Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts with label Stop Ethanol Trains Through Our Communities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stop Ethanol Trains Through Our Communities. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Explosive Crude-By-Rail Rolls Into Main Street America

The article below from EarthJustice highlights the growing alarm and opposition to the skyrocketing threat of rail transport of hazardous cargo through densely populated areas and fragile lands.

Please note that great concern was raised about the transport of  Explosive ETHANOL through Massachusetts.

Do we know what's in those rail cars?



Railroad cars for transporting oil line up at a station. (Arvydas Kniuksta / Shutterstock)
































Explosive Crude-By-Rail Rolls Into Main Street America


Is volatile crude oil coming by rail to a town near me? For weeks, I’ve been asking myself that question as I kept hearing about the skyrocketing number of trains that are transporting potentially explosive types of crude throughout the U.S. to East and West Coast export facilities.

And I’m not alone.

Recently, I attended a protest by my fellow neighbors in Berkeley, California, to stop crude-by-rail shipments coming through our town. The crude-oil boom is brought on by fracking in North Dakota and drilling in Canada’s Alberta tar sands. Both forms of crude are hazardous—Bakken shale crude from North Dakota is highly flammable and tar sands oil is extremely corrosive and also difficult to clean up.

Not surprisingly, once people hear how explosive and dangerous this crude can be when spilled, they really don’t want it traveling through their main streets…or anywhere else. But travel it does.

Hundreds of miles, in fact, through rural towns and along main streets, along densely populated areas like Chicago and Albany, and even inside windswept and vulnerable wild lands like Montana’s Glacier National Park.

I once drove a U-Haul along Yellowstone’s winding roads in my move from New York to California.

The sun was bright and the wind was calm, but I was still gripping the steering wheel the whole time.

Now imagine a 100-foot long train filled with millions of gallons of explosive crude oil traveling through that same area—in the dead of winter with the wind howling and the snow piling up on the tracks.

Seems like an accident just waiting to happen, right? Unfortunately, it already has, time and again. In fact, more oil spilled from trains last year than in the last four decades. And these spills can be catastrophic. Last July, a crude oil train derailed in Canada, decimating a town and killing 47 people.
Residents rally outside Berkeley City Hall.
Residents rally outside Berkeley City Hall to show opposition to a proposed crude by rail project. (Mauricio Castillo / Earthjustice)
These and other sobering statistics are causing communities to think twice about allowing these exploding trains onto their tracks. Last month, the City Council of Berkeley voted unanimously to oppose an oil company’s plans to transport crude oil through their town and other East Bay cities to a new refinery in nearby San Luis Obispo County. The council was backed by several people who showed up before the meeting to protest the crude by rail project.

East Bay resident Margaret Rossoff, who helps support communities in fighting refineries, compared crude by rail to “transporting dynamite.” Shoshanna Howard with the Center for Biological Diversity described the project as “preposterous,” adding that “We shouldn’t continue feeding into a fossil fuel system that has proven us wrong time and again.” Their concerns were echoed by many other local residents who felt strongly that we are going in the wrong direction by allowing more crude oil transport.

They are not alone.

In addition to Berkeley, the City Council of Richmond, another Bay Area community, also voted to oppose crude-by-rail plans that involved trains running through its city. In early February, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District issued energy company Kinder Morgan a permit to operate its crude-by-rail project, without any notice to the public or environmental and health review. Kinder Morgan is transporting volatile Bakken crude oil to Bay Area refineries using the same unsafe train cars involved in the explosion in Canada. Members of the Richmond community, perhaps even members of the air district’s Board of Directors, did not know that a permit to transport crude oil had been issued for over a month. The community’s opposition is backed by Earthjustice, which on behalf of environmental justice and conservation groups filed a lawsuit against Kinder Morgan and the air district and asked the court to halt operations immediately while the project undergoes a full and transparent review under the California Environmental Quality Act.

On the other side of the country, residents in the county of Albany, New York, feel similarly.

Recently, the county halted plans to expand crude-by-rail operations at its port terminal. The news followed pressure by a broad coalition—including community and environmental groups like Earthjustice—against the state Department of Environmental Conservation for its dangerously lax approach to skyrocketing shipments of crude-by-rail into the Port of Albany.

