Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Paris Accord. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paris Accord. Show all posts

Monday, January 20, 2020

FOCUS: Is Joe Biden a Climate Radical Now?





Reader Supported News
20 January 20

We are reacting to a substantial drop-off in the number and size of donations. That equates to a significant slashing of RSN’s budget. Yes we have to address that. No choice.
The readership remains strong. That’s a good thing. If a reasonable number of the people coming to RSN donate we will be fine. So far for this month that hasn’t happened.
In earnest.
Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News


If you would prefer to send a check:
Reader Supported News
PO Box 2043
Citrus Hts
CA 95611




Reader Supported News
19 January 20
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News

Sure, I'll make a donation!

FOCUS: Is Joe Biden a Climate Radical Now?
Vice President Joe Biden. (photo: Joshua Lott/Getty)
Kate Aronoff, The New Republic
Aronoff writes: "Joe Biden may have stumbled into supporting one of the most radical climate proposals of the primary."

Calling for emissions-related sanctions is far cry from Obama-era policies.

oe Biden may have stumbled into supporting one of the most radical climate proposals of the primary.
The moment came in an interview, published Friday, with members of The New York Times’ Editorial Board, which has been conducting a series of sit-downs with Democratic primary candidates. After a rambling discussion of the recently-passed U.S. Mexico-Canada Agreement’s (USMCA) enforcement mechanisms (“I’ve not read them yet. O.K.?” Biden responded), New York Times writer Binyamin Appelbaum asked Biden if he thought “Democrats should vote for an agreement that does not affirm the Paris accord and does not contain any binding commitments to deal with climate change.” In essence, he was asking whether Democrats should vote for a deal like the USMCA, which many Democrats supported this past week in the Senate and Joe Biden backed on the campaign trail.
“Look,” Biden answered vaguely, “it’s like saying would you sign an agreement with Turkey on a base closure because it didn’t have that in it? It depends on if it’s related to climate. Absolutely they should be part of it.”
He pointed to China. “China, in fact, in their ‘Belt and Road’ proposal is in fact exporting more dirty coal around the world and is subsidizing more than anybody in the world.” That’s not all true. While China is by far the world’s largest greenhouse gas emitter and dominant coal producer, Australia is its top coal exporter. The United States is fourth. China is ninth. What Biden was likely referring to was China’s generous state subsidies for coal and large-scale financing of coal-fired power plants across multiple continents.
Fact-checks aside, Biden then tottered into an interesting, innovative thought that bears roughly zero resemblance to the trade agreement he was presumably defending:
[W]hat we should be saying to them is, you keep your agreement on the climate accord, which you signed up to. If you don’t, you will pay a price for it. You will not be able to sell product here. And organize the world to make sure that no, they couldn’t sell product anywhere. To make sure that they in fact have a requirement to stick to what they committed to.
When Appelbaum noted that Canada is a major fossil fuel exporter too, Biden remained resolute on this apparent proposal for sanctions on anyone not meeting Paris Agreement commitments: “That’s what we should be doing to everybody in the world.”
What about the United States? Were Biden’s principle of climate sanctions applied for all fossil fuels out of step with Paris Agreement goals (to which Biden pledged to recommit), such a rule would almost certainly place a major damper on U.S. fossil fuel production.
While this isn’t completely out of step with the policies outlined on Biden’s website, he hasn’t previously discussed many of the details of this part of his platform. Emphasizing the need to stop China in particular from “subsidizing coal exports and outsourcing carbon pollution,” Biden’s stated platform pledges to make any bilateral U.S.-China climate agreement contingent on their cutting fossil fuel subsidies and lowering the carbon footprint of Belt and Road projects. He would also impose border adjustment fees on carbon-intensive goods, preventing “other nations” from “undermining our climate efforts.”
Laudably, Biden’s platform further calls for eliminating fossil fuel subsidies across the G20. Yet experts say living up to the Paris goals will require more direct policies to stanch America’s domestic fossil fuel production, much of it destined for export. The Production Gap Report released this year by the UN Environment Program, Stockholm Environmental Institute, and several other research bodies finds that the world’s governments are on track to produce 50 percent more fossil fuels than is consistent with capping warming at 1.5 degrees Celsius, and 120 percent more than is consistent with a 2-degree rise. Another report by Oil Change International found that the U.S. is set to account for 60 percent of the global increase in oil and gas production between now and 2030—drilling plainly incompatible with the Paris Agreement’s goals of keeping warming “well below” 2 degrees Celsius.
The Times interview also represents a big departure from policies Biden has been associated with prior to the current election cycle. Domestic crude oil production increased by 77 percent during Biden’s time as Vice President, and the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) projects that it’ll reach record highs through 2021. That’s due in no small part to the lifting of the crude oil export ban under the Obama administration in 2015, which boosted the fossil fuel industry by opening up expansive new markets for its products.
“I’m glad to see Biden acknowledge trade in fossil fuels as a climate issue. There is some promise in using trade measures to bring fossil fuel production in line with climate limits. And of course that is not limited to coal from China, or oil from Canada,” Stockholm Environmental Institute US Senior Scientist Peter Erickson wrote to me in an email. “Shouldn’t that same logic be applied to oil and gas exports from the U.S.?”
Were Biden to faithfully follow his commitment to the Paris goals and plan as outlined to the Times, he would push for not only a rapid, managed decline of the fossil fuel industry, but the creation of a binding international trade regime with the power to materially discipline any nation—including the U.S.—failing to scale back emissions and carbon-intensive exports.
This would be a game-changer in American foreign policy, essentially upending the world order as we know it in the interest of building a low-carbon world. It would also be a far cry from his old boss’s approach. At a Shell and Chevron-sponsored gala last year for Rice University’s Baker Institute in Houston, Obama happily took credit for inconsistencies in his administration’s handling of climate issues. He said he was “extraordinarily proud of the Paris Accords” before bragging about how much oil his administration helped extract. “You wouldn’t always know it, but it went up every year I was president,” he exclaimed, referring to domestic oil production. “That whole, suddenly America’s like the biggest oil producer and the biggest gas—that was me, people.”

