Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Fatal Toyota Camry Crash. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fatal Toyota Camry Crash. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 14, 2017

Appeals court upholds $11 million jury award in Toyota CAMRY crash




Appeals court upholds $11 million jury award in Toyota crash



Koua Fong Lee

Koua Fong Lee outside of the federal courthouse in Minneapolis 
in 2015. 

An appeals court has affirmed an $11 million jury award related to a Minnesota crash that killed three people and resulted in the wrongful imprisonment of a driver.
A jury in 2015 determined that Toyota was 60 percent to blame for the 2006 crash in St. Paul. A lawsuit alleged the crash was caused by a throttle design defect in a 1996 Camry that caused it to suddenly accelerate.
Toyota argued there was no defect. The company said driver Koua Fong Lee accidentally hit the gas instead of the brake.

• In 2014: As feds slam Toyota over hiding sticky pedal, let's remember Koua Fong Lee

Lee was incarcerated until 2010 after he won a new trial which showed he was wrongfully convicted. A subsequent civil trial in 2015 found Toyota liable. The 8th U.S. District Court of Appeals Friday affirmed the jury award.

https://www.mprnews.org/story/2017/06/09/appeals-court-upholds-11-million-jury-award-in-toyota-crash







Saturday, June 10, 2017

Mr. Toyoda: Can't you ever say you're sorry and fix the defect?









This appeared in JAPAN:

Appeals court upholds $11 million jury award in Toyota crash


MINNEAPOLIS (AP) -- An appeals court has affirmed an $11 million jury award related to a Minnesota crash that killed three people and resulted in the wrongful imprisonment of a driver.
    A jury in 2015 determined that Toyota was 60 percent to blame for the 2006 crash in St. Paul. A lawsuit alleged the crash was caused by a throttle design defect in a 1996 Camry that caused it to suddenly accelerate. Toyota argued there was no defect. The company said driver Koua Fong Lee accidentally hit the gas instead of the brake.
    Lee was incarcerated until 2010 after he won a new trial which showed he was wrongfully convicted. A subsequent civil trial in 2015 found Toyota liable. The 8th U.S. District Court of Appeals Friday affirmed the jury award.

    https://mainichi.jp/english/articles/20170610/p2g/00m/0bu/019000c


    Mr. Toyoda: Can't you ever say you're sorry and fix the defect?





    Friday, June 9, 2017

    8th Circuit upholds verdict, $11M award for Koua Fong Lee and victims in Toyota Camry crash




    Additional information available on the right side of this page. 

    8th Circuit upholds verdict, $11M award for Koua Fong Lee and victims in Toyota Camry crash





    A three-judge panel of the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has unanimously upheld the verdict in favor of Koua Fong Lee, the St. Paul man who sued the Toyota Corp. after he lost control of his Toyota Camry in 2006, resulting in the deaths of three people and his imprisonment.
    In a 2015 trial, a jury found Lee 40 percent at fault and Toyota 60 percent at fault for the collision and awarded Lee and other crash victims $11.4 million.
    The panel concluded that the evidence and testimony presented at trial gave a plausible explanation for Lee’s contention that his 1996 Camry accelerated while he tried to apply the brakes as he exited eastbound Interstate 94 at the Snelling Avenue exit. The Camry rear-ended a 1995 Oldsmobile Ciera, killing the Ciera’s driver and his son, and injuring the driver’s daughter, who died 16 months later, and two other relatives in the car.
    Texas attorney Bob Hilliard, representing Lee in the trial in U.S. District Court in Minneapolis, argued that the accelerator stuck as a result of a manufacturing defect by Toyota.
    Toyota appealed, saying U.S. District Judge Ann Montgomery improperly allowed irrelevant testimony at the trial. Three witnesses who testified that their 1996 Toyota Camrys inexplicably accelerated should not have been permitted to testify because their circumstances were different, the company argued.
    The appeals court ruled that the jury listened to conflicting testimony and reached a reasonable conclusion.
    “The jury’s verdict was not based on ‘sheer speculation,’ and instead is supported by reasonable inferences drawn from the plaintiffs’ evidence.
    On one point, the appeals court said that Montgomery erred in awarding prejudgment interest to the mother of Devyn Bolton, the girl who died later from her injuries. It was not immediately clear from the appeals court decision, how much money that would entail.
    Hilliard’s law firm said the $11.4 million verdict was the largest for sudden, unintended acceleration ever issued against Toyota.
    Before the civil trial, Lee spent two years in prison after Ramsey County prosecuted him for the accident and a jury convicted him of criminal vehicular homicide. Hilliard won Lee’s release after presenting evidence that Toyota Camrys had a history of sudden, unintended acceleration. County prosecutors decided to not retry the criminal case.
    http://m.startribune.com/8th-circuit-upholds-verdict-11m-award-for-koua-fong-lee-and-victims-in-toyota-camry-crash/427483223/?section=%2F