To Big Oil, these communities may look like places where it can transport millions of barrels of crude oil without drawing too much attention. But to people living near these tracks, like me and thousands of others, these communities are home. We have a right to know what hazards are moving in next door, a right to participate in decisions that impact our neighborhoods, and a right to health and environmental review of industrial activities before they happen.

We are not alone.


Related Audio Interview: Attorney Kristen Boyles discusses the fight to stop the expansion of crude-by-rail projects. Earthjustice, on behalf of communities and conservation groups, is fighting for the right of communities to stop these projects, which endanger public health and the environment. Listen to the interview:

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

Ignoring failures by the Feds.....

It's predictable that folks demand PIPELINES that leak and rupture as solution for the failures of the federal government to adequately fund oversight and regulation - the Bogey Man:
 
DEREGULATION!

Putting Corporate Profits above PUBLIC SAFETY explains a great deal.

We won't know the cause for ~ one year, but innocent communities have no way of knowing what's traveling in those freight cars and the threat they pose.



Mayor in N.D. seeks change in how oil is shipped


Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Railways involved in a rash of accidents, derailments, fires.....



Railways involved in a rash of accidents, derailments, fires in Canada in recent months



Railways involved in a rash of accidents, derailments, fires in Canada in recent months

The aftermath of a Sept. 25 train derailment near Landis, Sask., that spilled oil and forced the closure of a nearby school.

Photograph by: Canadian Press Files , Vancouver Sun, Postmedia file

Serious rail accidents in Canada since May 2013:

Oct. 19: Thirteen CN tanker cars - four laden with crude oil and nine carrying liquefied gas - came offthe rails just after midnight in the hamlet of Gainford, about 80 km. west of Edmonton. A massive fire ensued.

Oct. 17: Residents in the northwest Alberta town of Sexsmith were forced from their homes after four CN rail cars carrying anhydrous ammonia left the rails. The cars remained upright and there were no leaks.

Oct. 7: Four empty tanker cars that had been used to carry jet fuel went offthe track in Brampton, Ont. A CN employee suffered minor injuries and the derailment caused commuter delays for GO Train travellers.

Sept. 25: Seventeen CN rail cars, some carrying flammable petroleum, ethanol and chemicals, came offthe tracks near the village of Landis, in western Saskatchewan, in the middle of the night. A nearby school was closed as hazardous material crews cleaned up spilled oil. No one was injured.

Sep. 11: Eight cars of a CP train carrying a diluting agent used in oil pipelines derailed at a southeast Calgary rail yard. There were no injuries and no leaks from the cars, which were left lying on their sides. More than 140 homes were evacuated briefly.

July 27: A CP locomotive and seven tanker cars carrying oil left the tracks in Lloydminster, which straddles the northern Alberta-Saskatchewan boundary. Some diesel spilled from the locomotive and was contained. RCMP said nothing spilled from the cars, no one was injured and no evacuations were necessary.

July 8: An ammonia leak from a train caused the evacuation of roughly one-quarter of the population of the small northern Ontario town of Gogoma. No one was injured.

July 6: A runaway train of 72 tank cars loaded with crude oil crashed and exploded in the centre of Lac-Mégantic, Que., killing 47 people and destroying half the downtown area. The train, owned by Montreal, Maine & Atlantic Railway, was unmanned at the time.

June 27: Seven cars derailed as a bridge over the flood-swollen Bow River in Calgary collapsed when a CP train tried to cross it. Five cars carried petroleum products, one was filled with ethylene glycol and one was empty. No spills or injuries were reported but Calgary Mayor Naheed Nenshi demanded answers.

June 2: Eleven CP rail cars derailed on a trestle bridge near Wanup, east of Sudbury, Ont. There were no injuries, but the cars were carrying containers of consumer goods and about half of them entered a nearby river, prompting a drinking-water advisory.

May 21: Five cars on a CP train derailed near the village of Jansen in southeastern Saskatchewan and one of them spilled more than 91,000 litres of oil. There were no injuries.
 
 

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Nuclear train derailment leads to call for greater openness


Stop Ethanol Trains Through Our Communities offered the article below that highlights the lack of information to communities about Hazardous Rail Shipments:

Published: 27/09/2013

N-train derailment leads to call for greater openness

Written byWill Clark
Nigel Lowe, Dounreay director of the NDA, said investigations are being carried out into what caused the incident.
Nigel Lowe, Dounreay director of the NDA, said investigations are being carried out into what caused the incident.