Update My Monthly Donation



Friday, January 3, 2020

Greg Palast and Zach D. Roberts | Hunting Season on Voters Opens with Georgia and Wisconsin Purges and Registration Cancellation






Reader Supported News
02 January 20
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News

Greg Palast and Zach D. Roberts | Hunting Season on Voters Opens with Georgia and Wisconsin Purges and Registration Cancellation
Greg Palast. (photo: Photo Grrrrr/Flickr)
Greg Palast and Zach D. Roberts, The Palast Investigative Fund
Excerpt: "Two new court decisions have blessed mass purges of voters in two swing states, Georgia and Wisconsin. This could be the launch of a new system for purging masses of voters of color and young voters that is expected to spread to 20 or more states before the Presidential election."
READ MORE

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, accompanied by Republican members of the Senate, speaking at a news conference in Capitol Hill in Washington DC, on November 16, 2016. (photo: Andrew Harnik/AP)
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, accompanied by Republican members of the Senate, speaking at a news conference in Capitol Hill in Washington DC, on November 16, 2016. (photo: Andrew Harnik/AP

The GOP Senators' Deliciously Awful Impeachment Dilemma
David R. Lurie, The Daily Beast
Lurie writes: "Some ask why 'moderate' Republican senators have largely refused to criticize Mitch McConnell's scheme to undermine the Constitution by preventing witnesses from testifying during Donald Trump's upcoming removal trial. But it's no mystery."
EXCERPT:
In fact, McConnell intends his machinations, first and foremost, to aid swing-state senators, particularly those facing re-election in 2020, like Maine’s Susan Collins, Arizona’s Martha McSally, North Carolina’s Thom Tillis, Iowa’s Joni Ernst, and Colorado’s Cory Gardner. Those legislators are facing a stark choice: If they fail to excuse Trump’s criminal conduct, they’ll  lose the support of their party’s Trump-loyal voters. 
But if they vote to acquit after figures like Mick Mulvaney and John Bolton further implicate the president in a scheme to undermine the next election (and an ally under attack by Vladimir Putin’s Russia), they risk losing the support of most other voters. It is a dilemma of Republicans’ own creation, and it’s becoming more excruciating every day.
Republican legislators have fashioned a Hobson’s choice for themselves. On the one hand, they can accede to Trump and McConnell by violating their oaths and the Constitution, and voting to dismiss without hearing from the embargoed witnesses—and take a risk that their knuckling under to Trump ends with ignominious losses in the next general election.
On the other hand, GOP “moderates,” possibly joined by more independent colleagues, such as Lisa Murkowski and the soon-to-be retired Lamar Alexander, can vote to call figures like Mulvaney and Bolton, and even vote in favor of conviction—thereby inviting primary challenges ginned up by Trump himself.
It is indeed a dilemma, but one of Republicans’ own creation, a product of their decision to do what it takes to maintain their party’s grip on power, regardless of the cost to the nation or its laws and Constitution. If the trial ends up making the corrupting consequences of that choice clearer to the nation, then maybe justice will be done after all, regardless of whether further witnesses appear, or of Trump’s virtually certain “acquittal.”