    Wednesday, November 16, 2016

    PANGHOUA MOUA: KEEPING DREAMS ALIVE






    The Sudden Unintended Acceleration was caused by a heat-related nylon 6/6 “sticky pulley” mechanical issue in the 1996 Toyota Camry throttle control system. 


    See other posts related to Koua Fong Lee's wrongful conviction HERE

    Click on the LINK to view additional photos.  



    panghoua_2



    img_3731


    My Daily She




    PANGHOUA MOUA: KEEPING DREAMS ALIVE



    Most of Panghoua Moua’s life has been a challenge, to say the least.  After growing up in Hmong refugee camps in Thailand, she and her husband thought all their problems were over when they immigrated to the United States.  But just two years later, they were involved in a fatal car crash that left her husband wrongfully imprisoned for almost three years, until a judge declared their later-recalled Toyota to be at fault.  Keep reading for Panghoua’s story, and how her family is rebuilding their life.
    Panghoua is a dreamer.  She has had to be, to escape from her reality for so much of her life.  She was born in a Hmong refugee camp in Thailand in 1985, after her parents fled Laos during the Vietnam War.  She is the oldest of eight children.  Panghoua’s family was moved to two other camps during her childhood, and they always had their bags packed to move at a moment’s notice. She says, “It was normal for me.  I lived my whole life that way.”
    When Panghoua was 14 years old, she was excited to attend the Hmong New Year celebration–it was her favorite time of year, as it was the only time each year that she got new clothes.  What she didn’t expect was that she would meet a boy at the celebration, Koua Fong Lee, who would become her husband just two months later.  “We didn’t fall in love right away,” but once they did know, they married quickly, and immediately started dreaming of building a better life together.
    Panghoua explains, “I understand that in this country, fourteen is kind of young, but I was very, very mature.”  Panghoua learned how to take care of herself when she was little.  She worked her entire childhood, sewing traditional Hmong clothing and decor, and helping local Thai farmers with their harvests.  “Right now, I have a fourteen-year-old daughter, and she is very different than I was.  But I understand that life here is different.  I don’t want to compare us, because we live in a different society.  I don’t want my kids to live how I used to live.”



    In 2004, the United States opened the door for most of their camp to immigrate to St. Paul, Minnesota.  Relatives who had come to the area in the 1970s sponsored them, enrolling Panghoua and Koua in school, where they took English as a Second Language (ESL) and other courses to help them adjust to their new homeland.  They also let Panghoua’s family stay with them until they found a home in St. Paul close to the rest of their extended family.  The young couple’s dreams of a country they could call their own and a real education were finally coming true!
    And then the unthinkable happened.
    In June 2006, just two years after their arrival from the refugee camp, Koua was driving Panghoua, their daughter, and his father and brother home from a family graduation party.  As they exited the highway, Koua pressed the brake of his Toyota Camry, but it instead accelerated, crashing into a stopped car and killing three of the people in it.  Panghoua remembers, “I thought we might die.  I saw the car ahead of us, then turned and looked at my four-year-old and thought, ‘This might be the last time I see my daughter.’  It happened so fast.  I don’t remember the impact.”
    But she would never forget the impact that event had on her family.  “It took away everything–our hopes and dreams–in that moment.”
    Koua was convicted in 2008 and sentenced to eight years in prison.  He did everything he could to support Panghoua, who was pregnant with their fourth child, while he was in prison, including encouraging her when she decided to attend college to get an accounting degree.  She felt that with a degree, she could keep their dream alive.  She could have her own business, and Koua could help her if he was unable to get a good job later.

    She was also grateful to have an amazing support system help her through that time.  Her relatives helped with the legal process of the first trial, and Panghoua turned to her ESL teacher for emotional support while her husband was away.  They are still very good friends.
    When asked what gave her strength at that time, Panghoua quickly replies:

    I had Jemee [their oldest daughter] in the refugee camp, and I wanted her to have a different life.  When we learned that we had the opportunity to come to this country, go to school, and support our kids, I knew that was the future I wanted for her….When he was in prison, I knew I had to keep that dream alive.  It was hard to be positive, but I could not just give up.  I needed to be there for my kids.  I needed to be there for him.”