A CALL is being made for the public to be better informed in the aftermath of accidents involving trains used to move nuclear materials.

It follows last week’s derailment in the north of England of two wagons which were carrying three empty flasks to the giant reprocessing complex at Sellafield.

Highland anti-nuclear campaigner Tor Justad claims the incident involving flasks which had been imported from Japan supports concerns about the rail shipments which have been hauling spent fuel from Dounreay to the Cumbrian plant.

An emergency was declared after the wagons left the tracks at Salthouse Junction, near Barrow station on September 16 while travelling at 5mph. Nobody was injured in the incident, which resulted in five fire teams being scrambled, along with radiation monitoring personnel from Sellafield.

Mr Justad, who wants the Dounreay runs stopped on safety grounds, said last week’s accident had caused a lot of concern in Cumbria.

He said the public should be told of the procedures in place, should a similar incident occur.

"Nobody was injured, but it proved accidents do happen," he said at Wednesday evening’s meeting of Dounreay Stakeholder Group.

"Post Fukashima, there has been a review of nuclear matters and emergency planning related to transport.

"There was alarm in the local community due to the amount of emergency service vehicles at the scene.

"It illustrates the need for more public information to be available so people know what is likely to happen."

Nigel Lowe, Dounreay director of the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA), said investigations are being carried out into what caused the incident, with the results being made public in October. He said this would also include how the public would be notified of any future such incidents.

"The Rail Accident Investigation branch is investigating what happened and will produce a report for publication in the next two to three weeks," added Mr Lowe.

"The communication strategy will be part of the investigation done by the rail authority and hopefully that will be addressed in the report."

The 11th shipment of fast reactor breeder material was transported from Dounreay to Sellafield this week by operator Direct Rail Services (DRS) – a wholly owned subsidiary of the NDA.

Initially, a total of 90 packages were to be transported between the two sites but in February, it was announced the remainder of Dounreay’s so-called "exotic" fuel would also be transported to Sellafield.

Nuclear material left over from Dounreay’s research work is being returned to the NDA’s national fuel stocks as part of the site’s clean up and closure.

The material – rods made from natural uranium that were irradiated inside the reactor to breed new plutonium fuel for power stations – belongs to the NDA. Sellafield has facilities to recover the fuel for its possible re-use in power stations.

Dounreay managing director Mark Rouse was made aware of what happened in Cumbria and has sought re-assurances from DRS that there would be no repeat of last week’s accident.

"The derailment was flagged up to us immediately. Work was stopped regarding shipments until we received assurances that it was safe to transport this material by rail," he said.

"When in doubt we stop and we ask questions before we start again."

http://www.johnogroat-journal.co.uk/Home/N-train-derailment-leads-to-call-for-greater-openness-26092013.htm

 

Stop Ethanol Trains Through Our Communities recipient of a 2013 All-Chelsea Award!


Did you know that we won an award?
Our committee was a recipient of a 2013 All-Chelsea Award! At the awards ceremony on Sept 30 held at City Hall Chambers we were presented with an award for Project of the Year: "A proposal to transport millions of gallons of ethanol through Chelsea was derailed by community advocates and appointed and elected officials this past year. When first proposed, the community was told that nothing could be done. That's when advocates took up the challenge and prevailed, once again showing that Chelsea can be equal to any test." (from the awards program.)
 
 
 
Update on Lac Megantic: delays and stalled efforts to improve safety. Sound familiar?
http://tinyurl.com/lypdrwd
 
A CN locomotive passes by freight containers at the CN Taschereau yard in Montreal. (GRAHAM HUGHES/THE CANADIAN PRESS)
A CN locomotive passes by freight containers at the CN Taschereau yard in Montreal. (GRAHAM HUGHES/THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Contract talks with CN Rail stall as union cites rail-safety concerns

 
 
Contract talks between Canadian National Railway Co. and the Teamsters have hit a rut, and the union is blaming an impasse over rail safety, the industry’s hot-button issue after a series of high-profile rail disasters this year.

The Teamsters Canada Rail Conference, which represents 3,300 conductors, train and yard workers and traffic co-ordinators with Canada’s largest railway company, said Monday that CN’s decision last week not to extend a conciliation process could lead to a strike or a lockout on Oct. 28. The collective agreement expired on July 22.

