the only major country not to guarantee health care to all as a right or provide paid family and medical leave, or why we have more people in jail than any other country on earth at the same time as we have outrageously high levels of youth unemployment in minority communities.
Too many Americans are living in despair and hopelessness. Too many of our brothers and sisters are turning to drugs, alcohol and suicide to avoid the painful economic realities of their lives. Too many others are turning to rage and bigotry as they try to make sense of their declining standard of living.
At a time of hateful political division, a new president can bring our people together by leading and appointing an administration that will fight for working people. We need a secretary of treasury who is prepared to take on the greed and illegal behavior of Wall Street, not someone who comes from Wall Street or will leave office to go to Wall Street. We need a trade representative who understands that our current trade policies have failed, and that we must adopt a trade approach that represents workers and not the CEOs of large corporations. We need an attorney general who is prepared to vigorously enforce antitrust laws and prosecute bankers and corporate leaders who break the law.
This is a historic and pivotal moment in American history. Now is the time for our next president to rally the American people against Wall Street and corporate greed and stand up vigorously for the declining middle class.

Contribute to RSN
Become a Fan of RSN on Facebook and Twitter




Monday, March 21, 2016

Something pretty wild happened yesterday







Go to the Bernie Sanders' web site, donate what you can afford, let's do this TOGETHER! 
VOLUNTEER! Get Active! Get Involved! Phone bank.

Elect President Sanders and give him a PROGRESSIVE CONGRESS that represents ALL Americans, not corporations. 


Bernie Sanders for President

Something pretty wild happened when our campaign and the Clinton campaign filed FEC reports yesterday.

Yes, the overwhelming majority of money raised directly by the Clinton campaign in February came from big-dollar donations. Yes, a former hedge fund executive’s family gave millions of dollars to her super PAC. These things are to be expected by now.

But what we never expected was that our supporters, a large number of working Americans giving small amounts of money at a time, raised more than the Clinton campaign. A lot more … almost two times as much in direct contributions.

Now, the Clinton campaign has still raised more than us to date. But we are catching up. And when we do, that’s going to make it easier for us to run the margins we need to gain the delegate lead on June 7th. But that will only happen if supporters like you keep stepping up.

Add another contribution to our campaign by midnight tonight – ahead of our important primary and caucuses tomorrow night. It could make the difference.

Bernie likes to say that when people stand together, anything is possible. In this campaign, our supporters — giving small amounts of money — are taking on Wall Street, pharmaceutical interests, and people who profit from the destruction of the planet.

And we are winning. If we keep going, we can win this nomination.
Add your contribution now before Arizona, Idaho, and Utah vote or caucus tomorrow. 

All my best,
Jeff Weaver
Campaign Manager
Bernie 2016





Paid for by Bernie 2016
(not the billionaires)
PO Box 905 - Burlington VT 05402 United States - (855) 4-BERNIE



Sunday, February 28, 2016

RSN: Does Mitch McConnell Really Give a Damn About the Supreme Court?



Mitch McConnell. (photo: Kevin Lamarque/Reuters)
Mitch McConnell. (photo: Kevin Lamarque/Reuters)

Does Mitch McConnell Really Give a Damn About the Supreme Court?

By Michael Winship, Moyers & Company
27 February 16

Ideology has never been as important to the Senate majority leader as power.

