Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Pilgrim security violations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pilgrim security violations. Show all posts

Thursday, March 26, 2015

Expert: Pilgrim shutdown a 'near miss'






Expert: Pilgrim shutdown a 'near miss'

Plant's owner says claim is 'unfounded and irresponsible'



By Christine Legere
Posted Mar. 25, 2015

"Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station in Plymouth will be placed on the Union of Concerned Scientists' list because of a shutdown of the reactor that occured during a blizzard on Jan. 27. Merrily Cassidy/Cape Cod Times

PLYMOUTH — The Union of Concerned Scientists’ top nuclear expert says the forced reactor shutdown at Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station during the Jan. 27 blizzard was risky enough to make his organization’s annual “near miss” list.

David Lochbaum, director of the organization’s Nuclear Safety Project, said Pilgrim wasn’t near meltdown, but the multitude of mechanical difficulties that occurred after offsite power to the plant was partially lost are cause for concern.

“There are many, many steps before a core meltdown, but they took a few steps down that road,” Lochbaum said about Pilgrim. “In a perfect world, you don’t want to go down that path at all.”

An Entergy spokeswoman protested Lochbaum's characterization of the Jan. 27 shutdown.

“These claims are completely unfounded and irresponsible," Lauren Burm wrote in an email. "The shutdown occurred safely as plant operators were reducing power in response to the onset of a historic storm. During the storm, conditions were stable and there was never any threat to the safety of plant workers or the public."

On Jan. 27, Pilgrim’s problems began with partial loss of offsite electrical power out in the plant’s switch yard. Station response was complicated by the failure of a diesel-driven air compressor, leaking of a safety relief valve used to help depressurize the reactor; failure of one of the manually-operated safety relief valves; and failure of a "high pressure coolant injection system," which then leaked an inch of water onto the floor.

Sump pumps couldn’t clear it, since all nonvital functions were shut down.

“Those events had the potential to lead to core damage by a factor of 10,” Lochbaum said, which means the risk of that damage occurring would be 10 times greater than on a "normal everyday."

Nuclear Regulatory Commission officials sent a special federal inspection team to the plant shortly after the shutdown, a move that triggers inclusion by the Union of Concerned Scientists on its "near miss" list.

“Most shutdowns don’t have the NRC boarding a bus and heading for the plant,” Lochbaum said about the level of concern at the federal agency.

But NRC spokesman Neil Sheehan said the risk was still low.

“Keep in mind the risk is one in a million per year,” Sheehan said about the typical risk of an event causing serious damage to the reactor's core. “At 10, you’re still talking about an extremely rare event.”

Sheehan said eight special team inspections were performed in 2014. Only two of those were related to unplanned reactor shutdowns, which happen an average of about 38 times per year.

The situation is evaluated by risk analysts before a team is sent.

“It has to meet some clear-cut criteria for us to send a special inspection team in,” Sheehan said. “We’re not talking the risk of reactor meltdown. We’re talking about the erosion of safety margins. Anytime we see that sort of increase in risk, we take a closer look.”

Federal nuclear officials are expecting Entergy to submit a mandated follow-up report with more details in the next few days.

The NRC inspection team will issue its findings, along with any recommended enforcement, by the first week in May.

“The team conducted its exit interview at Pilgrim last Friday,” Sheehan said.

Lochbaum’s organization publishes an annual list of “near misses” at nuclear power plants and details why each was included on the list. Last year, Pilgrim wasn’t on the list, which included 11 plants.

In 2011, Pilgrim was on the list twice: One of those involved security-related issues which the NRC does not discuss.

"The second event at Pilgrim in 2011 involved the operators losing control of the reactor during an attempted start-up, forcing automatic protective safety features to step in and shut down the reactor," Lochbaum said.

Both times, special inspection teams were sent.

Burm said Entergy has invested nearly $500 million into safety-related upgrades since 2000.

"Safe operations are the foundation of all work done at Pilgrim," she wrote. "Whether in a temporary shutdown or operating at full capacity, Pilgrim has and always will operate safely."

When asked by the Times if he and the Union of Concerned Scientists are anti-nuclear power, Lochbaum said they do not oppose plants that perform well.

“Our criteria is set by government regulations,” Lochbaum said. “The regulations define what is safe. If you’re below that, we’re not happy. If you’re above, you won’t hear a peep from us.”

