Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). Show all posts

Friday, September 27, 2019

AG seeks overturn of Pilgrim license transfer




AG seeks overturn of Pilgrim license transfer


By Christine Legere
Posted Sep 26, 2019

Filing with federal appeals court asks that matter be sent back to NRC.
BOSTON — State Attorney General Maura Healey has filed a federal court appeal that seeks to vacate the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s order to transfer Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station’s license from Entergy Corp. to Holtec International, and its $1.1 billion trust fund along with it.
“The NRC has repeatedly rubber-stamped Holtec’s plans, despite serious concerns about the company’s financial capacity, technical qualifications and competency to safely decommission and clean up the Pilgrim site,” Healey said. “We are asking the court to exercise its authority to vacate the NRC’s misguided and unsupported actions.”
Pilgrim shut down permanently May 31 and is poised to be decommissioned. Entergy applied for the license transfer to Holtec in November. On Aug. 22, the NRC approved the request, along with an exemption for Holtec to use the decommissioning trust fund for nondecommissioning activities such as site restoration and spent fuel storage.
Entergy sold the plant to Holtec a few days after the transfer.
In the 103-page document submitted Wednesday, Healey’s general counsel, Seth Schofield, asks the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to vacate the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s “orders, findings and decisions and remand the matter back to the NRC for further proceedings.”
The court petition accuses the Nuclear Regulatory Commission of violating the Atomic Energy Act, National Environmental Policy Act and the agency’s own regulations by transferring Pilgrim’s license without providing “the Commonwealth with a meaningful opportunity to participate in the process.”
In February, the Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs and the attorney general’s office filed a petition to intervene in the NRC’s review of the requested license transfer. They questioned Holtec’s financial ability to decommission Pilgrim and called for a full environmental review of the reactor site before decommissioning. State officials also called for a public hearing.
“The Baker-Polito administration remains strongly committed to ensuring the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station is decommissioned in a manner that protects the safety of the public and environment and is supporting and assisting the attorney general’s lawsuit regarding the Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff’s approval of the license transfer prior to a ruling by the commission on the concerns raised by both the administration as well as the attorney general,” Energy and Environmental Affairs Secretary Secretary Kathleen A. Theoharides said Thursday.
A citizens group called Pilgrim Watch filed similar requests.
The petitions had yet to be acted on when the NRC approved the license transfer.
The NRC also denied a request made during the summer by the attorney general’s office to put the license transfer review on hold for 90 days to allow state officials and the plant owner time to reach a settlement agreement.
The day before the transfer approval, the attorney general sent a seven-page letter to the NRC questioning Holtec’s truthfulness, citing the company’s admission to bribery of a Tennessee Valley Authority employee in 2007. More recently, state officials in New Jersey froze a $260 million tax break secured by Holtec when they discovered the company had lied on its application, the attorney general said.
U.S. Sens. Edward Markey and Elizabeth Warren and U.S. Rep. William Keating, all Massachusetts Democrats, also weighed in, urging the NRC to hear from state officials and citizens groups before acting on the transfer request.
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s staff approved the license transfer despite never having taken action on the state’s petition to intervene.
Earlier this month, Healey made yet another attempt to have input, asking the NRC for a temporary stay on Pilgrim’s approved license transfer until the agency acts on her February petition to intervene.
Both the February motion and the September request remain pending, NRC spokesman Neil Sheehan said Thursday. The agency declined to comment on the federal court appeal.
Mary Lampert, president of Pilgrim Watch, praised the attorney general for filing the federal appeal.
“We could not agree more,” Lampert said. “In addition to depriving Pilgrim Watch and the commonwealth their right to participate in the process, NRC’s decisions endanger our health, safety and pocketbooks. We have full confidence that the attorney general’s office will prevail.”
Patrick O’Brien, spokesman for Comprehensive Decommissioning International, a joint company formed by Holtec and SNC Lavalin to decommission Pilgrim and several other plants, provided a written statement:
“The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has concluded that Holtec met the required regulatory, legal, technical and financial requirements to qualify as licensee. While we respect the petitioner’s rights to file legal motions, we are not going to comment on any specific legal motions or action.”









