Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Planned Parenthood. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Planned Parenthood. Show all posts

Monday, November 18, 2019

Andy Borowitz | "Everywhere She Went Turned Bad," Says Man With Six Bankruptcies




Reader Supported News
17 November 19

Who benefits from long fundraisers? What could be more counter-productive? Is it that we cannot do better, or that we will not?
Ready to change this now.
Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News


If you would prefer to send a check:
Reader Supported News
PO Box 2043
Citrus Hts
CA 95611




Reader Supported News
17 November 19
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News


Andy Borowitz | "Everywhere She Went Turned Bad," Says Man With Six Bankruptcies
Marie Yovanovitch. (photo: Michael Reynolds/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock)
Andy Borowitz, The New Yorker
Borowitz writes: "In a blistering tweet on Friday, the former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine, Marie Yovanovitch, was accused of leaving a trail of destruction by a man with six bankruptcies and multiple business failures."
READ MORE

Gordon Sondland. (photo: John Rudoff/Sipa USA/AP)
Gordon Sondland. (photo: John Rudoff/Sipa USA/AP)

Gordon Sondland, Who Flaunted Trump Access, May Offer First-Hand Account of Trump's Ukraine Aims
Bart Jansen and Deirdre Shesgreen, USA TODAY
Excerpt: "Gordon Sondland seemed to feast on his newfound political power when he snagged a plum ambassadorship and landed in Brussels as America's top diplomat to the European Union."