    The couple talked on the phone every day while he was in prison.  One night, Koua called home and told Panghoua that someone had told him of a Toyota recall due to unintended acceleration.  She recalls, “I searched online and found a family who’d had the same thing happen to them, and I just started crying.”
    When Panghoua told Koua’s cousin about other similar cases with Toyotas, he contacted an attorney in St. Paul, who also received help from a Texas attorney and the Minnesota Innocence Project, which works to free people who are wrongfully imprisoned.  After spending almost three years in prison, Koua was granted a retrial.  The prosecutor decided to drop the case.  Koua was released, and his criminal charge was erased.



    Although Panghoua was overjoyed to have her husband home, the transition was far from easy.  When he first came home, they both met with a psychiatrist and took prescription medications to sleep because they couldn’t stop thinking about the accident.  Panghoua also saw a counselor while Koua was in prison and after his release to deal with depression.
    The younger children didn’t know who he was at first, and Koua worked very hard to get to know them.  Panghoua admits, “I still have not talked openly with my kids about what happened.  I want them to be able to understand.  It changed our life, and the life of the other family…I think Jemee knows what happened, but she doesn’t want to talk about it.”

    Despite those challenges, her relationship with her husband is stronger than ever.   Panghoua says, “I talk to him about everything.  We appreciate each other more every day because you don’t know what tomorrow will bring you.”  She admits that their relationship is different than before, but they trust each other and communicate.  “We try to work very hard to keep our dream alive and have a good future and support our community.”


    She advises anyone whose loved one is struggling, “Never give up.  Be there for them, and think about the good things.”  She also emphasizes what a gift today is.  Anything could happen, but we don’t need to live in fear.

    Thursday, August 6, 2015

    2007 Toyota Camry Fatal Crash kills 2




    Funerals set for 2 women killed in Route 3 crash in Clifton




    By Justin Zaremba | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com 
    Email the author 
    on August 06, 2015



    EAST ORANGE — Funerals for the two 21-year-old women killed in a single-vehicle crash off of Route 3 in Clifton Friday have been set for this week and next week.
    Tashanique "Zoey" Hawkins, of Elizabeth, will have a noon service Friday at Smith Funeral Home, 455 North Broad St., Elizabeth. Carlene Maynard, of East Orange, will have a 10 a.m. funeral service Aug. 14 at Christ Episcopal Church at 422 Main St., East Orange.
    At about 3:30 a.m. on July 31, a 20-year-old East Orange woman driving a 2007 Toyota Camry with four passengers lost control of the vehicle for an unknown reason while on the Route 3 exit ramp to Valley Road, Clifton police Sgt. Michael Bienkowski has said. The vehicle left the roadway, struck a utility pole and rolled over, he said.
    The driver and two other female passengers were taken to St. Joseph's Medical Center for non-life threatening injuries, he said. Both Hawkins and Maynard were killed in the crash.

    RELATED: Police ID 2 women killed in Route 3 crash in Clifton

    Hawkins' viewing will take place at 10 a.m. Friday. Maynard's viewing will take place an hour before her funeral service on Aug. 14.
    Hawkins leaves behind her 10-month-old son, Basim Oma'ri; her parents, Kim and Davonn; and four siblings. Maynard, who recently turned 21, is survived by her parents, Marilyn and Odley; five siblings; and "thousands of friends and family," according to a statement on her Gofundme.com page.
    Gofundme.com pages have been set up for both Hawkins and Maynard following their deaths. Each page has raised several thousand dollars as of Thursday morning.
    "Tashanique was very popular because of her mild, soft, humble and fun loving spirit," according to a statement on Hawkins' Gofundme.com page.
    "Carlene was a fun, loving, and caring individual," according to a statement on Maynard's Gofundme.com page. "Every day of her life was filled excitement, adventure, and laughter. Her radiant smile and style epitomized the phrase 'glitz and glam.'"
    Clifton police have not yet released the names of the driver or the other passengers involved in the crash. Detective Sgt. Robert Bracken said Tuesday morning charges were not expected to be filed at this time in connection with the crash.
    Bracken has not yet provided more information on the circumstances of the crash, saying the matter was still under investigation. He previously said several people were ejected from the vehicle.

    http://www.nj.com/passaic-county/index.ssf/2015/08/funeral_set_for_2_women_killed_in_route_3_crash_in.html







    Sunday, July 5, 2015

    Out Of Control 2007 Grey Toyota Camry Kills Pedestrian




    2007 TOYOTA CAMRY Problems & Complaints





    Broadcast time: 13:51
    Friday, June 12, 2015

    32 Division
    416-808-1900


    On Thursday, June 11, 2015, at approximately 1:20 p.m., police responded to a call for a pedestrian struck personal injury collision at Yonge Street and Empress Avenue. 