More Related to this Story


Union spokesman Roland Hackl said in a release the railway is “pointing a gun to its workers’ heads to force them to make concessions” that would require CN employees to work longer hours, with less rest time between trips. That, the union said, leaves it gearing up for a fight to ensure the safety of Canadians and rail workers.

CN spokesman Mark Hallman said “none of [CN’s] bargaining proposals would in any way compromise the health and safety” of its employees and would in fact improve health and safety, though he offered no specifics. Talks are set to resume Oct. 21 with federally appointed mediators and CN “remains optimistic” a deal can be reached without a labour disruption, he added.

Rail safety has come to the forefront since the derailment of an oil train in the heart of Lac-Mégantic, Que., and subsequent conflagration left 47 people dead. Other high-profile accidents, including a fatal train-bus collision in Ottawa last month, have led to calls for a range of measures to improve rail safety and exposed several regulatory rifts between railway companies, regulators and municipalities.

Last month, Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd. CEO Hunter Harrison warned another Lac-Mégantic-type disaster could happen if regulators don’t impose tougher rules for transporting hazardous materials, while a Senate report in August called on Ottawa to force railways to retire tank cars that are prone to leakage in derailments.

The issue has also taken on added prominence in the Teamsters’ communications about its talks with CN. In an update sent by the union to members on June 21, two weeks before the Lac-Mégantic tragedy, the word “safety” does not appear, with the focus instead on proposed changes that would affect scheduling, reduce staffing on trains and increase the company’s flexibility in assigning work tasks. By last month, the union had recast its dispute with CN as an issue of employee and public health, with Mr. Hackl stating “the Lac-Mégantic tragedy can’t be in vain; the health and safety of workers and the public are not negotiable. Period.”

The negotiations come after a seven-year period in which the number of rail accidents in Canada has fallen steadily.

The renewed concerns about rail safety come after a period of improving safety performance for the industry: the number of accidents in Canada fell in six of the past seven years, dropping to 1,011 incidents in 2012 from 1,476 in 2005. “What the statistics indicate is that in general the railways are getting safer,” said David Jeanes, president of Transport Action Canada, a national public transportation advocacy group.

However, he noted the number of accidents dropped only marginally in 2012 from 2011 levels, while the number of accidents as of July, 2013, was up 1.2 per cent from the same level a year earlier. “The question is, have attempts to reduce these issues gone as far as they can go, or has [the industry] in fact stopped spending enough on safety to get continuous improvement?”




Sunday, September 15, 2013

Wall St. Exploits Ethanol Credits, and Prices Spike

Stop Ethanol Trains Through Our Communities



Wall St. Exploits Ethanol Credits, and Prices Spike


Jay Paul for The New York Times
The Chesapeake, Va., operations of TransMontaigne, an oil and gas transportation company that Morgan Stanley bought in 2006 and which has generated biofuel credits for it.

By GRETCHEN MORGENSON and ROBERT GEBELOFF

It was supposed to help clean the air, reduce dependence on foreign oil and bolster agriculture. But a little known market in ethanol credits has also become a hot new game on Wall Street.

The federal government created the market in special credits tied to ethanol eight years ago when it required refiners to mix ethanol into gasoline or buy credits from companies that do so. The idea was to push refiners to use the cleaner, renewable fuel, or force them to buy the credits.
 
A few worried that Wall Street would set out to exploit this young market, fears the government dismissed. But many people believe that is what happened this year when the price of the ethanol credits skyrocketed 20-fold in just six months, according to an analysis of regulatory documents and interviews with more than 40 people involved in the market, including industry executives, brokers, traders and analysts.
      
Traders for big banks and other financial institutions, these people say, amassed millions of the credits just as refiners were looking to buy more of them to meet an expanding federal requirement. Industry executives familiar with JPMorgan Chase’s activities, for example, told The Times that the bank offered to sell them hundreds of millions of the credits earlier this summer. When asked how the bank had amassed such a stake, the executives said they were told by the bank that it had stockpiled the credits.
 
A spokesman for JPMorgan, when asked about the exchange with the executives, disputed the account, saying the bank does not trade ethanol credits for a profit in the way it trades other securities, but is registered to deal in credits through its energy business. From time to time, the spokesman, Brian J. Marchiony, said in a statement that the bank also purchased credits “on behalf of clients who need to fulfill their E.P.A.-mandated obligations,” though it had not done so in the past year.
 