Appointed to the post by President Donald Trump after he donated $1 million to the president's inaugural committee, Sondland had a direct line to the Oval Office. And he wasn't shy, or even careful, about using it.
He apparently flaunted his ability to dial Trump's phone number at will and told more seasoned administration officials to move aside as he usurped their portfolios – particularly when it came to Ukraine, even though it's not part of the EU.
Now, Sondland's relationship with Trump and his extensive dealings with Ukraine have put the former hotelier, and his boss, in a precarious position. On Wednesday, Sondland takes center stage in the House Democrats' impeachment inquiry when he gives public testimony before the House Intelligence Committee. For impeachment investigators, he is a unique witness; he was Trump's point man in the effort to push politically motivated investigations in Ukraine, and he seemed to have the most extensive, direct dealings with the president on the matter.
"Sondland will be the first individual in this inquiry to give open testimony about direct contacts with Mr. Trump on the issue of the investigations, military assistance (to Ukraine) and the relationship with Zelensky," said Aaron David Miller, a top State Department negotiator for past presidents of both parties and now a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
"Whether he chooses to open the door to further teasers ... I don’t know," Miller said.
The wealthy Portland hotelier has already told lawmakers he relayed a quid pro quo to a top Ukraine official, telling him U.S. military aid to Ukraine was likely contingent on a public statement by Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, committing to the investigations Trump wanted. These included one into former Vice President Joe Biden and another into a debunked theory about Ukraine's involvement in 2016 election interference.
Trump's national security adviser, John Bolton, likened Sondland's diplomatic agenda to a "drug deal." Bolton's deputy, Fiona Hill, portrayed him as a dangerously uninformed and unconventional diplomat.
Now, new evidence emerged during last week's first public impeachment hearing that makes Sondland an even more intriguing witness for House Democrats.
The top U.S. diplomat in Ukraine, Bill Taylor, revealed Nov. 13 that one of his deputies overheard Sondland chatting with the president on July 26 while they were in a restaurant in Kiev.
During that cellphone call, "the member of my staff could hear President Trump on the phone asking Ambassador Sondland about "the investigations," Taylor recounted during the House Intelligence Committee's first public impeachment hearing. "Ambassador Sondland told President Trump that the Ukrainians were ready to move forward."
After the call, Taylor's aide asked Sondland what Trump thought about Ukraine. "Ambassador Sondland responded that President Trump cares more about the investigations of Biden" than he does about Ukraine, Taylor recounted.
House Democrats interviewed Taylor's aide during a closed-door session on Friday. David Holmes told lawmakers Sondland assured Trump that Zelensky “loves your ass” and would do “anything you ask him to” when asked about investigations he sought, according to his opening statement obtained by CNN and confirmed by The New York Times.
Holmes testified, "I then heard President Trump ask, 'So, he's gonna do the investigation?' Ambassador Sondland replied that 'he's gonna do it,' adding that President Zelensky will do 'anything you ask him to.'"
Trump told reporters on Nov. 13 that he didn't remember any Kiev phone call with Sondland.
"I know nothing about that. First time I've heard it," the president said, adding that there was no quid pro quo "pure and simple."
The day before the call with Sondland, on July 25, Trump pressed Zelensky to open the two investigations during a phone call that triggered a whistleblower complaint alleging that Trump had solicited foreign interference in the 2020 election. That allegation is the focus of the House Democrats' investigation.
Even before the Nov. 13 revelation, Sondland had told lawmakers that a White House visit for Zelensky – something the Ukrainian leader desperately wanted as a public demonstration of U.S. support – would be granted only after Zelensky publicly committed to the investigations Trump, and his personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani, were demanding. Sondland also told the impeachment panel that he "presumed" U.S. military assistance was linked to a public Zelensky statement because there was no other credible explanation for a delay in that aid.
Sondland offered that testimony in a Nov. 4 addendum he submitted to the House Democrats after his initial closed-door interview. He said testimony from other witnesses had refreshed his memory about his dealings with Ukrainian officials.
Taylor's new information links Trump even more directly to the Ukraine pressure campaign. It also raises fresh questions about Sondland's diplomatic portfolio and qualifications.
“He’s not someone who is trained either in the art of diplomacy or in the practicalities of information security,” said Ned Price, a former CIA counterterrorism analyst. Price noted that in Sondland's initial closed-door testimony, he seemed to minimize Trump's role in Ukraine by failing, for example, to mention the July 26 call and the link between U.S. military aid and the Biden investigation.
“I think he faces a decision as to if he wants to betray his political benefactor, or if he wants to risk his own reputation,” said Price, who also was a National Security Council adviser under President Barack Obama. "Obviously he’s going to be facing a lot of pressure because it’s either him or Trump.”
Trump has moved to distance himself from Sondland in recent days. “I hardly know the gentleman,” he told reporters on Nov. 8. Before Sondland testified, Trump called Sondland "a really good man and great American" in a tweet.
Price and others say Sondland's July 26 call with Trump raises red flags for another reason: It was likely a highly compromising security breach, and illustrates how lax Sondland was about following State Department protocols to protect sensitive information.
“The president is the most lucrative intelligence target throughout the world,” Price said. “When the Russians presumably heard that he was connected to the president of the United States, they knew they had hit the jackpot.”
Ukraine and Russia are essentially at war. Russia annexed Crimea in 2014, and Ukraine continues to battle Russian-backed separatists in the eastern part of its territory.
Conducting a cellphone call with the president in a public place in Ukraine's capital, "it just doesn’t get any worse than that," said Clint Watts, a research fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute and author of "Messing with the Enemy: Surviving in a Social Media World of Hackers, Terrorists, Russians, and Fake News."
Watts said Ukraine is "ground zero" for Russian espionage campaigns, and Moscow almost certainly intercepted Sondland's conversation with Trump on a major foreign policy issue of keen interest to Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Michael McFaul, a former U.S. ambassador to Russia, said the revelation about Sondland’s call with Trump was remarkable – and not just because it exposed their exchange to foreign espionage.
“Sondland calling Trump on a cellphone from Kyiv is extraordinary for all sorts of reasons,” McFaul said in a tweet. Normally, he said, EU ambassadors don’t call the president.
“They never do so to discuss Ukraine policy. Doing so on a cellphone from Kyiv means whole world was listening in,” McFaul wrote.
Even before Wednesday's new disclosures, other witnesses had raised questions about Sondland's security practices and his unorthodox approach to diplomacy. Fiona Hill, who until recently served as the Trump administration's National Security Council adviser for Europe and Russia, said he engaged in behavior that posed a major "counterintelligence risk" and he seemed either unwilling or unable to follow normal diplomatic protocols.
"Ambassador Sondland would frequently give people my personal cellphone to call up and demand meetings" with her or with Trump's national security adviser, John Bolton, Hill told lawmakers, according to a transcript of her testimony.
"We had all kinds of officials from Europe ... literally appearing at the gates of the White House, calling on our personal phones, which are actually in lock boxes," Hill said in her closed-door interview Oct. 14. "I'd find endless messages from irate officials who'd been told that they were supposed to meet with me by Ambassador Sondland."
Text messages and other testimony shows that Sondland spent months relaying Trump and Giuliani's demands to Ukrainian officials and other U.S. diplomats. Sondland has said he got his authority and instructions from Trump and Giuliani.
Before he amended his testimony, Sondland had told lawmakers there was “no quid pro quo" and that Trump relayed that to him directly.
“There is no quid pro. The president repeated, no quid pro. No quid pro quo multiple times,” Sondland told lawmakers during his closed-door deposition Oct. 17. “This was a very short call. And I recaIl that the president was really in a bad mood.”
National Security Council official Timothy Morrison testified Oct. 31 that Hill told him he "would be wise" to stay away from engagement with Giuliani and the "parallel" pressure campaign on Ukraine.
"She mentioned that Gordon talked with Rudy, and she mentioned that she stayed away from any conversation with Rudy and that I would be wise to do the same," Morrison said.
In his three-page amendment, Sondland said he recalled a Sept. 1 meeting in Warsaw with Andriy Yermak, a top aide to Zelensky, where he said aid wouldn’t resume without investigations.
“After that large meeting, I now recall speaking individually with Mr. Yermak, where I said that resumption of U.S. aid would likely not occur until Ukraine provided the public anti-corruption statement that we had been discussing for many weeks,” Sondland said.
Other diplomats, including Taylor and George Kent, the State Department's deputy assistant secretary of State for Europe and Eurasia, said Trump and Giuliani's demands for politically motivated investigations ran counter to U.S. national interests. Kent said the message also contradicted efforts to establish the rule of law in Ukraine.
"I believe he was looking to dig up political dirt against a potential rival in the next election cycle," Kent told the Intelligence Committee on Wednesday, referring to Giuliani.
"I agree with Mr. Kent," Taylor added.
Trump has said the July 25 call with Zelensky was “perfect” because he never mentioned the suspension of nearly the $400 million in military aid in exchange for Ukraine announcing investigations.
Many Republicans have attacked the impeachment inquiry as a sham. Rep. Mark Meadows, R-N.C., amounted the controversy to "a policy difference between the President of the United States and a few people at the State Department."
But House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., said Thursday the correct description is bribery.
"The devastating testimony corroborated evidence of bribery covered in the inquiry and the president abused power and violated his oath by threatening to withhold military aid and a White House meeting in exchange for an investigation into his political rival," Pelosi told reporters Thursday.