Democratic presidential candidate Julián Castro speaks in Las Vegas on Nov. 17, 2019. (photo: David Becker/Getty)
Democratic presidential candidate Julián Castro speaks in Las Vegas on Nov. 17, 2019. (photo: David Becker/Getty)

Julián Castro Drops Out of Presidential Race
Allan Smith, Maura Barrett and Suzanne Gamboa, NBC News
Excerpt: "Former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro dropped out of the presidential race Thursday after his campaign, focused on issues of immigration and education, failed to gain traction."
READ MORE

A Senate intelligence committee report in mid 2019 concluded that Kremlin hackers investigated election systems in all 50 states. (photo: Mark Makela/Reuters)
A Senate intelligence committee report in mid 2019 concluded that Kremlin hackers investigated election systems in all 50 states. (photo: Mark Makela/Reuters)

Cyber Attacks and Electronic Voting Errors Threaten 2020 Outcome, Experts Warn
Peter Stone, Guardian UK
Stone writes: "Potential electronic voting equipment failures and cyber attacks from Russia and other countries pose persistent threats to the 2020 elections, election security analysts and key Democrats warn."
READ MORE

Mark Collie and his son Blake at home in Washington, N.C. When Blake suffered an aneurysm, Mr. Collie turned to a Christian health cost-sharing ministry to help cover the costs. (photo: Madeline Gray/The New York Times)
Mark Collie and his son Blake at home in Washington, N.C. When Blake suffered an aneurysm, Mr. Collie turned to a Christian health cost-sharing ministry to help cover the costs. (photo: Madeline Gray/The New York Times)

It Looks Like Health Insurance, but It's Not. 'Just Trust God,' Buyers Are Told.
Reed Abelson, The New York Times
Abelson writes: "More than one million Americans, struggling to cope with the rising cost of health insurance, have joined such groups, attracted by prices that are far lower than the premiums for policies that must meet strict requirements, like guaranteed coverage for pre-existing conditions, established by the Affordable Care Act."
READ MORE

Teacher, Dennis Jones, knocking wild rice in a canoe. (photo: Tara Houska/Al Jazeera)
Teacher, Dennis Jones, knocking wild rice in a canoe. (photo: Tara Houska/Al Jazeera)

A Voice From the Forest in the Corporate Boardroom
Tara Houska, Al Jazeera
Houska writes: "For the past hour or so, the civil society representatives sitting opposite the financiers rattled off the science of climate crisis. Charts, graphs, data tracking the self-destruction of humanity flashed across the screen."
READ MORE

Students gather at John Marshall Park, blocks from the U.S. Capitol, to protest climate change on Sept. 20. (photo: Astrid Riecken/The Washington Post)
Students gather at John Marshall Park, blocks from the U.S. Capitol, to protest climate change on Sept. 20. (photo: Astrid Riecken/The Washington Post)

The 2010s Were a Lost Decade for Climate. We Can't Afford a Repeat, Scientists Warn.
Sarah Kaplan, The Washington Post
Kaplan writes: "By the final year of the decade, the planet had surpassed its 2010 temperature record five times."
READ MORE






Monday, December 30, 2019

Graham: Rudy Should Scrub Evidence for Russian Propaganda





Reader Supported News
30 December 19

We Are Not Doing Nearly as Well as Last Year
Year-end donations are down significantly from last year. Basic operating costs are not. Readership however is strong.
We understand that there are - a lot - of requests out there. Please don’t forget RSN.
In peace and solidarity.
Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News
Sure, I'll make a donation!

