Shaun King | Soul Snatchers: How New York City's Criminal Justice System Conspires to Destroy Black and Brown Lives Shaun King, Medium King writes: "What I'm about to tell you is the most painful, traumatic, outrageous, outlandish, over-the-top story of government sanctioned police brutality, wrongful imprisonment, wrongful convictions, forced testimony, widespread corruption, money, lots of money, and deep, deep, deep soul-snatching psychological abuse in modern American history." READ MORE
New York Police Department officers. (photo: AP)
hat I’m about to tell you is the most painful, traumatic, outrageous, outlandish, over-the-top story of government sanctioned police brutality, wrongful imprisonment, wrongful convictions, forced testimony, widespread corruption, money, lots of money, and deep, deep, deep soul-snatching psychological abuse in modern American history. I would not have believed it had I not seen it all for myself. The rabbit hole I am about to take you down is deep and twisted. It should lead to the termination of a whole host of officials. Many should be arrested and a comprehensive independent investigation should begin immediately.
I receive hundreds of personal emails about injustice in America every single day. In mid-July, dozens of those emails were about a Bronx teenager named Pedro Hernandez. People all over the country had seen reports from Sarah Wallace of NBC New York or James Ford of Pix 11 on how Hernandez, who was jailed at Rikers Island, was running out of time to be released in time to start college. Hernandez had won awards at Rikers for his leadership and academic performance, and had also been granted a scholarship from the Posse Foundation to enter college this fall. Offered a plea deal from the Bronx DA’s Office to be released for time served, Hernandez did what few people in his position would do — he turned down the deal. Accused of shooting Shaun Nardoni, a neighborhood teenager, in the leg on September 1st, 2015, Hernandez was offered a ticket out of Rikers in exchange for admitting he shot Nardoni. The District Attorney even sweetened the pot and pledged to expunge his record in five years if he met all of the terms of his probation. Hernandez still refused to take the deal — continuing to pledge that he was completely innocent and would rather take his chances with a jury before admitting to something he didn’t do.
For nearly a week, people emailed me about Pedro’s case before I finally clicked on the link to see what it was all about. Tory Russell, an activist and organizer from St. Louis, who I’d come to know from Ferguson, sent me a direct message on Twitter asking me if I could read the story and support Pedro somehow. I was on vacation with my family and it still took me another three days to finally read the story. I was hooked, but I had questions. As I Googled Pedro’s name and case, I saw several local reports that stated he had been wrongfully arrested and harassed by the NYPD for years. A guard at another facility was actually arrested and charged with criminal assault, endangering the welfare of a child, criminal obstruction of breathing and blood circulation, and harassment after being caught on film brutally beating and choking Pedro. Eight different eyewitnesses had all come forward to state that Pedro was not the shooter. Many even went so far as to identify the actual shooter. Why then, did Pedro remain behind bars? Why did it seem like the NYPD had it out for him? And how could the Bronx DA simultaneously believe that Pedro was safe enough to set free if he took the plea, but so dangerous, that if he didn’t, his bail would be set at an outrageous $250,000 with a stipulation that he not pay the typical 10%, but pay all $250,000 — effectively ensuring that he’d never get out on bail. That Pedro Hernandez, with the entire deck stacked against him, still refused to take a plea, hooked me.
As I reached out to Pedro’s family, I was immediately struck by something peculiar. I’ve written nearly 1,000 stories about police brutality and misconduct and have interviewed hundreds of families suffering through the consequences of those things. Almost every single one of those families, particularly when they are still in a stage of grief or conflict, without fail, want to speak exclusively about their very specific case. Pedro’s family was different. They immediately wanted me to know that Pedro was not alone, but that he was just one of hundreds of victims whose lives had been turned upside down by officers from the 42nd precinct in the Bronx who were working in close concert with the Bronx District Attorney’s Office. The accusations were so sweeping and broad that I wasn’t sure how to process them.