John Bel Edwards. (photo: The Advocate)
John Bel Edwards. (photo: The Advocate)

Louisiana Re-Elects Democrat Governor John Bel Edwards, in Blow to Trump
Oliver Laughland, Guardian UK
Laughland writes: "Louisiana's Democrat governor, John Bel Edwards, has been re-elected following a closely fought gubernatorial battle that marked another statewide defeat for Republicans and Donald Trump in the American south."

EXCERPTS:
Although Rispone lost by a thin two-point margin, the defeat is a substantial blow to the president following the loss of another Republican governor in Kentucky last month. Trump won Louisiana with 58% of the vote in 2016 and the state has not elected a Democrat president since Bill Clinton in 1996.

Still, the tenor of Edwards’ campaign focused almost entirely on state-based issues. The governor pushed his record expanding healthcare in the state, raising the pay of teachers, and stabilizing the state’s economy in the wake of a multibillion dollar deficit left by the previous Republican administration, under former governor Bobby Jindal.


Pete Buttigieg. (photo: WP)
Pete Buttigieg. (photo: WP)

Pete Buttigieg Touted Three Major Supporters of His Douglass Plan for Black America. They Were Alarmed When They Saw It.
Ryan Grim, The Intercept
Grim writes: "The South Bend, Indiana, mayor polls close to zero nationally with African Americans."

EXCERPTS:
After publication, the Buttigieg campaign said it had sent the plan to the list of supporters and asked them to opt out if they did not want their name included on the list. That email also specified that the list was meant to represent “over 400 Black South Carolinians.”
Whatever the intent, a review of the 422 names on the list of supporters finds that at least 297 of them appear in the South Carolina voter file. Not all states ask for information on race when registering to vote, but, unsurprisingly, given its history of voter suppression, South Carolina does. The campaign only published the names of the supporters, without additional identifying information, which makes finding them in the voter file a challenge, given some have common names like James Wilson and Mary Williams. But for 184 of them, the voter file lists either one name, or lists multiple people, all of whom self-identify as white — so at least 42 percent of the entire list is white. And that means 62 percent of the 297 names that can be reliably checked are white.
Thigpen said he believes the campaign knew what it was doing, and knew the impression it was giving off. “I do think the way it was rolled out, it gave the impression, or the characterization, of them having broad support potentially, listing myself and others at the top of it,” Thigpen said. “But then when I know the conversations I had had, and how they used my conversation, for you to tell me there were other persons on there listed in one way, when that wasn’t really how they were, would not surprise me.”
Told that roughly half of the list of supporters were white voters, Cordero laughed. “Really?”
Meanwhile, of those 297, seven are repeated; one of them appears three times. According to a review of public record databases and social media sites, multiple names on the list appear to be from people who do not live in South Carolina. One person seems to not live in the United States at all but in São Paulo, Brazil.
Two others may be badly misspelled at best, as they don’t appear anywhere online or in voter databases. The rest, which add up to 125, can’t be found in the voter file.


Pro-choice activists rally in support of Planned Parenthood. (photo: Jacquelyn Martin/AP)
Pro-choice activists rally in support of Planned Parenthood. (photo: Jacquelyn Martin/AP)

Planned Parenthood Wins $2 Million Lawsuit Against Anti-Abortion Group Behind Fake Videos and 'Malicious Campaign'
Chris Riotta, The Independent
Riotta writes: "An anti-abortion group broke the law by trespassing, illegally recording and manipulating videos to make Planned Parenthood officials appear as though they were profiting off fetal tissue donations, a federal jury ruled on Friday."

EXCERPT:
The six-week trial ended with the jury ordering the Centre for Medical Progress to pay nearly $2.3m (£1.8m) in damages for violating multiple federal and state laws.
David Daleiden, the president of the anti-abortion group, was found to have trespassed on private property and committed other crimes in recording the 2015 videos. He and other employees of the centre were ordered to pay varying amounts.
Mr Daleiden and a co-defendant, Sandra Merritt, are set to go on trial starting 6 December on 14 counts each of invasion of privacy. They have pleaded not guilty and argue they are undercover journalists shielded from prosecution.
Planned Parenthood sued the activists as part of what the group called "a multi-year illegal effort to manufacture a malicious campaign.''
"The jury recognised today that those behind the campaign broke the law in order to advance their goals of banning safe, legal abortion in this country, and to prevent Planned Parenthood from serving the patients who depend on us,'' the organisation's acting president and chief executive, Alexis McGill Johnson, said in a statement.