Update My Monthly Donation

If you would prefer to send a check:
Reader Supported News
PO Box 2043
Citrus Hts
CA 95611


Reader Supported News
30 December 19
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News


Graham: Rudy Should Scrub Evidence for Russian Propaganda
Rudy Giuliani. (image: Daily Beast)
Erin Banco and Asawin Suebsaeng, The Daily Beast
Excerpt: "'I wouldn't trust Rudy to represent me in a parking dispute so I'd say avoid,' one senior GOP Senate aide said when asked about any plans for a Ukraine briefing."
EXCERPT:
“Rudy Giuliani long ago lost any shred of credibility, especially after the dossier he assembled for the State Department stunningly mirrored Russian propaganda,” Sen. Bob Menendez (D-NJ) told The Daily Beast. “Knowing that, anyone that attempts to defend President Trump’s behavior by citing Rudy’s information over our own intelligence agencies is simply irresponsible, uninformed or willing to be that useful idiot the Kremlin desires.”
Giuliani has not briefed any Republican Senate leaders, including Senator Mitch McConnell (R-KY), according to two individuals with knowledge of the Senate leaders’ schedules.
“I wouldn’t trust Rudy to represent me in a parking dispute so I’d say avoid,” a senior GOP Senate aide said tersely when asked if it was a good idea for Republican senators to meet with Giuliani to get a Ukraine briefing. Another top aide in a different Republican office said their senator had informed staff that they had “no interest at all” in meeting with Giuliani on this, fearing it would amount to a “waste of time,” if not something worse.
And it’s not just Capitol Hill that’s worried about associating with Giuliani.
“I do not want my name showing up in a [news] story about what Rudy and the president discuss,” said one senior White House official. “I don’t want my text messages with [Giuliani] being all over cable news,” this official continued, referencing the incident when Trump’s personal lawyer went on Fox News and unveiled texts sent between him and Kurt Volker, the former U.S. special envoy to Ukraine. As The Daily Beast reported in early December, senior officials in the State Department and within the national security apparatus began worrying that Giuliani's ongoing crusade (which has been explicitly blessed and personally encouraged by President Trump) could hurt American foreign policy, and it even got to the point where these officials frantically devoted resources to tracking his foreign movements and figuring out who he was meeting with in Europe.
When asked about Sen. Graham’s recommendation to approach the intelligence community with his materials, and if he agreed that he should do so as due diligence, Giuliani would only reply to The Daily Beast, “It’s not Russian propaganda.”

Law enforcement vehicles are seen parked outside West Freeway Church of Christ as authorities continue to investigate a fatal shooting at the church on Sunday, in White Settlement, Texas. (photo: David Kent/AP)
Law enforcement vehicles are seen parked outside West Freeway Church of Christ as authorities continue to investigate a fatal shooting at the church on Sunday, in White Settlement, Texas. (photo: David Kent/AP)

Texas Church Shooter Kills 2 Before Being Fatally Shot by Congregants
Gabriela Saldivia, NPR
Saldivia writes: "A gunman opened fire during a church service Sunday morning in White Settlement, Texas, killing two people before two church members returned fire and killed him, authorities said."
READ MORE

Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi. (photo: Mohammed Al-Shaikh/Getty)
Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi. (photo: Mohammed Al-Shaikh/Getty)

Amy Goodman and Denis Moynihan | Let 2020 Be the Year to End the Murder and Imprisonment of Journalists
Amy Goodman and Denis Moynihan, Democracy Now!
Excerpt: "Beneath the grim statistic that 10 reporters were murdered in 2019 lies an important shift toward a public rejection of impunity for violence against journalists."
EXCERPT:
Similarly, in the wake of the murder of Jan Kuciak and his fiancee Martina Kusnirova, Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico resigned, and the Slovak businessman who is accused of ordering the murder, Marian Kocner, is finally set to stand trial almost two years later.
Justice for Jamal Khashoggi remains elusive. Agnes Callamard, the United Nations’ special rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, tweeted after the announcement of the Saudi convictions: “Bottom line: the hit-men are guilty, sentenced to death. The masterminds not only walk free, they have barely been touched by the investigation and the trial. That is the antithesis of Justice. It is a mockery.”
The Washington Post reported over a year ago that the CIA had concluded, on evidence that included intercepted phone calls, that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman ordered the killing. His close friendship with Donald Trump’s son-in-law and senior adviser, Jared Kushner has certainly contributed to the impunity he has so far enjoyed. One way to punish Saudi Arabia is through sanctions and denial of military aid — options that were open until just last week, when Congress passed, and sent to the White House for Trump’s signature, the $738 billion 2020 National Defense Authorization Act. Sen. Bernie Sanders and California Democratic Congressman Ro Khanna issued a joint statement calling the NDAA “a bill of astonishing moral cowardice,” in part for failing to deny aid to Saudi Arabia.
The role of a free press is to inform the public and to hold those in power accountable. We all have a responsibility to ensure that journalists are free to do their work, without threats of injury, imprisonment or death.