Thursday, April 18, 2019

Potential Pilgrim buyer may add to nuclear cleanup projects



Image result for massachusetts cape downwinders



Potential Pilgrim buyer may add to nuclear cleanup projects


By Christine Legere
Posted Apr 17, 2019

Holtec also seeks to acquire 3-reactor site in NY.
The company poised to buy Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station in Plymouth, along with two other plants, has announced its plan to also buy Indian Point Energy Center, a three-reactor site in New York.
If Holtec International receives authorization for the license transfers from federal regulators, the firm will own six reactors in four states, most of which it would then decommission simultaneously.
The process involves moving all the radioactive spent fuel generated by each reactor during operation into dry casks, dismantling and disposing of buildings and cleaning up contamination on the properties. The spent fuel must then be secured on-site until a federal repository has been constructed.
Holtec has promised to complete decommissioning at each of the plants in about eight years, instead of the 60-year time frame allowed by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Pilgrim, scheduled for permanent shutdown at the end of May, will be one of the first plants to be decommissioned. Although Holtec will hold the licenses of the plants it buys, it has contracted Comprehensive Decommissioning International, a new joint venture company between Holtec and SNC-Lavalin, to perform decommissioning.
The two other plants under agreement along with Pilgrim are Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station in New Jersey and Palisades Power Plant in Michigan.
In a written statement on the Indian Point purchase and decommissioning plan, CDI President Kelley Trice said the company would bring “a fleet approach to the decommissioning business.”
Although the company does not anticipate that all six reactors will be “in active decommissioning” at the same time, Holtec is confident it can manage simultaneous decommissioning projects, according to Joy Russell, the company’s senior vice president of business development and communications. “Each of Holtec’s decommissioning sites will have dedicated leadership,” she said.
“The on-site organizations will include incumbent plant staff who will be retained at license transfer, supplemented by experts in decommissioning and dismantling to fully round out successful and experienced teams at each site,” Russell said.
The lack of decommissioning experience on the part of Holtec and its new company CDI worries some officials and Pilgrim watchdogs.
“I don’t want Holtec to learn how to shave on our beard,” said Sean Mullin, a Plymouth businessman and chairman of the Nuclear Decommissioning Citizens Advisory Panel.
“It raises several questions on whether they have the qualified staff to do this,” Mullin said. “While they appear to be a qualified company, this is a new business venture on an accelerated time frame with multiple plants.”
Former state Sen. Daniel Wolf, a fellow member of the citizens decommissioning panel, agreed.
“I think everyone should be concerned they have adequate resources internally as a company to manage this and that regulatory oversight at the state and federal level have adequate resources as well,” Wolf said. “I’d love to see Holtec’s business plan.”
One of Indian Point’s three reactors shut down in the mid-1970s and was mothballed pending closure of the other two reactors. One of the remaining two will shut down in April 2020 and the other in April 2021. The sale of Indian Point to Holtec is expected to be completed in the third quarter of 2021.
As part of the deal, Holtec will take over the site, the spent nuclear fuel and the $1.85 billion in the decommissioning trust fund for the three reactors.
Pilgrim’s sale, currently under review by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, includes its $1.04 billion decommissioning fund.
Wolf pointed out the money in the funds — whether at Pilgrim or Indian Point — was put there by utility ratepayers.
“It is there to do decommissioning, not so there can be some opaque business venture,” he said.
During a meeting with Holtec last month, members of the citizens advisory panel were frustrated by the lack of answers to questions they had on the Pilgrim plant sale and decommissioning.
Holtec representative Andrea Steardis said the information they sought was proprietary or confidential.
“My concern is over their lack of candor and transparency on even the most basic details of the proposed transaction, like what they’re going to pay for the property,” Mullin said.
Diane Turco, president of the anti-Pilgrim activist group Cape Downwinders, had a warning for watchdogs of the Indian Point plant.
“Wait until the citizens in N.Y. attend meetings with Holtec where their questions will not be answered due to ‘proprietary’ issues,” she said via email. “Nonsense! Stakeholders whose communities will bear the brunt of ongoing safety concerns should have transparency and truth.”
Although the decommissioning panel was scheduled to meet Wednesday night, Holtec said its representatives could not attend and “reiterated it didn’t have any further information for us,” according to Mullin.
Mary Lampert, president of Pilgrim Watch, expressed concern over Holtec’s plan to decommission multiple plants, saying it “sounds like they’re biting off more than they can chew.”
“It shows that there is a lot of money to be made in decommissioning, especially if host states may be left with the bill,” she said.
Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey has petitioned to intervene in the review of Pilgrim’s license transfer, questioning whether Holtec can be held financially responsible if the trust fund runs out before decommissioning is completed.
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission also has requested assurance from Holtec that the company has the resources to clean up more than one plant at a time.
The news of the possible acquisition of Indian Point could strain those resources even further.
“Indian Point would be by far the largest of the sites they acquire,” NRC spokesman Neil Sheehan said. “That’s clearly a question we’ll be seeking answers to.”