Gilets jaunes protesters chant against President Macron at the Fontaine des Innocents during the second day of protests to mark the first anniversary of the movement, on November 17, 2019 in Paris, France. (photo: Kiran Ridley/Getty Images)
Gilets jaunes protesters chant against President Macron at the Fontaine des Innocents during the second day of protests to mark the first anniversary of the movement, on November 17, 2019 in Paris, France. (photo: Kiran Ridley/Getty Images)

France: Happy Birthday, Gilets Jaunes
Aurélie Dianara, Jacobin
Dianara writes: "Today marks one year since yellow-vested protesters first occupied roundabouts and intersections across France. The movement has given a voice to parts of society that usually go ignored - and the newfound spirit of revolt is continuing to shake Emmanuel Macron's government."
READ MORE

We can reduce our carbon footprint by embracing regenerative agriculture. (photo: Dougal Waters/Getty Images)
We can reduce our carbon footprint by embracing regenerative agriculture. (photo: Dougal Waters/Getty Images)

Regenerative, Organic Agriculture Is Essential to Fighting Climate Change
Ronnie Cummins, In These Times
Cummins writes: "'Regenerative agriculture' refers to farming and grazing practices that, among other benefits, reverse climate change by rebuilding soil organic matter and restoring degraded soil biodiversity."
READ MORE










Tuesday, November 12, 2019

RSN: Norman Solomon | Biden and Bloomberg Want Uncle Sam to Defer to Uncle Scrooge




Reader Supported News
12 November 19

I feel it a duty as a citizen to be as well informed as possible and RSN provides a ton of valid articles that help keep me on top of all the current events I’m interested in. Thanks ! I hope more readers join me in donating for this important source of pertinent information.
Ron, RSN Reader-Supporter


If you would prefer to send a check:
Reader Supported News
PO Box 2043
Citrus Hts
CA 95611



Reader Supported News
11 November 19
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News


RSN: Norman Solomon | Biden and Bloomberg Want Uncle Sam to Defer to Uncle Scrooge
Joe Biden and Michael Bloomberg. (image: Getty/Reuters)
Norman Solomon, Reader Supported News
Solomon writes: "The extremely rich Americans who are now frantically trying to figure out how to intervene in the Democratic presidential campaign make me wonder how different they are from the animated character who loved frolicking in money and kissing dollar bills while counting them."
READ MORE

Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., depart a press conference at the Capitol on Oct. 2. The impeachment inquiry enters a new phase this week with the start of public hearings. (photo: Win McNamee/Getty Images)
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., depart a press conference at the Capitol on Oct. 2. The impeachment inquiry enters a new phase this week with the start of public hearings. (photo: Win McNamee/Getty Images)

The Ukraine Impeachment Inquiry Begins a New Phase This Week: What You Need to Know
Philip Ewing, NPR
Ewing writes: "House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and her lieutenants are turning a new page in their impeachment inquiry this week based on a principle familiar to classics scholars: repetitio mater studiorum. 'Repetition is the mother of all learning.'"
READ MORE

Protesters in Manhattan marched on October 26, 2019, for the preservation of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, the Obama-era program that protects immigrants who came to the US as children from deportation. (photo: Erik McGregor/LightRocket/Getty Images)
Protesters in Manhattan marched on October 26, 2019, for the preservation of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, the Obama-era program that protects immigrants who came to the US as children from deportation. (photo: Erik McGregor/LightRocket/Getty Images)

The Battle Over DACA Comes to the Supreme Court
Nicole Narea, Vox
Narea writes: "The fate of some 670,000 immigrants hangs in the balance."
READ MORE

After passing a fetal-heartbeat bill, members of the Missouri House throw papers in the air to mark the end of the legislative session. (photo: The New York Times/Redux)
After passing a fetal-heartbeat bill, members of the Missouri House throw papers in the air to mark the end of the legislative session. (photo: The New York Times/Redux)

Abortion After the Clinic
Irin Carmon, New York Magazine
Carmon writes: "As Republican lawmakers try to legislate it out of existence, the future of reproductive healthcare may be at home."

EXCERPT:

hen Leana Wen introduced herself to America as the new president of Planned Parenthood last fall, she had a story she liked to tell — one that showed exactly why abortion access mattered. It was a sad tale of “a young woman lying on a stretcher, pulseless and unresponsive, because of a home abortion.” Wen, an emergency physician who had been plucked from Baltimore’s Health Department to take over the century-old institution, said the young woman had arrived at her ER in “a pool of blood” because “she didn’t have access to health care, so she had her cousin attempt an abortion on her at home. We did everything we could to resuscitate her, but she died.”
Wen was talking about a time when abortion was technically legal, yet the story rhymed with the pre-Roe era, when doctors and lawyers spoke of being radicalized by women filling their wards with blood and desperation, the same nightmare the familiar pro-choice rhetoric warns will soon be upon us. Behind the scenes, however, a vanguard of the abortion-rights movement implored Wen, directly and through intermediaries, to stop talking about “home abortion” in such dire terms. Not because they weren’t horrified by what had happened to that woman, not because they didn’t want better for her, but because these activists — doctors, lawyers, even people running abortion clinics — have concluded that “home abortions,” or, in their preferred nomenclature, “self-managed abortions,” need to be normalized in the abortion-rights conversation. And they didn’t think the president of the most visible pro-choice organization in the country should be scaremongering about it.