They went something like this:
“Stop and frisk has been banned, but police in the 42nd precinct are actually doing something far worse. They are setting quotas and goals for the number of people each officer must arrest. If you don’t meet or exceed the quotas, you feel the wrath of your supervisors. Instead of rejecting the quotas, some officers are embracing them and rounding up people, particularly teenage children, for crimes they know good and well they didn’t commit — locking them away sometimes for days, weeks, months, or even years at a time — then simply dismissing the charges. This isn’t just a few rogue cops, but an entire precinct is doing this and they are partnering with the Bronx District Attorney’s Office to make it happen. With threats, and even brute force, kids are being coerced to identify and testify against people they don’t even know. Officers are terrorizing families, snatching kids out of their beds, not a few times, but dozens of times per child, sometimes arresting them on false charges, sending them to Rikers, then releasing them months later. Cops think they can do anything they want and it appears they can. Pedro is being framed. They tried to frame him over and over again before this case. And other kids are being framed too. And the kids and families who’ve been victimized by this scandal are hollow shells of their former selves. The Police Commissioner, the Comptroller, and the Mayor all know about this and are doing nothing.”
In mid-July, I wasn’t quite sure how much of all of that I believed. Now, I believe all of it –every single bit. How I got here wasn’t easy, but over the next five days I’m going to try to break it all down for you. Saying it all in one piece would be sensory overload. Trust me. The evidence is meticulous, overwhelming and undeniable. I’ll have to start from the beginning and give you the foundation for how any what I’m going to be sharing is even possible. Today is the foundation, the next four parts of this series will not only expose the injustice, but will detail each case, the primary perpetrators, and who in the New York City government was aware that such corruption and brutality took place and did nothing to stop it.
Gentrification and the Increasing “Invisibility” of Police Brutality in New York City
For our Brooklyn apartment, my family of seven currently pays more in monthly rent for what is literally the second smallest of the fifty-five homes my wife and I have lived in between the two of us. The smallest ever was our first New York apartment. The monthly rent here is more than my entire Daily News paycheck. I work three other jobs to cover everything else. As rents have gone up and up and up, the old residents of my neighborhood have been squeezed out. When the cable guy came by to install our Internet and television, I kid you not, he smiled and said “Man, back in the day, I used to sell weed right outside of where your apartment is. Nobody used to wanna live here. It was totally different.”
I’ve come to understand just how right he is. For the fifteen years of my adult life that I called Atlanta home, I met more people who relocated there from New York than anywhere else. When they told me they left New York because the cost of living in Atlanta was so much better, I never quite appreciated what they meant until my family moved up here ourselves. The struggle is real. With what we pay for rent right now, in Atlanta you could live like royalty. Kanye said it best in his track Gossip Files,
How you go to New York?
What, you ain’t never took a tour there?
What, you ain’t know you gotta be rich just to be poor there?
He’s right. My wife and I know school teachers in New York who literally struggle to afford gas money or subway passes. What passes for “nice” in New York, would struggle to pass for that almost anywhere else. The poor and middle class have been pushed to the outer edges of New York City — deep into the Bronx or Brownsville and out of the central city of Manhattan and Brooklyn. Gentrification has caused Biggie’s Bed Stuy and Diddy’s Harlem to be heavily peopled by hipster white folk walking dogs and riding bikes. And what that means is that the methods of policing in these areas have changed drastically. Wherever huge numbers of white folk exist, the methods of policing change. Mind you, studies show that a higher percentage of white people actually sell drugs than African Americans, but African Americans are policed and prosecuted for those same drugs in a way that is altogether different for whites. Consequently, neighborhoods that were once hotbeds of aggressive policing just ten or twenty years ago now experience something far more humane from the NYPD — giving a few million people that live here the impression that police brutality must no longer exist in New York the way it used to.
It does. Gentrification here means millions of us rarely see police brutality because it doesn’t happen in our neighborhood, but it’s happening, in precincts and districts that the privileged classes rarely visit, and it’s worse than you could ever imagine.
Something Much Worse Than Stop and Frisk: Arrest Quotas
Follow my words here carefully. In 2013, a federal judge, Shira A. Scheindlin, in a 193 page ruling, stated that New York’s horrendous “stop and frisk” police tactic was unconstitutional because it unfairly and disproportionately targeted “blacks and Hispanics who would not have been stopped if they were white.” She did not rule that “stop and frisk” in and of itself is unconstitutional, but that the way New York was administering it, on the backs of people of color, was. The facts were undeniable, but the practice itself was not overruled.