Yanis Varoufakis. (photo: Getty Images)
Yanis Varoufakis. (photo: Getty Images)

Yanis Varoufakis | Imagining a World Without Capitalism
Yanis Varoufakis, Project Syndicate
Varoufakis writes: "Anti-capitalists had a miserable year. But so did capitalism."
READ MORE

Jaime Hoffman. (photo: Jaime Hoffman/Daily Beast)
Jaime Hoffman. (photo: Jaime Hoffman/Daily Beast)

She Canceled a Football Game. That's When the Torment Began.
Emily Shugerman, The Daily Beast
Excerpt: "How a bungled football season turned into a war between the Occidental football team and its gay, female athletics director."
EXCERPTS:
Two years later [2014], in a report to the board of trustees, a task force led by Hoffman warned about the growing safety risks of the football team. The number of recruits had been shrinking for years—part of a larger national decline in high school football—leaving Occidental with fewer, smaller players from which to choose. While some had recommended shuttering the program altogether, the task force recommended increasing safeguards and keeping a close watch on the team’s standing. “Should the competitive level of the team create an unsafe environment,” the group wrote, “the administration is encouraged to intervene.”

The Tigers’ roster numbers continued to drop over the next several practices. By Sept. 14, two days before their next game, the team was down to 36 eligible players. The opposing team had 117. Hoffman called an emergency meeting with the college’s general counsel, head athletic trainer, head football coach, and President Jonathan Veitch. Together, she says, they decided to cancel the game.
“When it comes to a sport like football where someone can be paralyzed or someone can die, I have to be the parent in this situation,” Hoffman told The Daily Beast. “I have to make a responsible decision.”
In the months following, Hoffman floated between friends' and relatives’ houses, looking for a place to live and a permanent job. Because she was technically on “active unpaid status,” the college never offered her severance. But because she was, for all intents and purposes, fired, she struggled to find a job elsewhere. Lower-tier schools like Whittier and Laverne didn’t call her for interviews, and Claremont College—where she was previously a finalist for a similar role—didn’t even call her back. 
In September of last year, Hoffman filed a lawsuit against Occidental for gender discrimination, whistleblower retaliation, and failure to accommodate disability, among other things. She is asking for her job back and compensation for her emotional distress. But she also hopes the lawsuit spark larger, institutional change for women at Occidental and other NCAA schools. 
"This is a trend in athletics in higher ed,” she told The Daily Beast. “It's easier to get rid of the women.”

A Ukrainian war prisoner embraces his mother after being released following a prisoner exchange, near Odradivka, eastern Ukraine. (photo: Evgeniy Maloletka/AP)
A Ukrainian war prisoner embraces his mother after being released following a prisoner exchange, near Odradivka, eastern Ukraine. (photo: Evgeniy Maloletka/AP)

Ukraine, Pro-Russia Separatists Complete Controversial Prisoner Swap
Al Jazeera
Excerpt: "Ukrainian government forces and pro-Russian separatists in eastern Ukraine have completed a full prisoner swap, exchanging all remaining detainees of the five-year conflict, the Ukrainian presidency has said."
EXCERPT:
It said that 76 former pro-government prisoners had returned home, while separatist officials said the self-proclaimed Donetsk and Lugansk People's Republics took in a total of 124 people.
The exchange comes after Russian President Vladimir Putin and Ukrainian leader Volodymyr Zelenskyy held their first face-to-face talks in Paris on December 9 and agreed on some measures to de-escalate Europe's only active war.
The summit, mediated by the leaders of France and Germany, was the first of its kind in three years.
Reporting from Moscow, Al Jazeera's Aleksandra Godfroid said Zelenskyy faced criticism in Ukraine "from the very start" when he openly showed his willingness to hold talks with Putin. 
"Critics say he might have compromised too much," Godfroid said. "On the other hand ... he did win the elections by promising to end this conflict". 