Peter King. (photo: NBC News)
Peter King. (photo: NBC News)

New York's Peter King Becomes 20th Republican to Announce Retirement From US House
Susan Heavey and Richard Cowan, Reuters
Excerpt: "Peter King is one of a dwindling number of centrist Republicans in a chamber that has become increasingly polarized."
READ MORE

The Bolivian president, Evo Morales, gives a speech at the presidential hangar in El Alto on Sunday. (photo: Enzo De Luca/AP)
The Bolivian president, Evo Morales, gives a speech at the presidential hangar in El Alto on Sunday. (photo: Enzo De Luca/AP)

Bolivian President Evo Morales Resigns After Election Result Dispute, Allies Claim "Coup Attempt"
Dan Collyns, Guardian UK
Collyns writes: "In a televised address, Bolivia's president of nearly 14 years said he was stepping down for the 'good of the country,' but added in an attack on opponents whom he had accused of a coup attempt: 'Dark forces have destroyed democracy.'"
READ MORE

Reports detailing the massive environmental, economic, and human consequences of unfettered global warming have come at a fast and furious pace. (photo: AP)
Reports detailing the massive environmental, economic, and human consequences of unfettered global warming have come at a fast and furious pace. (photo: AP)

Global Leaders Are Facing One of the Scariest Years of Climate Change Yet
Cristine Russell, Undark
Russell writes: "One year ago, the international scientific community could hardly have expected that Greta Thunberg, a teenager from Sweden, would become one of its greatest allies. Since beginning her weekly 'School Strike for the Climate,' the petite 16-year-old has skillfully used her public appearances and powerful social media presence to push for bolder global action to reduce carbon emissions."
READ MORE








Monday, October 28, 2019

Robert Reich | No Wonder Wall Street Fears Warren and Sanders - They Speak for the People








Reader Supported News
28 October 19
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News


Robert Reich | No Wonder Wall Street Fears Warren and Sanders - They Speak for the People
Robert Reich. (photo: unknown)
Robert Reich, Guardian UK
Reich writes: "Today's great divide is not between left and right. It's between democracy and oligarchy."
READ MORE

Ronan Farrow. (photo: David Vintiner/Observer New Review)
Ronan Farrow. (photo: David Vintiner/Observer New Review)

NBC News Can't Seem to Shake Ronan Farrow and the Scandal He Uncovered
Sarah Ellison and Paul Farhi, The Washington Post
Excerpt: "For weeks, the network has been rebutting allegations by a former correspondent, Ronan Farrow, that it suppressed his reporting on sexual assault allegations against movie producer Harvey Weinstein and covered up harassment and assault accusations against its former star, Matt Lauer."








Joe Biden and Dmytro Firtash. (photo: Sarah Rogers/The Daily Beast/Getty Images)
Joe Biden and Dmytro Firtash. (photo: Sarah Rogers/The Daily Beast/Getty Images)

Ukrainian Oligarch Seethed About 'Overlord' Biden for Years
Betsy Swan and Adam Rawnsley, The Daily Beast
Excerpt: "Indicted Ukrainian gas oligarch Dmytro Firtash spent more than million hiring key figures in Republican efforts to investigate the Biden family."

Dmytro Firtash’s lawyers say his team had to investigate Joe Biden to defend their client. One expert says Biden pushed reforms that cost the oligarch up to $400 million per year.