But other market participants, including Thomas D. O’Malley, chairman of PBF Energy in Parsippany, N.J., identified JPMorgan Chase and other financial institutions as being active sellers of the credits this year. He said the institutions had helped transform an environmental program into a profit machine, contributing to the market frenzy this year. “These things were designed to monitor the inclusion of ethanol in the gasoline pool,” Mr. O’Malley said. “They weren’t designed to become a speculative item. For the life of me I can’t see the justification for it.”
 
While banks are by no means the largest player in ethanol credits, Wall Street’s activity in this market reflects a larger effort by financial institutions to exert their influence over loosely regulated markets for basic commodities, from aluminum to oil. The opacity of the ethanol credit market makes it difficult to determine the extent to which large financial actors have profited.
 
The banks say they have far less influence in the market than others are suggesting, and are doing nothing wrong. But the activities, while legal, could have consequences for consumers. In the end, energy analysts say, the outcome will be felt at the gas pump — as the higher cost of the ethanol credits gets tacked onto the price of a gallon of gasoline. (The credits, which cost 7 cents each in January, peaked at $1.43 in July, and now are trading for 60 cents.)
 
The Valero Energy Corporation, a refiner that owns thousands of gas stations, says the squeeze in ethanol credits might cost it $800 million. PBF Energy, also a refiner, puts its bill at about $200 million. A review by The Times of a federal registry of nearly 1,500 businesses and individuals in the renewable fuel market found big Wall Street banks as well as a handful of people with troubled legal histories among the participants. Several high-profile cases of fraud have emerged.
 
Scott Mixon, the acting chief economist of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, said in an interview Friday that the issue of banks’ involvement in this market was something the agency was tracking and might look into more deeply because of the ethanol component. The commission regulates the commodities futures market, including trading in ethanol and gasoline.
      
Though the ethanol credits are traded by many major investment houses, they were created not on Wall Street but in Washington, on Capitol Hill and at the Environmental Protection Agency. At its inception, the so-called Renewable Fuel Standard was promoted as a means to reduce the nation’s reliance on foreign oil, fight global warming and provide a boost to farmers. The rules call for a set amount of ethanol, most of which is made from corn, and other renewable fuels to be blended with fossil fuels each year, with quotas assigned to individual refiners and importers.
 
Great article! Read the rest here:
 

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Crude that exploded in Lac-Mégantic was mislabelled: officials

When weekend passenger train service to Cape Cod travelling through Middleboro was begun, Middleboro Selectmen, Town Departments and concerned citizens justifiably expressed grave concerns.

Middleboro and many Massachusetts communities have rail freight lines carrying hazardous cargoes that are undisclosed, may be mislabelled. How do we know?





"Canadian investigators say the oil was inconsistently described, raising questions about the regulation of crude shipments in North America."

Crude that exploded in Lac-Mégantic was mislabelled: officials




Friday, September 6, 2013

Danger on the tracks: Unsafe rail cars carry oil through US towns





Danger on the tracks: Unsafe rail cars carry oil through US towns

Critics worry that trains carrying tons of crude oil aren't safe and pose a danger to surrounding communities. NBC's Lisa Myers reports.



Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy


The number of freight trains carrying oil across America has soared in the past five years, but federal officials warn that the massive steel tank cars that carry most of that oil through towns and past schools – the same cars that exploded in Quebec this summer, killing 47 -- may be unsafe and prone to rupture.

“The clock is ticking,” said Jim Arie, fire chief of the Chicago suburb of Barrington, Ill., where the number of trains that rumble across Main Street has grown from five a day to nearly one an hour. “As long as these rail cars are out there and they’re being used, potential exists for a major disaster.”

For two decades, federal officials have warned that the tank car that carries oil and ethanol, known as the DOT-111, has a serious design flaw and can split open in an accident, turning a derailment into a fiery catastrophe. At least five times since 1991, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) has raised concerns about the car’s design, including its relatively thin metal skin and the possibility that cars could tear holes in each other during accidents, creating a domino effect of spills.