The 'Give a Flake' campaign aims to turn skiers, snowboarders and other winter sports enthusiasts into climate policy advocates. (photo: Matt Powers/Aspen Snowmass)
The 'Give a Flake' campaign aims to turn skiers, snowboarders and other winter sports enthusiasts into climate policy advocates. (photo: Matt Powers/Aspen Snowmass)

Turning Skiers Into Climate Voters With the Advocacy Potential of the NRA
Judy Fahys, Inside Climate News
Fahys writes: "With rising global temperatures threatening to limit the skiing season and even warm some resorts out of existence, major ski companies are turning to their customers for help in the fight against climate change. Their goal: turn millions of snow-lovers into climate voters."
"The industry's much bigger, much more rabid, maybe more powerful and wealthy than the gun lobby, and yet we have no power," said Aspen Ski Co.'s Auden Schendler, pointing out that 10 million skiers logged about 59 million visits to U.S. resorts last winter.
"How do you mobilize that?" he asked. "Weaponize the outdoor community as a political movement."
That means venturing beyond the corporate sustainability campaigns already underway at resorts and ski companies, such as pressing local utilities to switch from coal to renewables, signing letters to policy makers and sending snow sport celebrities to lobby Congress.
Winter sports companies are now trying to mobilize those millions of skiers, snowboarders and other winter enthusiasts into a passionate political force for action on climate change by encouraging them to contact policy makers, vote for climate-friendly candidates and spread the word about climate change in their circles. The 2020 elections could become a proving ground for this new strategy to mix politics and play.
The winter sports industry knows it is facing an uncertain future.
One analysis, from a 2018 report by scientists with Climate Impact Lab, predicts that the number of days with below-freezing temperatures in Truckee, California, could shrink from 41 to 8 on average by the end of the century, and from 196 days to 141 at Stowe, Vermont. Rocky Mountain resorts, like Breckenridge and Taos, can expect their low-temperature days to decline by as much as one-third.
Another study, published in 2017, found that climate change will shorten the winter recreation season across the U.S., with half as many downhill skiing days in some places by 2050 and up to 80 percent fewer by 2090.
"We estimate these season-length changes could result in millions to tens of millions of foregone recreational visits annually by 2050, with an annual monetized impact of hundreds of millions of dollars," the study said. "Limiting global greenhouse gas emissions could both delay and substantially reduce adverse impacts to the winter recreation industry."
It's not just snow sports at risk. Mountain communities depend on agriculture, and mountain ecologies support wildlife, along with water storage for farmers, aquaculture, livestock and forestry.
Ski Resorts Have Started Cutting Their Own Emissions
Staring down that chilling reality, resorts have been focused so far on reducing their own carbon footprints.
At the climate-focused Mountain Towns Summit 2030 in Park City, Utah, this past fall, four major resort operators touted accomplishments like supplanting coal-fired power with renewables and adopting composting and recycling to reduce food waste at their lodges. But speaker after speaker conceded that resorts can't solve climate change on their own.
"Mountain towns are comprised of passionate citizens, vibrant businesses and natural splendor," and climate change threatens their economic stability, snowfall and way of life, local officials point out in a pact that was signed by more than 40 summit attendees, including government agencies, cities, counties, nonprofits and businesses.
"The climate crisis is the defining issue of our generation and must be addressed at all levels. As leaders in mountain communities, it is our obligation to address this issue in a bold, timely, and meaningful way," they wrote.
The signers pledged to be net-zero carbon emitters by 2030 and described steps they're taking to educate visitors about climate change and turn them into advocates for climate-friendly policies.
Laura Schaffer, sustainability director for Powdr, which operates the Snowbird resort in Utah and Killington Ski resort in Vermont, said visitors can expect to see more educational programs, such as one promoting sustainable behavior at the Killington ski school and the company's campaign to protect the environment so skiers can "play forever."
At Alterra Mountain Co. resorts, Sustainability Vice President David Perry said it's time to counter the climate change disinformation campaigns used by fossil-fuel companies and their supporters.
"They've changed a lot of minds to their disinformation campaign over a long period of time, and it's been incredibly effective," Perry said. "So we [ski companies] are on the back foot in a lot of these conversations. Guests are more receptive to communication when they're on vacation, and we are going to be taking advantage of that."
Getting Politicians to 'Give a Fl*ke' About Climate Change
Aspen decided years ago that the risk of driving away some customers wasn't nearly as threatening as climate change, and it has become the industry leader in climate outreach. On chairlifts, guests might find a quote from Pope Francis about the need to reduce the human harm to the climate. Throughout the Aspen Snowmass resort, staff members have been trained to talk about climate change and the threat it poses to winter recreation