ndicted Ukrainian gas oligarch Dmytro Firtash spent more than $1 million hiring key figures in Republican efforts to investigate the Biden family. 
His lawyers—who often go on Fox News to defend President Trump—say they needed the dirt on former Vice President Joe Biden to demonstrate that Firtash’s prosecution was politically motivated. 
But the two men have a history. Two Ukrainian gas industry experts say the gas-market reforms pushed by Biden and others in 2014 and 2015 hit Firtash in the wallet, and badly. One knowledgeable outside observer estimated that the 2014 and 2015 gas reforms and legislation cost him hundreds of millions of dollars. 
On Dec. 9, 2015, Biden gave a speech to Ukraine’s parliament. He praised the protesters who forced out Ukraine’s Russia-friendly president, he recited Ukrainian poetry, and he called for reforms to Ukraine’s gas market, too. 
“The energy sector needs to be competitive, ruled by market principles—not sweetheart deals,” he said, basking in the audience’s repeated applause.
Firtash, who built his fortune in part through a rather sweet gas-trading deal, hated it. Earlier this year—more than three and a half years after the talk—he was still seething. Firtash told The Daily Beast that the Ukrainian parliamentarians in the audience were humiliatingly subservient to Biden. 
“He was the overlord,” Firtash said. “I was ashamed to look at this. I was repulsed.”
Now people linked to Firtash are at the heart of Republicans’ efforts to find dirt on Biden, and a document Trump’s personal attorney Rudy Giuliani has said is key to his theory of Biden World malfeasance was produced for Firtash’s legal team. The reporter who published that document, The Hill’s John Solomon, is a client of Firtash’s new lawyers, Victoria Toensing and Joe DiGenova. Over the summer, Trump pressured Ukraine’s president to cooperate with Giuliani’s efforts. That pressure stunned many Republicans and gave House Democratic leadership the impetus they had long sought to announce an impeachment inquiry. 
And two Giuliani associates reportedly brought up Firtash’s name when talking about their plans for Ukraine’s energy sector. Those two associates also worked with Giuliani to find dirt on Biden, and they’ve both been charged with financial crimes. On top of that, Firtash’s lawyers say one of them, Lev Parnas, has worked as a translator for his legal team. 
Firtash’s blunt assessment of Biden’s speech at the parliament and influence on Ukraine—shared earlier this year with The Daily Beast and published here in full for the first time—highlights how a battle over the future of Ukraine bled into the highest levels of American politics. 
Firtash’s company did not respond to requests for comment. Biden’s campaign called Firtash “a Kremlin-friendly Ukrainian oligarch who’s been wanted on bribery and racketeering charges in the U.S. since 2014.”
Gas Man
Firtash was born in Ukraine and—like many other up-and-coming oligarchs—grew rich in the rubble of the Soviet Union. After spending some time in Moscow, he started trading gas from Central Asia to Ukraine. His renown as a gas trader grew, and he made deals with Russia’s state-owned giant Gazprom to move Russia’s abundant gas to energy-hungry Ukraine. 
With Gazprom’s blessing, he got deals widely characterized as of the sweetheart variety: Firtash bought cheap gas from Russia, sold it for a lot more in Ukraine, and profited. He then bankrolled Russia-friendly politicians in Ukraine. One such politician was Viktor Yanukovych, who hired Paul Manafort. American diplomats at the time saw Firtash as a vector of Russian influence—part of the connective tissue between the Kremlin and Kyiv. 
And American law enforcement saw him as a crook. On April 2, 2014, the Justice Department announced that he had been indicted for authorizing $18.5 million in bribes to Indian government officials. The case involved efforts to mine for titanium that would be used in Boeing planes. 
Austrian authorities arrested Firtash a few weeks before the DOJ’s announcement. He posted about $174 million in bail and has since been living in Vienna, fighting extradition from his palatial corporate offices there. And while the allegation isn’t part of the DOJ’s indictment of Firtash, U.S. government lawyers have said in court that he’s an “upper echelon” associate of a Russian criminal organization. Firtash says the claim is baseless. 
In June of this year, an Austrian judge greenlit his extradition to the U.S. But his high-powered legal team is still fighting. And this July, that team got some new oomph: DiGenova and Toensing, a husband-and-wife duo who have worked on a host of contentious fights and have deep ties in Washington’s tight-knit conservative legal community. They even reportedly secured a meeting about Firtash’s case with Attorney General Bill Barr—a sit-down many criminal defense lawyers would kill for. 
Firtash’s team has long argued he’s the victim of a political prosecution and that the U.S. government only targeted him to blunt his influence in Ukraine. That’s where Biden comes in. 
Direct Hit
In 2014, hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians took to the streets in protest. After Yanukovych’s government killed dozens of protesters, he was forced out and fled to Russia. He left behind a $20 billion hole in Ukraine’s economy, and the country teetered on the brink of fiscal collapse. 
Enter Biden. The vice president helmed America’s Ukraine policy, traveled to the country multiple times while in office, and said he spoke to the country’s president and prime minister “probably on average once a week if you average it out over the last year.” Kyiv was desperate for billions in support from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), where the U.S. holds sway. The Americans and the IMF pushed Ukraine to roll out a host of reforms to get the cash. 
"The Obama administration, and Vice President Biden in particular, led the international community to help advance gas sector reforms in Ukraine,” said a former State Department official with knowledge of the dynamics. “The thinking of the United States was that establishing an open, transparent gas sector would be vital to Ukraine’s fight against entrenched oligarchic corruption and would shore up the country’s strategic stability in the face of Russian aggression.” 