any years ago, I worked on a documentary about the how and why of political TV ads. The primary focus was on two media consultants: the late Bob Squier, a Democrat; and Bob Goodman, Republican.
One ad of which Goodman was especially proud was for a fellow in Kentucky running against Todd Hollenbach, Sr., the incumbent judge/executive of Jefferson County. Produced in 1977, the spot featured a farmer complaining about taxes that he claimed Judge Hollenbach had raised and then lied about.
As he mucked out a barn and his faithful horse whinnied, the farmer declared, “Maybe Hollenbach ought to have my job, because in my business, I deal with that kind of stuff every day.”
Then he threw a shovel of manure right at the camera.
Hollenbach lost to the candidate who approved this message: Mitch McConnell.
McConnell has been shoveling it ever since, but perhaps never as stunningly as on Tuesday, when he spoke from the floor of the US Senate. The now-majority leader of the so-called greatest deliberative body in the world blustered, as he has several times in the last couple of weeks, that Senate Republicans would never, ever consider an appointment by President Obama to replace the still-dead Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.
The president, McConnell then said, “has every right to nominate someone, even if doing so will inevitably plunge our nation into another bitter and avoidable struggle.”
Excuse me, Senator, the bitter and undeniably avoidable struggle was created by you on the Saturday that Scalia’s corpse was found. The body was barely cold when you crassly announced that the duly-elected President of the United States should not name the judge’s successor but must leave it to the next president – more than 300 days from now.
McConnell continued, “Even if he never expects that nominee to be actually confirmed but rather to wield as an election cudgel, he certainly has the right to do that.” Again, Senator, it’s you who is wielding the blunt object.
And then the majority leader had the chutzpah, as they say down home in his Bluegrass State, to add that Barack Obama also “has the right to make a different choice. He can let the people decide and make this an actual legacy-building moment rather than just another campaign roadshow.”
Oh brother, look who’s talking. Of all the pompous, insincere bloviation; ignoring courtesy, tradition – let alone the US Constitution – in the name of Senator McConnell’s own misbegotten ambitions.
Psychiatrists call this “projection,” the defensive method by which people take their own negative beliefs or feelings and attribute them to someone else – otherwise known as shifting blame. In McConnell’s case, add to it a megadose of the cynical manipulation and crass opportunism characteristic of most of his political career.
Not that it was always so. McConnell began his political life as a liberal Republican – remember them? — interning for legendary Kentucky senator and statesman John Sherman Cooper. He supported the Equal Rights Amendment and collective bargaining. Friends say he was pro-Planned Parenthood and he even wrote an op-ed piece in the Louisville Courier-Journal favoring campaign finance reform. Former McConnell press secretary Meme Sweets Runyon told Jason Cherkis and Zach Carter at The Huffington Post, “He was kind of a good-government guy. He thought the government could do good and could be a solution.”
But once Mitch McConnell got to Washington as an elected senator and the mood of the Republican Party shifted right, so did he. Delay and obstruction became stepping stones. At the same time, the man whoNew York Times columnist Gail Collins famously described as having “the natural charisma of an oyster,” developed a Jekyll-and-Hyde style of self-serving pragmatism – bashing government from Capitol Hill but using all of its perks to bolster support among his constituents.
Up until the tea party-led ban on earmarks a few years ago, McConnell played out this dichotomy across Kentucky. In Washington, he voted against a health care program for poor children. In Kentucky, he funneled money to provide innovative health services for pregnant women. In Washington, he railed against Obamacare. In Kentucky, he supported free health care and prevention programs paid for by the federal government without the hassle of a private-insurance middleman. This policy ping-pong may not suggest a coherent belief system, but it has led to loyalty among the GOP in Washington and something close to fealty in Kentucky. It has advanced McConnell’s highest ideal: his own political survival.
“McConnell’s hold on Kentucky is a grim reminder of the practice of power in America — where political excellence can be wholly divorced from successful governance and even public admiration,” theHuffington Post reporters continued. “The most dominant and influential Kentucky politician since his hero Henry Clay, McConnell has rarely used his indefatigable talents toward broad, substantive reforms. He may be ruling, but he’s ruling over a commonwealth with the lowest median income in the country, where too many counties have infant mortality rates comparable to those of the Third World. His solutions have been piecemeal and temporary, more cynical than merciful.”
And so it goes. “He privileges the scoreboard above all,” The New Yorker’s Evan Osnos wrote in 2014. “Asked about his ideological evolution, he explained simply, ‘I wanted to win.’”
Tailoring his positions to adjust to the shifting seasons, what sets Mitch McConnell apart is that his motives aren’t really ideological but so baldly about holding onto personal power. His opposition to Obama’s naming of a Scalia replacement puts the majority leader in solid with the far-right Republicans he purportedly so dislikes but who have threatened his job security over the last few years, both at home and in DC.
What’s more, McConnell is desperate to keep a conservative majority on the Court to preserve the unbridled flow of campaign cash that the Citizens United decision let loose and that he so successfully has tapped for himself and the GOP. Unlike the young man who penned that campaign finance reform op-ed back in Louisville, fundraising has become his favorite thing, and he’s scary good at it. As his former Republican Senate colleague Alan Simpson said, “When he asked for money, his eyes would shine like diamonds. He obviously loved it.”
And even if a Democrat holds onto the White House next year, chances are McConnell – the man who once said that the most important thing was to make Barack Obama a one-term president — will still play a power broker role in determining which Supreme Court candidate will successively run the 60-vote supermajority gauntlet needed for Senate approval. It’s good to be king.
But if he wants us all to wait for a Republican president to choose the next appointment to the Court, he might want to think twice. Donald Trump bows before no man – just ask him — and he shovels muck even better than that farmer who helped Mitch McConnell win his first public office.