    It is reported that: 

    − a 62-year-old woman was driving a 2007 Toyota Camry, eastbound on Park Home Avenue approaching Yonge Street (Park Home Avenue is on the west side of Yonge Street and Empress Avenue is on the east side) 

    − a 59-year-old man was driving a 2014 Toyota Venza eastbound on Park Home Avenue, approaching Yonge Street 

    − the Camry side-swiped the Venza and continued eastbound into the intersection 

    − the driver of the Camry subsequently struck four pedestrians, then mounted the curb on the northeast area of the intersection, and struck a concrete embankment, a tree and finally a vehicle, which was parked behind 5151 Yonge Street 

    One pedestrian suffered fatal injuries and was pronounced dead at the scene, a second pedestrian was transported to hospital suffering from life-threatening injuries. The remaining pedestrians were transported to hospital suffering from non-life-threatening injuries. 

    The driver of the Camry was transported to hospital suffering from non-life-threatening injuries and the driver of the Venza was not injured. 

    Anyone with information is asked to contact police at 416-808-1900, Crime Stoppers anonymously at 416-222-TIPS (8477), online at www.222tips.com, text TOR and your message to CRIMES (274637). Download the free Crime Stoppers Mobile App on iTunes, Google Play or Blackberry App World. 


    http://torontopolice.on.ca/newsreleases/32077


    VIDEO ON LINK

    Man dies after out-of-control car strikes 4 pedestrians in North York


    Last Updated Jun 12, 2015 at 8:51 am EDT





    http://www.680news.com/2015/06/11/man-dies-after-out-of-control-car-strikes-4-pedestrians-in-north-york/




    Four pedestrians were struck, one fatally, by an out-of-control vehicle near Yonge Street and Empress Avenue on Thursday afternoon.

    The incident happened just before 1:30 p.m.

    Witnesses told CityNews a car hit a taxi and continued to drive through Empress Avenue, hopping a curb at Yonge Street where several pedestrians were hit.

    The vehicle ended up on the sidewalk and hit a tree before striking a black Porsche, witnesses said.

    A 65-year-old man was killed. Two others were seriously injured, and another suffered minor injuries.

    Witness Susan Barry said the car was “out of control completely.”


    The 62-year-old female driver of the car wasn’t seriously injured, but appeared rattled.

    “She didn’t know what happened,” another witness told CityNews. “She was just sitting on the curb, not talking. She was in very bad shock…She was just shaking.”

    Police are asking witnesses to come forward. At this point, no charges have been laid.

    The area was closed to traffic for several hours, but all roads have since reopened.





    Toronto police release details on deadly [TOYOTA] collision





    At least three people were hit by a car that jumped the curb on Yonge Street, June 11, 2015.
    At least three people were hit by a car that jumped the curb on Yonge Street, June 11, 2015.
    Peter Kim / Global News
    Toronto police are releasing some details about a collision which killed one pedestrian and injured four other people.
    The incident took place just before 1:30 p.m. on Thursday at Yonge St. and Empress Ave.
    Police say a 62-year-old woman was driving a Toyota Camry when her car side-swiped another vehicle and continued into an intersection.
    The Camry then hit four pedestrians, mounted a curb, hit a concrete embankment, a tree and another parked car before coming to a stop.
    One pedestrian was killed and the three others were taken to hospital, one of them with life-threatening injuries.
    The driver of the Camry was also taken to hospital with non-life threatening injuries.
    Police are asking anyone with information on the incident to contact them.

    http://globalnews.ca/news/2051770/toronto-police-release-details-on-deadly-collision/


    Another man fighting for his life following crash on Yonge Street
    Police are still deciding whether to recommend charges against a female driver
    Posted on 6/12/2015 by Russ Courtney
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Toronto police release details on fatal collision
    Jun 12, 2015
    By The Canadian Press
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    One killed, four hurt in north
    Toronto crash
    Witness says bodies ''fell from the sky''
    ‘I saw three people fall from the sky':
    Pedestrian dies after brutal Toronto
    car crash
    TORONTO
    Victor Ferreira and Davide Mastracci | June 11, 2015 7:19 PM ET
    (with 0:56 sec video)
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    2011 TOYOTA CAMRY Problems & Complaints