“If we don’t start upgrading these cars soon, my concern is that we will have a catastrophic event in the near future,” said transit safety expert John Goglia, who served on the NTSB's board from 1995 to 2004. "Even if the car doesn't crumble and get destroyed in a derailment, 66 percent of the cars are going to spill whatever product is in there, and there is some pretty hazardous material being carried around in these cars."

Yet the government has done little, allowing the industry to make some voluntary safety upgrades but leaving most of the DOT-111s in service and unaltered. Just after the Quebec crash, the agency charged with regulating tank cars, the Pipeline and Hazard Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), put off acting for another year, though this week the agency agreed to start considering safety upgrades.

In Barrington, the people who live close to the tracks are tired of waiting.

“It’s unbelievable that something that can have this kind of impact hasn’t been addressed,” said Karen Darch, Barrington’s “president,” or mayor.

Steve Morrissey, whose window looks out on Barrington’s busy tracks, said he sleeps “with one eye open” and has prepared an emergency evacuation plan.

“I have told my family that it would not be a matter of if, but a matter of when.”

For more on oil trains, watch "NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams" tonight.


Oil train traffic is rising because the domestic oil business is booming, with production at its highest point since 1993. In a bid for freedom from foreign oil, America has stepped up ethanol production and new oil extraction methods like hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking.” North Dakota alone is now producing more than 820,000 barrels per day.

The result: the amount of crude and ethanol traveling by rail has skyrocketed. According to figures from the Association of American Railroads (AAR), just 9,500 carloads of crude and 220,000 carloads of ethanol moved by rail in 2008. Last year the combined figure for crude and ethanol was 600,000 cars. About 70 percent of North Dakota’s oil and 70 percent of the nation’s ethanol now moves by rail.

Nearly all of the cars in the swelling fleet of mile-long oil trains crisscrossing the country are DOT-111s, which hold up to 30,000 gallons apiece.

The oil train that exploded in Lac Megantic, Quebec in July, killing 47 people and destroying half the downtown, was made up of DOT-111s. Canadian authorities are investigating the tank cars, the volatility of the oil, and the handling of the train as possible factors in the tragedy.


NBC News
Steve Morrissey of Barrington, Ill., walks on the train tracks near his house. The boom in domestic oil and ethanol means that the number of freight trains rumbling through the heart of this Chicago suburb and past the window of his house has grown from five a day to nearly one an hour.


In 2009, an ethanol train comprised of DOT-111s derailed and caught flame in Cherry Valley, Ill., 50 miles west of Barrington, killing one person and injuring nine others.

In a 2012 report on the crash, NTSB investigators again criticized the cars, concluding that the “inadequate design of the DOT-111 tank cars” played a large role in the catastrophic nature of the Cherry Valley crash, illustrating their “inability ... to withstand the forces of accidents.”

Before the report was issued, however, the industry decided to take action. In order to get out in front of any new regulations, the industry convened a task force led by the AAR to weigh revisions to DOT-111 standards.


In 2011, the task force issued voluntary standards that required newly built cars carrying crude and ethanol to have thicker steel shells, improved valve coverings, and end shields to prevent punctures – all attempts to address problems the NTSB had long highlighted. The AAR also petitioned PHMSA to adopt higher federal standards for the DOT-111.

“The industry continues to look forward to action on this request from PHMSA,” said AAR spokesperson Holly Arthur in a statement, “and in the meantime has adopted the higher tank car specifications so that all new tank cars carrying … crude oil and ethanol ordered after October of 2011 are being built to these higher standards.”

Read the AAR's full statement here.

The new cars are gradually being added to the existing fleet, but most cars predate the changes.

According to the AAR, about 25 percent of the approximately 32,000 cars that carry crude now meet the higher standards. Numbers for ethanol cars are less clear, but according to the Renewable Fuels Association, which represents the industry, most of the fleet of 63,000 cars is more than three years old, predating the upgrade.

The NTSB, which can only issue recommendations, not regulations, has argued that mingling the new, sturdier cars with older cars defeats the purpose of the upgrade, saying the intended safety benefits are “not realized.” The old thin-skinned cars are still vulnerable to rupture, and the newer, heavier cars can still damage them during collisions.

But the industry would prefer to replace the old-style cars by attrition. And the old-style cars can last for 40 years.

The industry has also resisted improving the existing cars via retrofitting because of technical issues.