A staggering 5 million incidents of stop and frisk took place in New York since 2002. Nearly 90% of those stops were of people who were found to be completely innocent. The overwhelming majority of stops, of course, were done against black and Latino residents of the city. When the practice was formally disbanded in New York City after Judge Scheindlin’s decision, it was seen as an enormous victory for police reforms. And it was, but something that is perhaps even more nefarious than stop and frisk unofficially rose up within the NYPD to take its place — a crisis of false arrests driven by an unwritten quota system being overseen by precincts across the city.
Just three days after Donald Trump was inaugurated, New York City agreed to something that is so scandalous, so huge, that only the incoming presidency of Donald Trump could’ve outshined it. New York City agreed to pay $75 million (that’s $75,000,000) out in a police corruption case that should’ve rocked the city and the nation to its core. They likely chose that date and time on purpose. The case had been in litigation for years and years, but the city chose one of the most fragile, news heavy times in the history of modern American media to drop an absolute bomb. The city admitted that it was forced to dismiss over 900,000 arrests and summonses because they simply didn’t have the evidence to back them. These weren’t 900,000 stops that were made, but 900,000 legal actions accusing people of crimes that they did not commit. They were all bogus. Not 9,000. Not 90,000 — which seems like an outrageous number, but 900,000. Not only that, but the case actually had its very own deleted email scandal, where almost every single email Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly ever sent was deleted — never to be found again. Yeah, really.
Here’s the lawsuit:
Here’s the $75,000,000 settlement with 900,000+ bogus cases.
In the settlement, the NYPD refused to admit that they were using quotas, but did agree that they would send out updated notices to every officer and leader that they are banned. Mind you, that’s already been done many times before. How in the hell does a city accumulate 900,000 false arrests and summonses? I’m glad you asked. Officers within the department have already spelled it out very clearly.
To understand the misconduct, brutality, forced pleas, false witnesses, and corruption that I am about to share, you must first understand the unjust system that police officers themselves have bravely identified as being the root source of it all — arrest quotas. Yes, racism and bigotry and white supremacy, conscious or otherwise, are all essential underlying problems with policing in America, but arrest quotas, or the departmental demand that each officer has a certain number of arrests, preferably with certain types of crimes, on the backs of certain types of people, are the vehicle that allows America’s worst instincts to wreck havoc on the lives of everyday people in New York. Gentrification has essentially pushed these horrible practices out of the eyesight of New York’s privileged class and the victory of Stop and Frisk being cut down gave the both city and the NYPD cover for something that is arguably far worse.
The systemic foundation of the next four parts of this series was not set by me, but by heroic, award-winning officers within the NYPD who believed with all of their heart that arrest quotas, imposed on everyday cops by their supervisors, were not only deeply unjust for the hundreds of thousands of New York City residents affected by these quotas who are frequently targeted and arrested without cause, but that the system is poisonous for officers themselves — actually breeding the worst instincts of racism, brutality, and corruption from the top down.
What I’m about to say could get slightly wonky, but I’m asking you to look past the legalese and understand that what we are talking about here are amazingly brave cops who put their lives and careers on the line to stand up for what they thought was right by not only speaking out against unjust practices within the department, but by actually suing the NYPD, their supervisors, and the City of New York to expose such things. I’m going to share five different cases with you that involve a combined 15 different NYPD officers who have taken the courageous step of filing suit to prove that the NYPD is illegally using arrest quotas. 13 of these officers are still currently working within the department. These are not jaded cops with an ax to grind. Filing these suits, while insisting on remaining cops within the NYPD, has made their day to day duty within the department a living hell. They’ve been harassed, ridiculed, and blacklisted, but have continued to push through not only because they love their jobs, but because they want to change the department from the inside out.
I’ll start with the most recent case and work my way backwards.
The NYPD 12 v. The City of New York, The Mayor of New York, The Police Commissioner, and the Commanding Officer of Patrol Services
Read their full 49 page lawsuit below. It’s some of the most deeply compelling stuff you’ll ever read. Again, because this lawsuit of twelve courageous officers standing against injustice within their own department broke during the Trump campaign, it appears to have gotten lost in the shuffle. It gets no bigger than this case.