Amir Parvez said it all!




Amir Parvez added 67 new photos to the album: Bernie Sanders / Elizabeth Warren 2016 — with Bernie Sanders and 3 others.

"The problems we face, did not come down from the heavens.
They are made, they are made by bad human decisions,
and good human decisions can change them.
The greed of the billionaire class has got to end and we are going to do it for them. I don’t represent the big-money interests and I don’t want their money.
What kind of nation are we when we give tax breaks to billionaires, but we can't take care of the elderly and the children?
We have billions to spend on war but no money to take care of the very pressing needs of the American people. That bothers me a lot.
Children should not go hungry in this country while profitable corporations and the wealthy avoid their tax responsibilities.
Education must become affordable to all.
Health care should be a right, not a privilege.
Nobody who works 40 hours a week should be living in poverty.
I got into politics not to figure out how to become President.
I got into politics because I give a damn. And that's why I'm fighting for change.
I believe that at the end of the day when people come together,
when people are united there is nothing, nothing, nothing that can stop us."
"I don't take money from big banks. I don't get personal speaking fees from Goldman Sachs. Secretary Clinton has received over $600,000 from Goldman Sachs in one year, and she is not the only one.
Goldman Sachs has given this country two secretaries of treasury, one on the Republicans, one under Democrats. The leader of Goldman Sachs is a billionaire who comes to Congress and tells us we should cut Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.
Congress is not listening to the American people. It's listening to the Big Money and Big Pharma interests.
Citizens United gave billionaires like the Koch Brothers an even bigger opportunity to purchase the House, the Senate, even the White House. Super PACs are enabling the wealthiest people and the largest corporations in this country to spend unlimited amounts on elections.
We have a campaign finance system that is corrupt, we have super PACs, we have the pharmaceutical industry pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into campaign contributions and lobbying, and the private insurance companies as well.
We've got to bring back the 21st century Glass-Steagall legislation and we've got to break up these huge financial institutions. They have too much economic power and they have too much financial power over our entire economy. We need to end Citizens United.
The CEOs of large multinationals may like Hillary. They ain't going to like me and Wall Street is going to like me even less."
“We have a problem: money. Our system of elections is riddled with corruption. Money floods our political system, money that lets a handful of billionaires shape who gets into Congress and may decide who sits in the White House.
But that does not mean that anyone with any integrity must roll over and play dead. This congress doesn't lack for workable ideas for how to root out the influence of money in politics. This congress just lacks a spine to do it.
Six years ago the Supreme Court turned loose a flood of hidden money that is about to drown our democracy. We can blame the Supreme Court, heck we should blame the Supreme Court. But that is no excuse for doing nothing.
A new presidential election is upon us. The first votes will be cast in Iowa in just a few days. Anyone who shrugs and claims it is too hard has crawled into bed with the billionaires who want to run this country like some private club.
All of us were sent here to do our best to make government work, to make it work not just for those at the top but to make government work for all people. And it's time we start acting like it.”
- U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren
"Ever since Donald Trump has been opening his mouth, you're seeing all these bitter people, demagogues, latent racists who are becoming emboldened. You're seeing some ugly stuff happening around this country. I know you`re angry. And you know what? You should be angry because you`re working longer hours for low wages.
We've got millions of people who are in trouble today. They are fearful. They’re confused. They are anxious on a number of levels. We have people with two or three jobs, worried to death about their children, worried about their own retirement. The cost of everything, from college tuition to prescription drugs, has gone up and people aren’t getting paid a living wage.
People are hurting, they’re struggling, and no one is talking about it. They want something to be able to stand up and fight for. That`s what I believe the antidote is to Trumpism.
What’s the cause of their problems? What does it mean that 58 percent of all new income in America is going to the top 1 percent?Who is your enemy? Is it Wall Street? Is it Big Money? Is it massive inequality in terms of wealth and income?
Well, no one talks about that really. Why do you keep voting for people who are giving more tax breaks to billionaires, who are going to send your jobs abroad, not going to let you form a union, not going to allow your kids to go to college?