    ---------------------------------------------------------------

    2010 TOYOTA CAMRY Problems & Complaints

    ---------------------------------------------------------------

    2009 TOYOTA CAMRY Problems & Complaints

    ---------------------------------------------------------------

    2008 TOYOTA CAMRY Problems & Complaints

    ---------------------------------------------------------------

    2007 TOYOTA CAMRY Problems & Complaints




    Tuesday, June 16, 2015

    Hilliard Reports Judge Denies Toyota New Trial, Affirms Verdict: $14,062,483.02






    Hilliard Reports Judge Denies Toyota New Trial, Affirms Verdict: $14,062,483.02


    CORPUS CHRISTI, Texas, June 15, 2015 /PRNewswire/ -- Today, Judge Montgomery of the District Court of Minnesota issued an Order affirming the jury's award in a case involving a defective Toyota Camry that has been pending for the past five years which resulted in the death of three individuals and a man spending nearly three years in prison for a crime he did not commit.
    On August 5, 2010, Koua Fong Lee, a Hmong immigrant, was released from prison after serving two and a half years of an eight-year prison sentence, wrongfully convicted of criminal vehicular homicide. Mr. Lee and his family were involved in a car accident on June 10, 2006 after a trip home from a family celebration at church turned deadly. Upon exiting the highway onboard his 1996 Toyota Camry, Mr. Lee's brakes failed, causing a violent rear-end collision that led to the death of three passengers in another vehicle and seriously injured two others. Mr. Lee's vehicle experienced sudden unintended acceleration caused by a design defect in Toyota's fleet. While Toyota had kept consumers and the public in the dark about prior incidents of sudden unintended acceleration, Mr. Lee was nonetheless forced to spend over two years in prison, until a new trial was granted to prove that Toyota's design defect was the true cause of the deadly accident. Upon this showing the State had no other recourse but to drop all charges against Mr. Lee.
    On February 3, 2015, in a subsequent civil trial, a jury found that Toyota was liable for design defects and awarded a total of $11.4million—the single largest verdict against Toyota for sudden unintended acceleration.
    In an effort to avoid the multi-million dollar award, on March 4, 2015, Toyota asked the Court to declare that the Toyota Camry involved in the accident did not have a design defect or to grant the automaker a new trial— alleging there was no evidence presented at trial to support the finding that the accident was caused by a design defect. This is not the first time the auto giant seeks to dodge the record-setting jury award. On February 17, Toyota asked the Court to reduce the jury verdict, alleging that Mr. Lee should contribute $4 million to the payment since the jury found him to be 40 percent at fault.
    In the 67-page Opinion, Judge Montgomery declared, "The jury deliberated for five days before reaching its unanimous verdict.  The Court is convinced the jury discharged their duties diligently and with care.  The verdict did not result in a miscarriage of justice warranting a new trial."
    "The jury reached the right decision when it found for Koua.  And the Judge reached the right decision when she affirmed the jury's award," said Bob Hilliard, Founding Partner at Hilliard Munoz Gonzales, LLP, who took-on Toyota to remedy Mr. Lee's unjust conviction and who continues to fight on his behalf.  "The tragedy that cuts the deepest is an innocent man sat in prison for over two years while a car company, knowing he was innocent, continued to make billions while cowardly refusing to admit the truth of the defect. Today justice was affirmed and the Lees, as well as the other innocent victims, have finally won!"
    ABOUT HMG     http://www.hmglawfirm.com/ 
    Hilliard Munoz Gonzales LLP (HMG) specializes in mass torts, personal injury, product liability, commercial and business litigation, and wrongful death. Hilliard Munoz Gonzales LLP has been successfully representing clients in the United States and Mexico since 1986. Bob Hilliard obtained the Largest Verdict in the country in 2012 and the #1 verdict in Texas in 2013.

    http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/hilliard-reports-judge-denies-toyota-new-trial-affirms-verdict--1406248302-300099528.html





    Monday, March 16, 2015

    Toyota Camry Fatal




    ADDITIONAL VIDEO ON LINK






    Published on Mar 15, 2015
    Two people were killed and two injured after a train hit a car in Louisville, Ky. on Saturday. Released video footage of the incident that shows the car driving over the railroad tracks right before getting hit by the train. The identity of the victims have not been released.


    Kentucky Train Hits Car on Tracks





    http://fox40.com/2015/03/15/kentucky-train-hits-car-on-tracks/