Related content






https://www.capecodtimes.com/news/20190417/potential-pilgrim-buyer-may-add-to-nuclear-cleanup-projects?utm_source=SFMC&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=The%20Cape%20Cod%20Times%20daily%202019-04-18&utm_content=GTDT_CCT&utm_term=041819















Wednesday, April 3, 2019

Healey: Show us the money for Pilgrim decommissioning





Healey: Show us the money for Pilgrim decommissioning

By Christine Legere
Posted Apr 2, 2019

Attorney general files rebuttal in bid to intervene in nuclear plant’s sale.
BOSTON — In a forceful final pitch to intervene in the federal review of Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station’s sale and license transfer, Attorney General Maura Healey argues the plant’s prospective owner has not provided enough financial information for a transfer decision to be made.
Longtime owner Entergy Nuclear Operations is looking to sell the Plymouth plant to New Jersey-based Holtec International. The two have a license transfer request pending before the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
Pilgrim, a 46-year-old reactor and the only one remaining in Massachusetts, is set to power down permanently May 31.
Holtec proposes it will then dismantle the reactor and buildings, load the radioactive fuel rods from decades of operation into steel-lined cement casks and clean up the site, using a $1.03 billion decommissioning trust fund that comes with plant ownership. 
The company has promised an aggressive timeline, saying it can complete cleanup in about eight years. If the license transfer does not occur, Entergy plans to take 60 years to complete decommissioning.
Healey points out that Pilgrim will be the first plant Holtec decommissions, and the company intends to decommission other plants at the same time.
A license transfer to Holtec is under review for the Oyster Creek nuclear plant in New Jersey, and Holtec plans to take over the Entergy-owned Palisades plant in Michigan when it permanently powers down in 2022.
Healey is concerned that the $1 billion trust fund, the only source of funding identified in the transfer application to handle decommissioning and site cleanup activities at Pilgrim, will prove insufficient. A funding shortfall could put not just the wallets of Massachusetts residents on the line, but also their health and safety, the attorney general has argued.
She has requested a hearing so the public can weigh in before federal regulators make their final decision.
Healey filed her petition to intervene in February. Holtec and Entergy have since submitted arguments in opposition.
Healey was forceful in her rebuttal of their arguments Monday.
“The applicants oppose the Commonwealth of Massachusetts’ petition to intervene and for a hearing, based on a simple yet wholly misguided premise: trust us,” she wrote. “Trust that the Pilgrim decommissioning trust fund contains sufficient money for Holtec, on its first attempt to decommission and restore the site at a pace never previously achieved.”
Even after those tasks are completed, the fund must continue to cover the cost of storing the spent fuel on the site for decades, she noted.
The financial information Holtec submitted to federal regulators does not provide assurance that any funding sources beyond the decommissioning trust fund would be available if money runs short. Holtec Pilgrim and Holtec Decommissioning International, both limited liability corporations that would hold Pilgrim’s license after the transfer, have no assets listed.
“Its status as a limited liability company will make it extremely difficult, if not impossible, to reach beyond it to a parent entity to secure additional funding in the event of a shortfall,” the state official’s submission says.
And although nuclear plant owners have successfully sued the Department of Energy for failure to provide a national repository for spent fuel, Holtec has “carefully avoided making a regulatory commitment” to use the $500 million anticipated payment to cover a trust fund shortfall, the attorney general said.
In the initial petition to intervene, Healey and officials from other state agencies expressed concern that other contamination found during decommissioning might need cleaning up. Those unanticipated costs would strain the budget, they said.
Healey and the governor’s office also have asked for a closer look at the property under the National Environmental Policy Act as part of the license review.
Entergy and Holtec argue that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission does not require such study. Instead, the review relies on existing documents such as environmental assessments or supplemental environmental statements.
Holtec’s senior vice president for business development and communications provided a brief statement.
“We are aware of the Attorney General’s April 1st filing with the NRC,” said Joy Russell. “We respect the process and we believe we have made appropriate regulatory filings and responses and we stand behind the positions in those documents.”
Duxbury-based citizens group Pilgrim Watch is also looking to intervene, and made similar arguments in its filing with the NRC on Monday.
“We know that neither the present owners (Entergy), nor the prospective buyer (Holtec), has sufficient funds to decommission the site; and neither have performed the requisite thorough site assessment to have any understanding of all the contaminants on the site,” Mary Lampert, president of Pilgrim Watch, said via email. “Without the site analysis, they cannot judge how much it will cost to clean it up nor prevent runoff into Cape Cod Bay.
“Our goal in this litigation is to prevent having Massachusetts taxpayers left holding the bag after Pilgrim’s owner, either Entergy or Holtec (both limited liability companies), skip town leaving us a huge bill, a very dirty site, and tons of spent fuel to guard for the indefinite future,” Lampert said.
NRC spokesman Neil Sheehan said the submissions were under review.