Also, please read “A Black Officer’s Fight Against the NYPD” by Saki Knafo. This article masterfully unpacks the story of Edwin Raymond, who serves as the lead plaintiff in this case as well as many of the painful stories of the eleven other black and Latino officers who tried to do right by changing the department from within, only to suffer serious consequences as a result.
This is the most important lawsuit ever filed against the NYPD. It is currently up for review. Attorneys on the case, and officers who filed as plaintiffs, have each told me that the city has fought and delayed and stalled this case at every turn. The evidence of arrest quotas, and the mistreatment officers received for not meeting them, that they have compiled is both damning and undeniable.
I’ve met personally with seven of the plaintiffs — all current NYPD officers. They’ve put their lives on the line by filing this case. These are high-performing cops. They loathe crime and want to make the city safe, but simply put their foot down when they were expected to make arrests and meet quotas whether they saw crime or not. The officers have, of course, recorded extensive evidence of the illegal quota system to back their claims.
Here they are talking about it. You have to see this for yourself.
Here is Sgt. Edwin Raymond speaking at length about the racial quota systems.
These first two lawsuits are from respected police officers within the 42nd Precinct -which will be the focus of this series. The 42nd Precinct is the same crew that we will prove has attempted to frame Pedro Hernandez and so many other children in the community. These lawsuits have helped us understand why. The culture in this precinct is toxic. See how…
Officer Craig Matthews (of the 42nd Precinct) v. New York City & the NYPD
Officer Matthews is not only a 19 year veteran of the NYPD, but has won award after award for his great work — including stopping a crazed shooter in Manhattan near the Empire State Building. He was simply unwilling to arrest and charge people from crimes they didn’t commit — which is what the quota system in the 42nd Precinct was demanding officers do. When Matthews began reporting to his supervisors that he was being asked to do complete false arrests and meet illegal quotas, the mistreatment began. He tried to work within the system and when that didn’t work, he was finally forced to file this lawsuit exposing the NYPD’s illegal quota system.
See his full lawsuit here. It’s as compelling as it gets.
The US Circuit Court actually upheld his lawsuit. See it here:
Then New York City settled with Officer Matthews, who still works for the department. See that here. This man is a hero.
See a news segment on the settlement and lawsuit here:
Officer Vanessa Hicks (of the 42nd Precinct) v. New York City & the NYPD
In the same precinct as Officer Craig Matthews, Vanessa Hicks was being told that she, too, had to meet the arrest quota or suffer the consequences. She had a strong career in the department, but the NYPD derailed her career after she refused to participate in the quota system with false arrests.
See the full lawsuit here:
Officer Adhyl Polanco v. New York City & The NYPD
Officer Adhyl Polanco, who still works for the NYPD, was a pioneer in exposing quotas, police misconduct, false arrests, and forced/coerced confessions within the NYPD. Like others, he attempted to work within the system and only resorted to filing a lawsuit when his supervisors began to directly threaten his career because he exposed corruption.
See his full lawsuit here:
Officer Adrian Schoolcraft v. The NYPD and The City of New York
You just need to read this case file for yourself. When Officer Adrian Schoolcraft exposed an illegal arrest quota system within the NYPD — including extensive evidence of the system from recordings and data collection, he was literally forced to stay in a mental hospital for a psychiatric evaluation. Yeah, really. When he fled the city to stay with his father in upstate New York, he recorded the police coming to his father’s house to harass him over and over again. After years of fighting back against the NYPD, the City of New York and Jamaica Hospital finally settled with him.
See the full lawsuit here:
Here is a news video from that year on Officer Schoolcraft’s lawsuit:
All of this is to say that brave officers within the NYPD have made it clear that an illegal quota system, which relies on false arrests, false reports, and false confessions, drives the NYPD. We’re talking about a system that just had to throw out 900,000 bogus cases. This system, which must be exposed and rooted out, is the foundation of poor policing across the city. Police say this. It’s important to point out that because this isn’t a conspiracy theory from an activist or a hit piece from a journalist, today is about allowing the brave officers of the NYPD to describe the most critical problem they have for themselves. In these next four parts, we will show how arrest quotas have literally ruined the lives of family after family in one Bronx community and how the highest officials in the city have bent over backwards to conceal this unjust system. To be clear, this story has heroes, villains, and far too many victims.