"UCS is pro-nuclear safety and anti-nuclear disaster," he later wrote in an email. "Our commentaries and reports are true to this position, highlighting good nuclear safety outcomes and spotlighting bad ones."



http://www.capecodtimes.com/article/20150325/NEWS/150329671/101015/NEWSLETTER100




Friday, September 19, 2014

Watchdogs complain of lax Pilgrim security






 
Citizens groups from both sides of the Cape Cod Canal have sent a petition to federal officials saying security at the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station should be tightened or the plant should be shut down.
 
"This petition is filed shortly after both the anniversary of 9/11 and President Obama's Sept. 10 speech that told the nation that ISIL threatened the homeland," the petition says. "Reactors have symbolic value and the capability of enormous destruction. Pilgrim is a symbolic target because it is located in America's Hometown."
 
The Cape Downwinders and Pilgrim Watch, which have both called for closing the plant, cited 15 incidents of trespassing on the Plymouth plant property since 2002 that have been documented in the news or police logs.
 
"There were probably even more," said Mary Lampert, founder and executive director of Pilgrim Watch.
 
The petition was filed with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Lampert, who has submitted numerous petitions to the NRC over the last several years, said it's important to continue to highlight concerns about the Pilgrim plant.
 
"It gets the conversation on the burner," she said.
 
Ten of the trespassing incidents on the list happened during the last three years, the nuclear watchdogs said.
 
The petition claims plant security has eroded.
 
"The guard house is unmanned and there is no visible security personnel around the perimeter of the owner-controlled areas," states the petition. "People can and do enter the owner-controlled area without a problem or detection."
 
Three of the excursions onto the power plant property happened just in the last month, according to Plymouth police logs.
 
On Sept. 11, a man and woman from Connecticut were spotted by security in a back parking lot. The pair said they were looking for the beach. Both were arrested for trespassing by Plymouth police. The woman was also charged with drug possession.
 
On Sept. 2, two men from Canada were arrested on the property. They said they were looking for a place to fish.
 
On Aug. 31, two men from New Hampshire, who said they were looking for a path to the waterfront, were arrested for trespassing.
 
On Aug. 21, an incident involved two members of Cape Downwinders who were being filmed by a Boston news station. Diane Turco and William Maurer, following the interview, walked down the plant driveway and into a building. They left the building after spending several minutes there unchallenged and returned to the news truck where they found two plant guards checking out the vehicle and crew, according to the account written by the Downwinders. They were not arrested.
 
Entergy, the owner-operator of the Plymouth reactor meanwhile argues the plant is secure.
 
Spokesman Jerry Nappi said trespassers may have wandered onto the reactor property, but they were outside security areas.
 
"Employees, tradesmen, the postal service and others go across the owner-controlled area, which is the outermost area, to get to the next layer," Nappi said. "You enter a building where you place your hand on a piece of equipment. If there's a match, the gate opens."
 
"We have intrusion detectors, fences and vehicle barriers along the border between the outer area and the next layer."
 
Beyond the outer area, the plant has graduated areas of security laid out in three circles around the reactor, Nappi said.
 
Lampert disagreed with Nappi's characterization of the outer area as being less of a concern.
 
"With today's weapons, the closer you get to the protected area the more accurate you'll be," she said.
 
"You could cause serious damage."
 
Lampert said if a team of trained terrorists launched an attack by land and water, "we'd probably be cooked." But if an attack were being planned by an individual, security guards posted on the outer area of the property and in the guardhouse could be a deterrent.
 
Lampert contends Entergy may have made a financial or public relations decision to cut security.
 
"If you have visible guards, it's not good PR," Lampert said. "You're telling the public, 'Gee, something could go wrong here.'"
 
But Nappi said security at the plant has been beefed up, not stripped down.
 
"Security personnel has remained stable, and there have been significant advancement in detection and protective measures."
 
Neil Sheehan, spokesman for the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, said plant owners are given somewhat of a free hand regarding security.
 
"We want to give them flexibility with their security programs," Sheehan said. "They may allocate a security officer who would be in a guardhouse to a better location."
 
Sheehan said the petition will be referred to one of the NRC's directors.
 
"In this case, it would likely be the Director of the Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, though it could be the Office of Nuclear Security and Incident Response," Sheehan said.
 
Follow Christine Legere on Twitter: @chrislegereCCT.
 