“Mr. Firtash’s control of RosUkrEnergo, which exerted monopolistic control over regional gas distribution, would have been threatened by these reforms,” the official added.
Biden has touted his leverage over Kyiv, including successfully pushing for the ouster of the country’s then-chief prosecutor, Viktor Shokin. Biden wasn’t the only one pushing for Shokin to leave as part of Ukraine’s anti-corruption efforts. The prosecutor had put in anemic performance charging powerful and well-connected kleptocrats while in office and the IMF, the European Union, and Ukrainian anti-corruption activists all urged his ouster.
Shokin had also scrutinized a gas company whose board included Biden’s son Hunter Biden, a fact that Trump and his allies have cited as evidence of corruption. They note that Shokin’s replacement wasn’t much better. But the reporter who broke the Hunter Biden story years ago reported that Joe Biden’s overall anti-corruption push in Ukraine likely endangered the company his son was linked to.
The Americans and the IMF also pushed for a series of reforms to Ukraine’s energy sector, including the gas industry. In 2014 and 2015, the Ukrainians unveiled a variety of changes: Kyiv changed the corporate governance of its state-owned gas company, Naftogaz; it passed its “Natural Gas Market” law, which the prime minister touted as having “de-oligarchized and de-monopolized” the gas market; and it rolled out a basket of regulatory changes to its gas sector—with Biden cheerleading along the way. 
In a July 2015 speech, Biden praised Ukraine for “closing the space for corrupt middlemen who rip off the Ukrainian people.” 
“Middleman” was an epithet often aimed at oligarchs like Firtash, whose gas business had raked in millions by acting as a broker between Ukraine’s state-owned gas company and Russia’s Gazprom. 
“There is one of the biggest state-owned enterprises, which is Ukrainian Naftogaz, a gas company, that had very shadowy and non-transparent deals with middlemen and with the Russian Federation,” Arseniy Yatseniuk, the country’s prime minister at the time, said in a speech just two days after Biden’s. “So last year we eliminated this middleman. His name is Mr. Firtash. He is under FBI investigation and expected to be extradited to the United States.”
Oleksandr Kharchenko, the director of the Center for Energy Industry Research Center in Kyiv, said the changes damaged Firtash’s business interests. 
“It hit him directly,” he said. 
Yessed to Death
Firtash, for his part, saw in Biden a swaggering politician overstepping his bounds—and a Ukrainian audience embarrassingly enchanted with what they saw.
“When Biden came to Ukraine and he spoke in parliament, I was reminded of an old story from the Soviet Union when the first secretary of the ObKom [the regional committee of the Communist Party] came, and on the one side all the komsomoltsi [youth members of the Communist Party] lined up, and on the other the communists, and they all took loyalty oaths. You understand? That’s how approximately it was with Biden,” Firtash told The Daily Beast in February.
Biden’s influence in Ukraine, he added, was “enormous.”
Firtash saw Yatseniuk, the prime minister at the time, as a pawn of Biden and other Americans. 
“Who appointed whom, and who actually governed the country?” he said. 
Firtash has also sparred with Andriy Kobolyev, who became CEO of Naftogaz under Yatseniuk. Lev Parnas and Igor Fruman—the indicted Giuliani associates—reportedly discussed an effort to oust Kobolyev earlier this year. Reuters has reported that Firtash financed their work. 
Firtash’s lawyers say scrutiny of Biden’s role is necessary for his criminal defense. 
“The U.S. and Austrian legal teams have always been focused on Dmitry Firtash’s innocence,” a spokesperson for DiGenova and Toensing said in a statement provided to The Daily Beast. “The U.S. Justice Department has submitted false and misleading statements about Mr. Firtash and the evidence in his case to the Austrian courts. In the context of reopening the extradition case, the Austrian legal team sought former Prosecutor General Viktor Shokin’s sworn statement as one of numerous statements and other evidence submitted to the Austrian court. The former Vice President’s role in Mr. Firtash’s extradition is materially relevant to the Austrian lawyers’ argument that the prosecution is political.”
The 2015 reforms appear to have cost Firtash a lot of money. It’s difficult to estimate how much, as the oligarch’s finances are quite opaque. Victoria Voytsitska was a member of the eighth convocation of the Ukrainian parliament and a member of its committee on Fuel Energy, Nuclear Policies, and Security. She told The Daily Beast that the gas market reforms have likely cost Firtash about $215 million to $400 million a year since their 2015 rollout. 
“Firtash really was pushed out of Naftogaz’s financial flow,” Kharchenko said. 
That said, many caution against overestimating the significance of the reforms Ukraine implemented. Firtash remains immensely wealthy and powerful, and controls Ukrainian gas distribution networks, known as oblgazes. And in the wake of the Maidan Revolution, he kept control of his assets in Ukraine. Oligarchs still dominate Ukraine’s energy sector, which is far from a bastion of transparency.
Ed Chow, an energy expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said Biden and the U.S. didn’t push hard enough for major, structural changes. 
“To be fair, Biden was the most senior U.S. official interested in Ukraine,” he said. “Without Biden, even less would have happened in terms of the U.S. government pressuring Ukraine. Ukrainians would have moved forward even less on reform. I would give the U.S. government a mixed grade.” 
An American political consultant who’s worked in Ukraine for years and spoke anonymously because of client sensitivities said Kyiv has honed its ability to satisfy Westerners without upending the status quo. 
“The Ukrainians, if you look at their history, they’ve always been at the edge of one empire or another,” the consultant said. “They were used to dealing with viceroys, representatives of the sultan, representatives of the Lithuanian empire, the Polish empire, the Russian and Soviet empires. They’re masters at paying lip service to the guy who comes to town for a week. They will yes him to death, and then the minute he leaves, it’s business as usual.”
But business changed for Firtash after 2015. And Biden stayed on his mind.


Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi at a mosque in Mosul, Iraq, in 2014. (photo: Getty Images)
Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi at a mosque in Mosul, Iraq, in 2014. (photo: Getty Images)

Baghdadi's Death Doesn't Mean What Trump Thinks It Does
Fred Kaplan, Slate
Kaplan writes: "The killing of ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi is a big deal in the fight against terrorism - but not as big a deal as President Donald Trump made it out to be in his 50 - minute press conference on Sunday morning." 

The ISIS leader’s killing is a moment of military triumph that the president has cheapened and politicized.

he killing of ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi is a big deal in the fight against terrorism—but not as big a deal as President Donald Trump made it out to be in his 50-minute press conference on Sunday morning. 
It is a big deal, as an act of justice, because Baghdadi had murdered and brutalized so many people in his quest—for a while, quite successful—to claim a swath of Iraq and Syria as a caliphate and himself as its holy leader. 
It is a big deal as an elaborate operation involving special operations forces, intelligence from at least a few countries, and coordination from several more. Trump thanked Russia, Iraq, and Turkey—for allowing U.S. forces to operate in an area of northwestern Syria, where they had never had much presence—as well as the Syrian Kurds, leaving unmentioned the fact that, given his abandonment of them earlier this month, they are unlikely to be so helpful in the future. 
But the killing is less of a big deal because, not least, as Trump has boasted on previous occasions, ISIS had already been severely reduced in stature and was no longer such a centralized organization. Its members still carried out terrorist activities, but Baghdadi no longer directed them to the degree he once had. 
Bruce Hoffman, a specialist on terrorism at Georgetown University, said in an email Sunday morning that Baghdadi’s death may merely drive “the remaining ISIS forces into an alliance with al-Qaida”—which has experienced a bit of a revival in recent years. 
ISIS began, after all, as a splinter group from al-Qaida. The two groups still have many ideological similarities; “their estrangement,” Hoffman said, “was always the product of an outsize clash of egos of its two leaders”—Baghdadi and al-Qaida leader Ayman al-Zawahiri—“rather than substantive divisions or core beliefs.” A modus vivendi between the two groups is particularly plausible, Hoffman said, because Baghdadi’s strategy ultimately proved far less successful than “al-Qaida’s long-standing counsels for strategic patience, which have resulted in both its resilience and consolidated presence in Idlib province”—the last remaining rebel stronghold in Western Syria. 
In any case, Hoffman added, the militants in both al-Qaida and ISIS “regard their struggle as divinely ordained,” so “the death of a mere mortal”—even one as charismatic as Baghdadi or bin Laden (who, at the time of the raid on his compound, was much more powerful)—“is inconsequential.” 
In short, Trump’s triumphalism may prove as short-sighted as that of his predecessors. Hoffman said, “This has always been the problem with our approach to counterterrorism: the temptation to declare victory again and again, especially given our electoral cycle”—for instance, George W. Bush’s “Mission Accomplished” banner after toppling Saddam Hussein in 2003, and the celebrations surrounding Barack Obama’s announcement of Osama bin Laden’s killing in 2011. 
Trump’s special brand of triumphalism might also sour what could otherwise have been a much-needed moment of success amid the House impeachment hearings. When Obama appeared on nationwide television, for nine minutes, to announce bin Laden’s death, some Republican critics denounced him for what they saw as his self-congratulation. Trump tweeted at the time, “Stop congratulating Obama for killing bin Laden. The Navy Seals killed bin Laden.” 
Cut to seven years later, almost to the day, and, in his 50-minute Sunday-morning news conference, not only did Trump take credit for killing Baghdadi, he reveled in the act, describing the terrorist leader as “whimpering and crying and screaming all the way” as special forces and dogs chased him to the end of a tunnel, where he detonated a suicide vest, killing himself and three of his children, dying “like a dog … like a coward.” 
Trump also boasted that killing Baghdadi was a bigger deal than killing bin Laden—which is to say, that Donald Trump is a bigger deal than Barack Obama. “This is the biggest there is,” Trump said. “This is the worst ever. Osama bin Laden was big, but Osama bin Laden became big with the World Trade Center. This is a man who built a whole, as he would like to call it, a country.” 
Trump also claimed credit, as he has in the past, for warning about bin Laden in a book published a year before the 9/11 attack, when as he put it, almost no one had heard of al-Qaida. (He also, while on the subject of his books, noted that he’d written 12 of them, and “all of them did well.”) But in fact, this book, called The America We Deserve, only fleetingly mentioned bin Laden, who, in any case, was already quite well-known as the result of his earlier attack on the World Trade Center in 1993. 
Trump may hope to garner some political favor from the killing. But the gain is likely to be minimal. Harry Enten, CNN’s pollster, tweeted Sunday morning that the bin Laden raid gave Obama an “approval boost” that “lasted maybe a few weeks”—and that raid was widely viewed as the final revenge for bin Laden’s murder of 3,000 Americans. Baghdadi is less of a household name, and Trump’s repeated claims that he’d destroyed ISIS already may have blunted the killing’s political impact. 
Finally, and most puzzling, following his announcement, Trump repeated his claim that U.S. troops control Syria’s oil fields (which is untrue) and that he might invite companies like ExxonMobil to come in and drill (which they have neither the legal right nor the remotest desire to do). All of which raises, once again, the question: Is Trump putting more troops in Syria? Is he taking them out? And, whatever the case may be, why? 


A banner stating 'STILL HERE' hangs on the side of the Planned Parenthood Building after a judge granted a temporary restraining order on the closing of Missouri's sole remaining clinic in St. Louis, May 31, 2019. (photo: Lawrence Bryant/Reuters)
A banner stating 'STILL HERE' hangs on the side of the Planned Parenthood Building after a judge granted a temporary restraining order on the closing of Missouri's sole remaining clinic in St. Louis, May 31, 2019. (photo: Lawrence Bryant/Reuters)

Missouri's Only Abortion Clinic to Challenge State Shutdown Order
Robert Langellier, Reuters
Langellier writes: "The fate of Missouri's only abortion clinic is at stake on Monday, as a state arbiter hears arguments from Planned Parenthood and state officials who have threatened to close the clinic and make Missouri the sole U.S. state without legal abortion services."
READ MORE

People gather near a part of the Berlin Wall that has been broken down after the communist German Democratic Republic's (GDR) decision to open borders between East and West Berlin, circa November 1989. (photo: Carol Guzy/The Washington Post/Getty Images)
People gather near a part of the Berlin Wall that has been broken down after the communist German Democratic Republic's (GDR) decision to open borders between East and West Berlin, circa November 1989. (photo: Carol Guzy/The Washington Post/Getty Images)

What the Dismantling of the Berlin Wall Means 30 Years Later, and the Return of War-as-the-Answer
James Carroll, TomDispatch
Carroll writes: "Some anniversaries are less about the past than the future. So it should be with November 9, 1989."
READ MORE

A ghost forest near the Savannah River in Georgia. (photo: Stephen B. Morton/AP)
A ghost forest near the Savannah River in Georgia. (photo: Stephen B. Morton/AP)

This Halloween, Scare Your Friends With Some Climate Crisis Vocab
Kate Yoder, Grist
Yoder writes: "Scientists and journalists alike are talking about the effects of global warming in frightening terms. In the spirit of the Halloween season, here's a sampling of some of the spookiest."
READ MORE