A three-judge panel of the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has unanimously upheld the verdict in favor of Koua Fong Lee, the St. Paul man who sued the Toyota Corp. after he lost control of his Toyota Camry in 2006, resulting in the deaths of three people and his imprisonment.
In a 2015 trial, a jury found Lee 40 percent at fault and Toyota 60 percent at fault for the collision and awarded Lee and other crash victims $11.4 million.
The panel concluded that the evidence and testimony presented at trial gave a plausible explanation for Lee’s contention that his 1996 Camry accelerated while he tried to apply the brakes as he exited eastbound Interstate 94 at the Snelling Avenue exit. The Camry rear-ended a 1995 Oldsmobile Ciera, killing the Ciera’s driver and his son, and injuring the driver’s daughter, who died 16 months later, and two other relatives in the car.
Texas attorney Bob Hilliard, representing Lee in the trial in U.S. District Court in Minneapolis, argued that the accelerator stuck as a result of a manufacturing defect by Toyota.
Toyota appealed, saying U.S. District Judge Ann Montgomery improperly allowed irrelevant testimony at the trial. Three witnesses who testified that their 1996 Toyota Camrys inexplicably accelerated should not have been permitted to testify because their circumstances were different, the company argued.
The appeals court ruled that the jury listened to conflicting testimony and reached a reasonable conclusion.
“The jury’s verdict was not based on ‘sheer speculation,’ and instead is supported by reasonable inferences drawn from the plaintiffs’ evidence.
On one point, the appeals court said that Montgomery erred in awarding prejudgment interest to the mother of Devyn Bolton, the girl who died later from her injuries. It was not immediately clear from the appeals court decision, how much money that would entail.
Hilliard’s law firm said the $11.4 million verdict was the largest for sudden, unintended acceleration ever issued against Toyota.
Before the civil trial, Lee spent two years in prison after Ramsey County prosecuted him for the accident and a jury convicted him of criminal vehicular homicide. Hilliard won Lee’s release after presenting evidence that Toyota Camrys had a history of sudden, unintended acceleration. County prosecutors decided to not retry the criminal case.
After spending nearly three years in prison for a crime he did not commit, many might expect Koua Fong Lee to be bitter about the way life has treated him.
Instead, his words and actions convey a very different message—one of faith and gratitude.
Having emigrated with his family to St. Paul, Minn., in 2004, Lee had been in the country only a couple years when catastrophe struck. The 1996 Toyota Camry that Lee and his family were in—which was later proven to have a mechanical defect—accelerated and crashed into two other cars, killing three people. Despite Lee’s assertion that he had continually tried to brake, he was convicted of vehicular homicide and sent to prison.
Throughout the trial and his imprisonment, Lee didn’t lose faith. In fact, he gained it.
Lee recalled the morning well. Feeling stressed, he had sought out the prison’s library, pulling a book at random from the shelves and beginning to read, immediately feeling a connection to the words he found printed there.
“I felt like the words touched me,” Lee said, “I asked all the people, ‘What is this book?’ And they said, ‘This is the Bible.’”
To this day, Lee remembers the words that resonated so much with him.
Humble yourselves therefore under the mighty hand of God, so that he may exalt you in due time. Cast all your anxiety on him, because he cares for you. … And after you have suffered for a little while, the God of all grace, who called you to his eternal glory in Christ, will himself restore, support, strengthen, and establish you (1 Peter 5:6-10).
“I read it, and it made me feel relief from all of the stress that I had,” Lee said.
He signed up for a weekly Bible study to learn more, a choice for which is forever grateful. “When I was in prison, I saw that God is always on my side. When I had a difficult time, I read the Bible and it helped me go through everything.”
Support came in other ways, too. Many groups and individuals were inspired by his story and reached out to him, his wife, Panghoua Moua, and their four children.
Sylvia Dixen, a retired nurse and longtime Lutheran, was among them. After reading Lee’s story in the newspaper, she sent him a letter, which included her phone number.