Because they pick out a victim whether it`s Blacks, whether it`s gays, whether it`s women, whether it`s immigrants, whether it`s Muslims who we can pick on.
We can't allow racism and xenophobia to gain traction. You want decent jobs. You want your kids to have an opportunity. We’re going to fight to give you that.
Don’t go to the dark side. Don't take it out on the Muslims or Latinos. Don’t go bashing immigrants or refugees. We've got to stand with those people who are being attacked today. We’ve got to stand up to the people who are so angry, who are so hateful.
Try to help us work together to create a country where your kids and you can have a decent standard of living. It has to be a bold and radical agenda, a political movement that will make your life better, not just other people's lives worse."
- Bernie Sanders
Don't #MakeAmericaHateAgain
WHEN YOU & YOUR FAMILY/FRIENDS DON'T VOTE, REPUBLICANS WIN!
Many of you have few days left to register and vote Democrat for Bernie Sanders. Please make sure you do that.
Remember that all the ignorant Republicans are going to vote in huge numbers 'religiously' because most of them think their 'God' wants them to vote for the 'not so Republican' GOP morons.
Voting for HILLARY CLINTON would mean choosing Government Of the Rich, By the Corrupt, For the Corporations.
BERNIE SANDERS is a real Social Democrat.
=>Government Of the People, By the People, For the People
Choosing her over Sanders is like choosing the status quo... the same mess and unfair system that won't change anything.
It doesn't take rocket science to understand that corporations invest into politicians like Hillary only for profits and favors at the expense of our interests.
To the feminists who support her just because she is a woman... You don't need a female president but a feminist president who understands women's issues. And that would be Bernie. Clinton just doesn't care.
The GOP, Hillary Clinton, her billionaire/Wall Street friends, DNC, Media and all corrupt politicians and corporations will try their best to sabotage Bernie Sanders' political revolution. We the People must not let that happen. We cannot ignore this real, just war against the oligarchy destroying/controlling our lives and the world.
Media and DNC are against Bernie Sanders. Make sure you educate the people in your life about Bernie Sanders and and Social Democracy. Make them vote Sanders!
"There is a secret to being a supporter of Bernie Sanders. It is something that totally escapes the thinking of most Democrats and Republicans. It is the mental understanding that Sanders is fighting a war that most people are not. It is the war between corporations and the people. Unless you are fighting this war as well, you cannot possibly understand how important it is to vote for Bernie over Hillary. This is not about Hillary or Bernie, it is about fighting your real enemies, the multi-national corporations who are trying to control this nation and the world. You ignore this war at your own peril."
"The illusion of democracy is an insult to our intelligence.
The world is being taken over by a handful of business powers who dominate the natural resources we need to live, while controlling the money we need to obtain these resources. The end result will be world monopoly based not on human life but financial and corporate power. Corruption is not some by-product of capitalism, it is its very foundation.
Efficiency, sustainability, and abundance are enemies of profit. It is the mechanism of scarcity that increases profit. War, poverty, corruption, hunger, misery, human suffering will not change in a monetary system.
The last thing the men behind the curtain want is a conscious informed public capable of critical thinking. They seek to keep you in a distracted, naive bubble. And they are doing a damn good job of it.
You have to know the truth and seek the truth and the truth will set you free. It's time to claim the unity and work together to create a sustainable global society, where everyone is taken care of and everyone is truly free."
-Jacque Fresco
“If those in charge of our society - politicians, corporate executives, and owners of press and television - can dominate our ideas, they will be secure in their power. They will not need soldiers patrolling the streets. We will control ourselves.
Our problem is civil obedience. Our problem is that people all over the world have obeyed the dictates of leaders and millions have been killed because of this obedience. Our problem is that people are obedient all over the world in the face of poverty and starvation and stupidity, and war, and cruelty. Our problem is that people are obedient while the jails are full of petty thieves and the grand thieves are running the country. That’s our problem.
The challenge remains. On the other side are formidable forces: money, political power, the major media. On our side are the people of the world and a power greater than money or weapons: the truth. We live in a beautiful country. But people who have no respect for human life, freedom, or justice have taken it over. It is now up to all of us to take it back.”
-Howard Zinn
#Bernie2016 #FeelTheBern #WeAreBernie #NotMeUs #BernieOrBust #WeEndorseBernie