Related content



https://www.capecodtimes.com/news/20190402/healey-show-us-money-for-pilgrim-decommissioning?utm_source=SFMC&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=The%20Cape%20Cod%20Times%20daily%202019-04-03&utm_content=GTDT_CCT&utm_term=040319




Image result for PILGRIM PROTEST



Pilgrim's plight

30 years ago, problems at the nuclear plant hinted at the future

http://gatehousenews.com/nuclearpower/pilgrims-plight/

Friday, March 22, 2019

Requests to intervene in Pilgrim sale challenged



Image result for ag maura healey

Requests to intervene in Pilgrim sale challenged


By Christine Leger
Posted Mar 20, 2019

Plant’s owner, potential owner ask regulators to reject speculation about decommissioning.
The current owner of Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station and the company looking to take over and decommission the plant after it shuts down have asked federal regulators to reject requests from state officials and the Pilgrim Watch citizens group to intervene in the review of the plant’s sale and license transfer.
Pilgrim, the only nuclear plant still operating in Massachusetts, is set to permanently shut down May 31.
Plant owner Entergy Corp. and prospective owner Holtec International submitted a transfer-of-license request to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission in November. Under the terms of the transfer, Holtec would take over the nuclear reactor for decommissioning and the 1,500-acre site.
As part of the deal, Holtec also would get Pilgrim’s $1.03 billion fund to cover decommissioning costs, management of 4,100 radioactive spent fuel rods and site cleanup.
If the plant does not change hands, Entergy has said it would stretch the decommissioning of Pilgrim over 60 years. Holtec said it would get the work done in eight years.
In a request to intervene in the license transfer filed last month, Attorney General Maura Healey cited concerns that money might run out before decommissioning was completed and that the environmental study required before the start of plant decommissioning was inadequate.
Pilgrim Watch filed similar concerns as its reason to intervene.
Both were looking for hearings.
“We’re intervening to protect the public and ensure the transaction does not leave our state’s taxpayers on the hook for any of the costs,” Healey wrote in a statement last month.
In its calculations, Holtec had estimated it could complete decommissioning and site restoration with $3.6 million to spare. State officials said the margin did not allow for unanticipated events such as the discovery of previously unknown radiological and nonradiological contamination, a radiological incident during transfer of spent fuel to dry casks for storage, a future requirement from the Department of Energy to repackage the spent fuel before transport to a federal repository, and other money-draining possibilities.
In their joint request that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission deny the petitions, Entergy and Holtec say the state relies on speculation rather than facts in its petition.
“The Commonwealth merely speculates regarding various possibilities that could affect (Holtec’s) decommissioning cost estimate for Pilgrim,” the joint response says. The companies add the state’s arguments related to financial risk “lack adequate support and fail to raise any genuine material dispute” to the application for license transfer.
Holtec further points out its decommissioning cost estimate contains a 17 percent contingency — about $165 million.
Entergy and Holtec also address the state’s contention that an expanded environmental review should be done before decommissioning, saying the Nuclear Regulatory Commission does not require such study. Instead, the review relies on existing documents such as environmental assessments or supplemental environmental statements.
“We believe the transfer of Pilgrim from Entergy to Holtec for prompt, safe and efficient decommissioning is the best outcome for all stakeholders, including the Commonwealth and the Town of Plymouth,” Entergy spokesman Patrick O’Brien said via email.
The attorney general was successful in securing an extension of the March 25 deadline to reply to Entergy’s and Holtec’s response to April 1. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has granted the same extension to Pilgrim Watch.