“His story touched Sylvia’s heart,” said her husband, Bud Dixen, a retired ELCA pastor. “She herself was a refugee, born in India. She moved here at age 6 and always had an affinity with people who came from other places and didn’t have much.”
Despite Lee’s initial surprise at receiving the letter, he called Dixen to thank her, and the two struck up a friendship—one that would continue until her death in early 2013.
In August of 2010, Lee was released following the discovery that some Toyota models had problems with sudden acceleration. Gathering family and friends together to celebrate, Lee and Dixen finally met for the first time.
Although she passed away just a few years later, her husband has remained in touch with Lee and his family, continuing the friendship that started with that first call.
It is examples like this that inspire Lee now.
“Even though I was a stranger, she still wanted to talk to me and be a part of my life,” Lee said. “I’m still thinking about her, and I remember to get into another person’s life and make them happy like she did.”
After his release, Lee went back to school to do just that. He graduated in December from Metropolitan State University with a bachelor’s degree in social work.
The desire to give back is not a new one for Lee. It’s one he’s dreamed of for years.
Though born in Laos, Lee moved to Thailand when he was a child and spent the next 20 years living in a refugee camp. During that time, he said he witnessed the generosity of those who brought items to share with the refugees.
“I received many things from those people,” Lee said. “I think to myself that one day I will be like them and help other people. Now I have a chance to do that.”
Today Lee’s dream of helping other immigrants overcome their difficulties is finally coming true.
Krista Webb Webb is a freelance writer in St. Paul, Minn.
Barrett Brown | The Rule of Law Enforcement Barrett Brown, The Intercept Brown writes: "There's more to prison life than just sitting around despising the New York Times." READ MORE
The TPP: A Corporate Bill of Rights Larry Brown, teleSUR Brown writes: "What we aren't told by our governments is that these so-called trade deals are really not very much about trade at all. They are international corporate constitutions, aimed at limiting the ability of our governments to control transnational corporate behavior: an international Corporate Bill of Rights." READ MORE
Sanders Says He'll Debate Clinton on Thursday Jesse Byrnes, The Hill Byrnes writes: "Bernie Sanders said Wednesday morning that he would participate in a Democratic debate this week in New Hampshire after some negotiating between his campaign and presidential rival Hillary Clinton." READ MORE
Jimmy Carter on 2016 Election: Supreme Court Allows 'Legal Bribery' in Politics Julia Glum, International Business Times Glum writes: "Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter spoke out Wednesday about the 2016 presidential campaign, calling out Republican front-runner Donald Trump by name and blaming a Supreme Court decision for letting 'legal bribery' corrupt the campaign finance system." READ MORE
Dozens Convicted of Murder - Including 5 on Death Row - Were Exonerated Last Year Mark Berman, The Washington Post Berman writes: "There were 149 people exonerated in the United States last year after being wrongly convicted of crimes, a tally that included dozens convicted of murder and an uptick in people who had pleaded guilty or falsely confessed, according to a new report." READ MORE
Juan Thompson, Who Chronicled Tough St. Louis Background for National Media, Fired in Fabrication Scandal Doyle Murphy, Riverfront Times Murphy writes: "Juan Thompson, a national reporter who penned vivid essays about growing up poor in St. Louis, has been fired from The Intercept after his editors alleged he made up quotes and covered his tracks with fake email accounts." READ MORE
What We Know So Far About Sexual Transmission of Zika Virus Rae Ellen Bichel, NPR Bichel writes: "Experts say it's unclear how the virus remains in bodily fluids but hypothesize that it could hide in white blood cells." READ MORE
Ndume Olatushani is an artist, organizer, and a passionate advocate for justice who works with the Children’s Defense Fund’s Nashville organizing team. He helps us fight to keep children and people of color, especially Black boys, out of the Cradle to Prison Pipeline™ and mass incarceration system which will trap 1 in 3 Black boys born in 2001 sometime during their lifetime. He also combats zero tolerance school discipline policies that push Black children, especially Black boys, out of school and criminalize children of color. I met Ndume soon after he was freed as an inmate wrongly convicted of murder who served almost 28 years in prison, 20 on death row, before his release June 1, 2012. He’s a gentle, forgiving man. Long before that, Ndume was a small Black boy trying—and failing—to survive the violence, poverty, and low expectations that surrounded him.