Monday, February 22, 2016

RSN: From Scalia to Obama, What Rule of Law?



Tradition or guilt mandates polite behavior is not to speak ill of the dead. 

Antonin Scalia did more damage to Democracy than any, was Bought & Sold....may have been jovial and worshiped by the Wack-A-Ding extremists.....but did the greatest disservice to our Nation as history will reflect. 

Much will be written....

History will not be kind! 






RSN Godot Logo
Reader Supported News | 22 February 16

You Can Feel Us Pressing to Finish
The urgency is not lost on anyone. Yes, for sure “today” will make huge difference in terms of when we finish this fundraiser.
Can you help - “today.”
Marc Ash 
Curator, Reader Supported News

If you would prefer to send a check: 
Reader Supported News 
PO Box 2043 
Citrus Hts 
CA 95611


It's Live on the HomePage Now: 
Reader Supported News

FOCUS: Steve Weissman | From Scalia to Obama, What Rule of Law? 
Barack Obama and Antonin Scalia. (photo: AFP/Getty Images) 
Steve Weissman, Reader Supported News 
Weissman writes: "In significant sections of our political economy, the rule of law operates as it should, allowing people to know what the rules are and to see them fairly enforced. But, like the myth of free markets, paeans to the rule of law - sincere, self-serving, or ceremonial - too often mask the naked exercise of power." 
READ MORE