The five-member commission will then review the requests to intervene and consider the arguments against them.
If a hearing is granted, it could take place in front of the full commission, a designated member or an appointed hearing officer.

Related content


https://www.capecodtimes.com/news/20190320/requests-to-intervene-in-pilgrim-sale-challenged?utm_source=SFMC&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=GHM_Daily_Newsletter_Cape_Cod_Times&utm_content=GTDT_CCT&utm_term=032119





Wednesday, February 27, 2019

State sounds alarm over sale of Pilgrim for decommissioning


State sounds alarm over sale of Pilgrim for decommissioning

By Bob Salzberg, Associated Press 
Posted Feb 21, 2019

BOSTON — Massachusetts officials raised major concerns Wednesday about Entergy’s proposed sale of the soon-to-be-closed Pilgrim nuclear power plant in Plymouth to another company for decommissioning.
In a motion filed with the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Democratic Attorney General Maura Healey and Republican Gov. Charlie Baker’s administration asked that the state be allowed to intervene in the federal review of the pending deal, citing health, safety and financial risks associated with the planned transfer of Pilgrim’s license to a New Jersey-based subsidiary of Holtec International.
Specifically, Healey and state Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs Matthew Beaton argue that Entergy and Holtec have failed to demonstrate that sufficient financial resources exist to safely decommission the plant and provide for the long-term storage of spent nuclear fuel at the site.
The state’s only remaining nuclear plant, which began operations in 1972 and has a spotty safety record, is slated for permanent shutdown by June 1. In documents filed last year with the NRC, Holtec said it would undertake an “accelerated decommissioning” of the facility, shortening the timeframe for cleanup and restoration of the site from the original estimate of 60 years to just eight years.
“While (Massachusetts) welcomes the possibility of a properly conducted and expedited cleanup and restoration of Pilgrim, the risk of a funding shortfall and the attendant significant health, safety, environmental, financial and economic risks to (Massachusetts) and its citizens raise serious questions about the realization of that benefit,” state officials wrote.
The petition stops short of asking the NRC to block the sale, but suggests the agency should not allow it to go forward as currently proposed. The state is also seeking a public hearing to air its concerns.
In a statement, Entergy said it was reviewing the state’s filing.
“We believe the transfer of Pilgrim to Holtec for prompt and safe decommissioning is the best option for Plymouth and the Commonwealth of Massachusetts,” the company said.
An after-hours message left with a spokeswoman for Holtec was not immediately returned.
The proposed sale, announced last summer, also includes the Entergy-owned Palisades nuclear plant in Covert, Michigan, which is expected to close in 2022.
The decommissioning process involves radiological decontamination, removal of spent fuel and dismantling of the reactor and physical plant. While Holtec believes those steps could be completed within eight years, the spent fuel may remain in casks stored near the Pilgrim site for decades since the federal government has yet to approve a national long-term nuclear waste storage facility.
Nuclear plants are required by the NRC to maintain special trust funds to pay for decommissioning. Holtec has said the slightly more than $1 billion available in Pilgrim’s trust fund would be sufficient to cover costs, but with only $3.6 million to spare — a cushion that critics say is too small to cover unanticipated expenses and that could leave Massachusetts taxpayers on the hook for overruns.
A citizen’s advocacy group, Pilgrim Watch, also filed a motion to intervene on Wednesday, citing similar concerns as those expressed by state officials.
“The actual cost of decontaminating and restoring the Pilgrim site will be more, probably far more, than Holtec has estimated,” the group wrote.