Not long after his release from prison, he wrote his story:
“My name is Ndume Olatushani. I was born and raised in St. Louis, Missouri. I currently reside in the Nashville, Tennessee area. I spent my early years in the notorious Pruitt- Igoe Projects where the best and worst of human behavior were always on display. Because the Pruitt-Igoe Projects had become so lawless they were the first to be torn down by the federal government in the 1970's.
“At a young age I was exposed to all kind of things that no child should ever be exposed to. At the age of five I witnessed my first murder, which was of a young black man. At the time, I did not realize how this tragic event would help shape me but, like any child exposed to violence over a sustained period of time, I gradually became desensitized to violence. In some ways I became the people who stood around at the site of the playground murder, laughing and joking, as the young man took his last breaths.
“Though I officially dropped out of school in the eleventh grade, I had checked out of school mentally years earlier. In the newly integrated schools I attended, I experienced hostility from my white peers and discouragement from my teachers. My fourth grade teacher who was white asked my class what we wanted to be when we grew up. When I told her I wanted to be a veterinarian, her response was that I should instead aspire to do something with my hands, like construction.
“Years later, when I was sitting in a prison cell assessing my life, I understood the significance of her statement. As a child I did not understand the effect her statement had on me psychologically, and I did not understand the pathology of racism. Of course I do not lay the misguided decisions I made on her doorstep, but she was a part of the thread that weaved the quilt of my life. It was her and so many small but significant events that I was exposed to as a child that contributed to the trajectory of my life's decisions.
“As a young man, I began making some bad decisions that landed me in jail and prison on a range of felony charges. I have seen the inside of jails and prisons in four states. While I was making the decisions that landed me in all those jail and prison cells, I had no idea that the criminal record I was developing would lead to me being falsely accused and wrongly convicted of a robbery murder. I was 26 years old when, in 1985, I was wrongly convicted and sentenced to death for a murder that took place in Memphis, Tennessee, a state I had never even stepped foot in before standing trial there.
“It took 28 years — 20 of which I spent on death row—for me to finally prove that I was innocent. In December of 2011, a court overturned my conviction in the face of overwhelming proof that the prosecutors in my case had buried a mountain of evidence demonstrating my innocence. The bulk of the buried evidence showed that an entirely different group of suspects were the real perpetrators of the crime…
“I was red-lined for failure, although I do not absolve myself from the decisions that I made that helped make it possible. But those decisions were not without some guidance and direction from a system [whose] only use for some people is for them to be sitting in a jail or prison cell. We have to ensure that we are fully aware of this system and we have to continue to work hard at disrupting and dismantling this system to save our children.
“I feel strongly about not forgetting all the men I left behind in prison. I am deeply committed to working for criminal justice reform. The work [I and my coworkers are] doing to challenge polices resulting in the mass incarceration of people of color and especially the zero tolerance policies leading to the criminalization of our children is incredibly important to me and it should be to all of us. I witnessed what the policies of mass incarceration have done to generations and we don’t have to wonder about its effects on our future.”
Ndume taught himself to become a fine artist in prison and has not a bitter or mean bone in his body. He works tirelessly today with poor children, especially boys of color living in Nashville housing projects, encouraging alternatives to the street through art.
Ndume’s art along with his mentees’ creations grace our offices in Washington, D.C. and Tennessee to remind us of the gifts children have if we enable them to come forth and blossom and not discourage them. Every parent and educator ought to be very mindful about the power their words and attitudes convey to the children we raise and teach. They will live up or down to our expectations. Let’s make sure we lift them all up and give them something to strive toward.
Marian Wright Edelman is President of the Children's Defense Fund whose Leave No Child Behind® mission is to ensure every child a Healthy Start, a Head Start, a Fair Start, a Safe Start and a Moral Start in life and successful passage to adulthood with the help of caring families and communities. For more information go to www.childrensdefense.org.
Mrs. Edelman's Child Watch Column also appears each week on The Huffington Post.