There's also "Give A Flake," Aspen's marketing campaign to turn winter sports enthusiasts into climate policy advocates with easy-to-share social media messages and postcards that praise politicians who #GiveAFlake about climate change—and needle those who don't. In 2018, "Give A Flake" was responsible for a million postcards targeting three swing-state Republican senators who, while they don't reject climate science, "haven't really done anything" about it, in Schendler's view.
Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, who leads the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee and has been one of the few Republicans willing to talk about climate change concerns, hosted climate solutions hearings last spring, just months after being targeted by a "Give A Flake" campaign that criticized her record. When "Give A Flake" ran an ad in Outside Magazine targeting her the previous fall, she responded and got into a public exchange with Schendler in letters to the magazine over her climate record.
Aspen visitors also see the "Protect Our Winters" logo on employee uniforms, which refers to an athlete-led climate-action nonprofit that's been breaking trail for the winter sports community's public engagement effort for more than a decade.
'We Can Turn Our Passion Into Purpose'
POW previously used a more traditional approach to raising awareness about climate change. To spur fans to become more politically active, snow sport stars like POW founder and professional snowboarder Jeremy Jones have testified before Congress and are featured in videos urging outdoor recreationists to get political about climate change.
This year, POW has a strategic plan to get out the vote, with an eye on more than 34 million Americans who identify themselves as climbers, skiers/snowboarders, trail runners or mountain bikers—roughly 25 percent of the 2016 election voters.
"With the right tools, these Americans—this passionate outdoor community of ours—can be the difference in addressing the climate crisis," POW Executive Director Mario Molina, who previously served as international director for The Climate Reality Project, wrote in the strategic plan. "Connected by our shared love of the outdoors, we can turn our passion into purpose and then into results."
The group's 2020 game plan is to secure pledges from 40,000 people in Maine, New Hampshire and parts of Nevada, Colorado, Michigan and North Carolina to vote with climate as a top priority. POW is volunteering to help host 100 community events in these priority areas that feature outdoor athletes, and it is planning contests to engage more people on the issue.
"We need to continue to validate personal experience with scientific facts—that's a powerful combination," said Molina, who sees the thrill of snow sports as a powerful impetus for inspiring outdoor recreation enthusiasts to press politicians on climate change.
Molina wants to shift people's thinking so personal climate action takes on new meaning beyond simply recycling or driving a hybrid. He wants outdoor enthusiasts to see voting as a powerful tool for fighting climate change.
"If we were to get a million people to call their representatives once a month," he said, "we would see different results coming out of both our state and federal legislatures."
"The ski industry, particularly, has potential to wield incredible political power," Molina said, if it is able to motivate guests to become climate advocates, "let's just say how the NRA recruits people at gun shows."
Some in the ski industry cringe at the comparison. They also look at some of the negative attention Patagonia attracted when it opposed President Donald Trump's move to downsize the Bears Ears National Monument. Its open resistance to Trump administration policies was targeted on social media with a #BoycottPatagonia effort.
Despite the pushback from some quarters, Patagonia CEO Rose Mercario has called the response to the company's environmental campaigns "overwhelmingly positive."
Ski Industry Has Been Ramping Up Activism
The ramp-up of political activism around climate change has been underway in the background in the outdoor recreation industry for years. Ski companies are part of the Outdoor Business Climate Partnership, the U.S. Business Climate Action Contribution Platform and We Are Still In, the coalition supporting Paris Accord climate-pollution reduction goals after the Trump administration announced the United States would pull out.
The Boulder, Colorado-based Outdoor Industry Association began arguing with Utah's Republican leaders over a decade ago about state policies on public lands. The fight played out over the industry's twice-yearly trade shows in Salt Lake City as the outdoor industry, with a national economic impact of $887 billion spending and 7.6 million jobs, tried to make the political case for a healthy environment.
But after Utah Republicans called on the Trump administration to strip national monument protections from 2 million acres of public land in the state three years ago, OIA responded swiftly by relocating its big trade show from Salt Lake City to Denver—a move estimated to cost to Utah's convention business $1 billion over a decade.
"Brands are seeing that they can utilize their voice to encourage and push for action and de-polarize the climate arena," said Andrew Pappas, manager of state and local policy at OIA.
Schendler, the Aspen executive, said the outdoor recreation industry is taking too long to engage customers on climate change. He said "Give A Flake" will be targeting Trump on his climate position in 2020.
"People say, 'Your business is the ski business—just do skiing'," Schendler explains. "We say, 'This is business. We are threatened—we are threatened today with going out of business.'"