https://plymouth.wickedlocal.com/news/20190221/state-sounds-alarm-over-sale-of-pilgrim-for-decommissioning


Friday, August 24, 2018

Pilgrim nears temperature cap



Pilgrim nears temperature cap





Reactor at reduced power as winds, warm water challenge cooling operations.
PLYMOUTH — Northeasterly winds have been pushing warm water released from Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station’s reactor beyond a breakwater and into a sheltered area where 500 million gallons are drawn each day to cool operational systems, according to a spokesman for plant owner-operator Entergy Corp.
Bay water being used for cooling may not exceed 75 degrees under Pilgrim’s federal operating license, and the warm water migrating to the intake area is driving temperatures toward the federal cap.
If the intake water goes above 75 degrees, operators must begin shutdown procedures.
Pilgrim operators have lowered reactor power to between 42 and 50 percent since Sunday to avoid that scenario.


“They’re using reduced power to mitigate that,” said Neil Sheehan, spokesman for the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. “By reducing it to 43 percent, it reduces cooling demands.”
Pine duBois, executive director of the Jones River Watershed Association and well-known steward of Cape Cod Bay, said Pilgrim’s current problem is not surprising.
“The bay is pretty warm right now,” duBois said. “The ocean is being impacted by global warming, and the Gulf Stream current is warming and coming closer to our shore.”
That northeasterly wind would not only direct the hot outfall water into the intake area, it would drive debris from the bay into the screens used to prevent it from entering the cooling system, duBois said, creating one more challenge for plant operators.
Entergy spokesman Patrick O’Brien confirmed the “thermal backwash” used to clean the screens is currently being done, even though it had been done about a week ago.
The Pilgrim plant has been in operation since 1972, but it experienced intake temperatures at its allowed limit for the first time in its history in 2013. Temperatures exceeded the limit again in 2015 and 2016.
Several nuclear reactors are grappling with temperature problems, Sheehan said. Some have requested and been granted increases to the temperature limit for water being taken in.
“Pilgrim contemplated it,” Sheehan said. The company ultimately did not request a temperature increase. “They continue to be challenged at this time of year by warm water,” he said.
David Lochbaum, director of the nuclear safety program for the Union of Concerned Scientists, said it is likely too late for Pilgrim to ask to lift the temperature cap, as the plant is set to shut down permanently in June.
“Millstone and Turkey Point are nuclear plants using the same ocean as Pilgrim for cooling water,” Lochbaum wrote in an email. “Years ago, the owners of Millstone and Turkey Point noticed the rising ocean temperature and took steps for NRC to approve increased cooling water temperature limits.”
It has been a tough year financially for Pilgrim, and the extended power-down will not help.
The plant has been in full shutdown for 55 days since Jan. 1. Pilgrim generates an average of about $1.1 million in gross revenue per day and about $569,000 after all the bills are paid, based on figures from ISO-New England and data from SNL Energy, a data and analysis resource for the utility industry.

Related content