Koua Fong Lee, left, and his wife, Panghoua Moua, react after hearing that charges against him were dropped, on August 5, 2010. (Pioneer Press: Ben Garvin)
Koua Fong Lee spent 2-1/2 years in prison for a crime he did not commit. Now, the state is prepared to put a dollar amount on his suffering.
Attorneys for Lee, who was convicted of criminal vehicular homicide after crashing his Toyota Camry in 2006, have filed a stipulation in Ramsey County District Court for him to receive compensation under a law that took effect July 1.
The Imprisonment and Exoneration Remedies Act provides a minimum of $50,000 per year of imprisonment, plus actual costs incurred by the defendant, for any individual wrongfully imprisoned who meets certain other requirements.
Lee is the first person to file for compensation under the new law, experts said.
Ramsey County Attorney John Choi joined in the stipulation, agreeing that Lee is eligible based on his exoneration.
"This was very easy for us to do, because this was the right thing to do," Choi said.
"Knowing what we do today, (the case) would not likely have been charged."
Lee, now 37, of St. Paul, was taking the Snelling Avenue exit from eastbound Interstate 94 in St. Paul on June 10, 2006, when he crashed into an Oldsmobile Ciera that was stopped for a red light.
He tried to slow his Camry.
"The brakes aren't working!" he yelled to his passengers, all members of his family.
Two people in the Oldsmobile, Javis Trice-Adams, 33, and Javis Adams Jr., 9, died instantly. Devyn Bolton died a year and a half later, at age 7, from complications of quadriplegia. Lee was charged with two counts of criminal vehicular homicide.
He was convicted at trial in 2007 and sentenced in January 2008 to eight years in prison. But after reports surfaced in 2009 and 2010 of sudden unintended acceleration in Toyotas, and questions arose about the trial attorney's handling of Lee's case, two new lawyers asked the judge to throw out his conviction.
Then-Ramsey County Attorney Susan Gaertner opposed the effort.
Judge Joanne Smith heard four days of testimony, which included harrowing accounts by other drivers of the same model vehicle as Lee's, a 1996 Camry, who had also experienced sudden acceleration.
She also heard testimony about the alleged mishandling of the trial by Lee's defense attorney at the time.
Once the testimony was in, the judge swiftly set Lee free.
The state then dismissed the charges.
The Minnesota Innocence Project helped get Lee out of prison and spearheaded the new legislation.
"I think it's a way of giving people something for the years that they lost in prison," said Julie Jonas, attorney with the Innocence Project.
"Money can't fix everything, but it's a starting point, and it can help."
Lee and another wrongly imprisoned man, Michael Hansen, testified at the Legislature this year for the bill.
Hansen, of Lonsdale, was convicted in the death of his baby daughter, but later showed the death was accidental.
Smith signed an order Tuesday determining that Lee is eligible for the money.
His case will now go to a panel of three attorneys or judges appointed by the Minnesota Supreme Court to determine a dollar amount.
The law calls for a damages award of between $50,000 and $100,000 per year spent in prison.
It also provides at least $25,000 for each year served on supervised release or as a registered predatory offender; those categories do not apply to Lee.Rep. John Lesch, DFL-St. Paul, a co-sponsor of the law, said it recognizes that, "as good as our system is," people are still wrongly put behind bars.
There was some initial resistance from the Minnesota County Attorneys Association, Lesch said, but that was to be expected."It looks initially like an attack. The natural tendency is to say, 'Something went wrong, we want to blame someone,' and it tends to be the prosecutor," he said. But Choi acted as a "very effective mediator."
Choi said the idea of a wrongful conviction implies that "people were intentionally trying to do bad things," and that did not happen with the Lee case.
"In Minnesota, I really believe we try to do the best that we can. We try to do justice," he said.
"Our worst nightmare is to convict an innocent person"
At the time Lee was charged, problems with unintended acceleration were not widely recognized.
Those involved in the trial, including the prosecution, the jury and the judge, were working in good faith, Choi said. Lee could not be reached Tuesday for comment.
His attorneys said he has earned his associate's degree and is working on a bachelor's degree. He hopes to become a social worker.
A civil case filed by Lee and the victims of the crash against Toyota is scheduled to go to trial Jan. 7 in U.S. District Court in Minneapolis.