or almost 30 years, Justice Antonin ‘Nino’ Scalia was a larger-than-life presence on the bench – a brilliant legal mind with an energetic style, incisive wit, and colorful opinions,” declared President Barack Obama. “Justice Scalia dedicated his life to the cornerstone of our democracy: The rule of law.”
High praise indeed – and completely bogus, especially from a commander-in-chief who acts as judge, jury, and (by proxy) executioner for drone targets around the world, and a POTUS who refused to bring criminal indictments against the Wall Street bankers who created the global economic crash in 2008.
Rule of law? Would you like me to sell you a nice bridge in Brooklyn?
In significant sections of our political economy, the rule of law operates as it should, allowing people to know what the rules are and to see them fairly enforced. But, like the myth of free markets, paeans to the rule of law – sincere, self-serving, or ceremonial – too often mask the naked exercise of power. They also trash the once-sacrosanct ideal that no one – rich or poor, black or white, government official or private citizen – stands above the law.
Even before Ronald Reagan named him a federal judge and then Supreme Court justice, Antonin Scalia added dramatically to this legal hocus pocus when, in 1982, conservative and libertarian law students at Harvard, Yale, and the University of Chicago created the Federalist Society. Scalia served as one of the faculty advisors, along with his friend and long-time colleague Robert Bork.
The right-wing activists opposed liberal judicial approaches that had enlarged the federal government, reduced states' rights, and created “privacy rights” that the Constitution had never explicitly sanctioned. They hated legalized abortion and federal intervention to protect African-Americans, and they favored “traditional values,” unfettered campaign contributions, and an unrestrained right to bear arms. Presenting themselves as “strict constructionists” defending the true meaning of the Constitution, the Federalists framed their fight as a response to “judicial activism.” They insisted that the judiciary “say what the law is, not what it should be.”
Increasingly persuasive as American voters swung to the right, these arguments helped the Federalists become the country’s single most influential group of legal intellectuals. They essentially follow two overlapping schools of thought – or claim to. On the Constitution and its amendments, they base their decisions, they say, on the original intent of the framers and subsequent authors. The appeal is obvious. The Federalists appear to offer an objective way to make Constitutional decisions, which they contrast to the unavoidably subjective judgments of liberal judges and justices seeking to adapt what they call “a living Constitution” to situations that James Madison and John Adams could never have conceived of.
“It’s not a living document,” Scalia insisted. “It’s dead, dead, dead.”
Well, not quite. Take a look at Scalia’s classic 2011 interview in the California Lawyer. “In 1868, when the 39th Congress was debating and ultimately proposing the 14th Amendment, I don't think anybody would have thought that equal protection applied to sex discrimination, or certainly not to sexual orientation,” said the interviewer. “So does that mean that we've gone off in error by applying the 14th Amendment to both?”
“Yes, yes. Sorry, to tell you that,” replied the effervescent Scalia. “Nobody ever thought that that’s what it meant. Nobody ever voted for that. If the current society wants to outlaw discrimination by sex, hey we have things called legislatures, and they enact things called laws. You don’t need a constitution to keep things up-to-date. All you need is a legislature and a ballot box. You don’t like the death penalty anymore, that’s fine. You want a right to abortion? There’s nothing in the Constitution about that. But that doesn’t mean you cannot prohibit it. Persuade your fellow citizens it’s a good idea and pass a law. That’s what democracy is all about. It’s not about nine superannuated judges who have been there too long, imposing these demands on society.”
Scalia appeared to be offering a principled and unfailingly democratic defense of Originalism. How then could he have joined in the majority decision in Bush v. Gore, which cited the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause to override the voters of Florida and make George W. Bush president?
In 2011, journalist Robert Parry pointedly answered the question. He called Scalia a hypocrite. It’s difficult to disagree. But “Originalism” has hypocrisy built-in. Too often, neither historians nor lawyers know what all the different authors of any particular passage intended or how to weigh their differences. It’s largely guesswork and often – though not always – depends on the results a particular judge or justice wants.
“Judges are not competent historians,” explains circuit court judge Richard A. Posner, a Reagan appointee and one of the country’s leading legal authorities. “To put to a judge a question that he cannot answer is to evoke ‘motivated thinking,’ the form of cognitive delusion that consists of credulously accepting the evidence that supports a preconception and of peremptorily rejecting the evidence that contradicts it.”
Others may suggest a more straightforward view of how Scalia interpreted the ineptly drafted Second Amendment: “A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” Did the framers intend the militia clause to restrict the right to keep and bear arms? Or did they want to preserve militias, now the National Guard, and also preserve the ancient English right for individuals to keep and bear arms? One can in all honesty read the text either way, and competent historians have no agreed-upon answer.
Scalia made his subjective preference clear in writing the majority decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, declaring that the Second Amendment guaranteed an individual’s right to possess a firearm for self-defense or any other legal purpose. Liberal law professors, like Laurence Tribe and Sanford Levinson, had reluctantly come to the same conclusion, while two conservative federal judges – Posner and J. Harvie Wilkinson – condemned Scalia’s decision as activist and highly political. This was precisely how he and they saw the liberal creation of privacy rights and legalization of abortion in Roe v. Wade. Leave both gun and abortion rights to the political process, Wilkinson and Posner argued.
A third case makes chopped liver of Scalia’s claim to “say what the law is, not what it should be.” In Citizens United, Scalia joined in the majority decision that the First Amendment guaranteed individuals and corporations the right to unlimited election spending.
University of Colorado law professor Paul Campos found this most instructive. “The men who drafted and ratified the First Amendment would have, it’s safe to say, been shocked out of their wits if someone had told them they were granting the same free speech rights to corporations they were giving to persons,” wrote Campos. “It would be hard to come up with a purer example of treating the Constitution as a ‘living document,’ the meaning of which changes as social circumstances change.”
Campos called Scalia “an intellectual phony.” That, too, would be hard to disagree with. I would only add that among the first to give prominence to the idea that money is speech were those activist liberals at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). Was their reasoning any more objective than Scalia’s? Was it any closer to the rule of law?
Contrary to much that’s been written, Scalia called himself “a faint-hearted Originalist.” Over time he leaned more to “textualism,” which focused narrowly on what specific laws and contracts say – and emphatically not on trying to figure out what the authors intended. This was an even more objective way to make judicial decisions, he insisted. But he was equally ideological about that. His textualism “tilts toward ‘small government’ and away from ‘big government,’ which in modern America is a conservative preference,” wrote Richard Posner in his trenchant critique of Scalia’s “incoherence.”
But Posner goes beyond pillorying Scalia. He tells a needed truth about how his colleagues play the judicial game, liberals as well as conservatives. “Judges like to say that all they do when they interpret a constitutional or statutory provision is apply, to the facts of the particular case, law that has been given to them,” he explained. “They do not make law: that is the job of legislators, and for the authors and ratifiers of constitutions. They are not Apollo; they are his oracle. They are passive interpreters. Their role is semantic.”
Posner does not buy the pretense, not from Scalia or from any other judge or justice, left, right, or center. Neither should anyone else.
“Judges,” he wrote, “tend to deny the creative – the legislative – dimension of judging, important as it is in our system, because they do not want to give the impression that they are competing with legislators, or engaged in anything but the politically unthreatening activity of objective, literal-minded interpretation, using arcane tools of legal analysis.”
Rule of law? No, the rule of lawyers, with undeniable ideological, political, and experiential bias. This honest understanding should govern how the country chooses Scalia’s replacement and all the judges and justices to follow.


A veteran of the Berkeley Free Speech Movement and the New Left monthly Ramparts, Steve Weissman lived for many years in London, working as a magazine writer and television producer. He now lives and works in France, where he is researching a new book, "Big Money and the Corporate State: How Global Banks, Corporations, and Speculators Rule and How to Nonviolently Break Their Hold."
Reader Supported News is the Publication of Origin for this work. Permission to republish is freely granted with credit and a link back to Reader Supported News.