 
 
 

Thursday, February 27, 2014

NRC dings Entergy with a non-cited violation




NRC dings Entergy with a non-cited violation

 
 
Pilgrim supervisors brought initial issue to NRC's attention
In an official letter from the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) dated February 26, 2014, Entergy, the owners of Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station in Plymouth, received notification of a non-cited violation in response to a violation that occurred in January 2013.

According to the NRC, Pilgrim initially notified them about the matter and took steps to correct it.

The issue in question involved a contract medical assistant who "deliberately failed to conduct required tactile and/or olfactory testing" during the annual physical examination of three licensed operators on January 10, 2013. One of the three operators told a Pilgrim supervisor that the medical assistant did not require the olfactory test. Pilgrim supervisors promptly began an investigation and notified the NRC two days later.

Based on an investigation conducted by the NRC's Office of Investigations, it was determined that the medical assistant deliberately did not conduct the required tests, then falsified medical records to "indicate they were performed."

Due to the medical assistant's actions, Entergy violated NRC requirements in Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 55.27 and in 10 CFR 55.9. CFR 55.27 has to do with the documentation of medical records and 55.9 is concerned with the keeping of accurate and complete records.

NRC has officially graded the violation as a Security Level IV. The violation is being considered minor as the licensed operators were officially tested within a few days of the incident. But the NRC did increase the significance of the violation because it was willful and the NRC, according to the letter, bases its regulator program on "licensees and their contractors acting with integrity."

The NRC has issued a non-cited violation because Entergy, Pilgrim's owner took corrective action, the violation was not repetitive, the violation was the result of the actions of a contractor, not a supervisor or licensed operator at Pilgrim. According to the NRC website, non-cited violations are typically issued for Security Level IV violations unless licensees fail to restore compliance. NRC's investigation was completed in September 2013.

The letter does not require a response, but Entergy does have 30 days to contest the non-cited violation.

The unidentified medical assistant's access to the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station has been revoked, according to the NRC.


http://www.capecodtoday.com/article/2014/02/27/24293-nrc-dings-entergy-non-cited-violation

 

Friday, January 24, 2014

Pilgrim nuclear plant faulted on security issues




Pilgrim nuclear plant faulted on security issues
 
Top Photo
Pilgrim Nuclear Power StationCape Cod Times file/Merrily Cassidy
 
 
PLYMOUTH — Federal nuclear regulators found five security-related violations at the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station during a routine inspection last month.
 
Two of those had been spotted by inspectors as long ago as 2012 but the shortcomings had yet to be addressed.
 
On Thursday, Nuclear Regulatory Commission spokesman Neil Sheehan characterized the number of infractions found in this latest inspection as high.
 
It isn't uncommon for plants to receive multiple "green" or "low security significance" inspection findings, "but five is above the normal average," Sheehan said.
 
For two of the violations, the NRC issued written notices to Entergy Nuclear Operations, the plant's owner and operator, for failing "to correct long-standing equipment deficiencies important to station security defense ... within a reasonable amount of time," according to the NRC letter.
 
The deficiencies dated back to November 2012.
 
The company was issued "noncited violation" notices for two of the others, which require Entergy to correct the problems or face enforcement action.
 
While federal regulators won't specifically discuss findings related to security, the two were described as related to "human performance."
 
One was issued because inspectors determined "there should have been tighter security-related controls on work activities," Sheehan said.
 
Another of the noncited violations was related to decision-making.
 
"Our approach is the company should always err on the side of conservatism," Sheehan said.
 
NRC officials said those two shortcomings had been addressed by Entergy by the time inspectors left the site.
 
The final infraction found at the plant did not rise to the level of either of the two enforcement actions, Sheehan said.
 
Entergy has 30 days to respond to the NRC's letter.
 
"If we're not satisfied with the company's response or they fail to make meaningful changes, we could do more enforcement, including civil penalties," Sheehan said.
 
"Secure and safe operations are of the utmost importance at Pilgrim," Entergy said in a written statement. "At no time was the safety and security of the community or employees ever at risk."
 
The issues were promptly addressed and others have become part of the plant's corrective action plan "to preclude future occurrences," the statement said.
 
Just two months ago, Pilgrim owners received three notices for violating federal regulations by letting their employees work more hours than rules allow, operating when both of the plant's meteorological towers were down and failing to meet a federal security requirement, according to a report based on a routine check of the plant by inspectors in October.
 
Those violations were also classified as "low safety significance," although federal officials stressed that all three findings were rated that way because nothing bad happened as a result.