While the industry says it's not opposed to retrofitting in principle, the AAR asserted in written comments to regulators in 2011 that retrofitting would make the cars too heavy and inhibit their movement. The group also said that derailments over the preceding five years had cost $64 million, while retrofitting all crude and ethanol DOT-111s would run $1 billion.

“There were no feasible options that could be applied to all existing and new cars,” said the AAR.
Christopher Barkan of the University of Illinois, whose extensive safety research has been used by both industry and government, agreed that making upgrades to older DOT-111s is not as simple as it may seem. “Retrofitting is the most difficult issue and it’s not just a matter of money,” Barkan said.

“These cars are complicated engineering structures that move hundreds of thousands of miles and absorb all kinds of shocks and vibrations.” The effectiveness of retrofits would vary depending on the particular car and retrofit, he said, and in some cases adding extra protection and weight to existing cars may not be technically feasible.

In the wake of July’s devastating crash in Quebec, however, both the Canadian and U.S. governments are taking a fresh look at the DOT-111. The train, carrying crude from North Dakota across Canada, derailed just miles from the Maine border, and had been set to cross back into the States.

On Wednesday, the PHMSA announced that it wanted to identify “additional safety enhancements” recommended by the industry task force two years ago and then “provide the public an opportunity to comment.” The process could take 18 months.

In a statement, the AAR emphasized its commitment to safety, and its record. “Freight railroads are always seeking to learn how to make their safety record ever stronger,” said spokesperson Holly Arthur. “Today, 99.997 percent of all rail hazmat shipments reach their destination without a release caused by a train accident.” Arthur also noted that the trade group had asked the government to institute tougher standards in 2011.

Former NTSB board member John Goglia said it was "pretty disheartening" that regulators "haven't addressed those problems. … [O]ur government has not risen to the occasion.”

Lisa Riordan Seville is a researcher with the NBC News investigative unit. Lisa Myers is the Senior Investigative Correspondent at NBC News.


Monday, August 12, 2013

Freight Trains

Massachusetts communities have NO control over the hazardous cargo.

This horrific tragedy highlights the threats posed by RAIL FREIGHT SHIPMENTS and the lack of regulations.




What insurance coverage is required in US?

Tanker cars are owned by the shippers and other freight cars are owned by railroads. Railroads are “common carriers” which must carry these shippers’ cargoes, even though they have no control over the safety standards of the tanker cars carrying them.




VIDEO

How the oil spill is being cleaned at Lac-Mégantic
Reporter Kim Mackrael joins Hannah Sung to discuss the oil spill at Lac-Mégantic and efforts to clean it up


VIDEO

How will the MM&A bankruptcy affect the families of Lac-Mégantic victims?
Justin Giovannetti joins Hannah Sung to discuss how the Montreal, Maine & Atlantic bankruptcy filing will affect families' and businesses' lawsuits against the railway.


Crews work in the area of the derailed tanker cars in Lac-Mégantic on July 14, 2013. The train derailment and subsequent fires and explosions destroyed much of the downtown area of the picturesque Quebec town. (Peter Power/The Globe and Mail)
Crews work in the area of the derailed tanker cars in Lac-Mégantic on July 14, 2013. The train derailment and subsequent fires and explosions destroyed much of the downtown area of the picturesque Quebec town. (Peter Power/The Globe and Mail)

Canadian Transportation Agency approved MM&A’s coverage

LAC-MEGANTIC, QUE. — The Globe and Mail




Thursday, August 8, 2013

Do you think you're safe?

A train destroyed a community, killing many.

The Corporate solution? File for bankruptcy.

Is our community safe?

These Big Corporations fight reasonable regulations, destroy communities, spill their contents, jeopardize public safety......


ARE WE SAFE?    NO!


Stop Ethanol Trains Through Our Communities
Well, this was certainly inevitable. And highlights the need for regulations that would require that anyone transporting hazardous materials have sufficient funds to cover the costs associated with possible accidents.

Canadian railway company in runaway train crash files for bankruptcy

By CNN Staff
updated 4:23 PM EDT, Wed August 7, 2013
 
Edward Burkhardt, CEO of Montreal, Maine & Atlantic Railways Inc., speaks on Wednesday, July 10, during a news conference. A train with 72 tanker cars carrying crude oil barreled down the track before <a href='http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/10/world/americas/canada-runaway-train/index.html?hpt=hp_c3'>derailing and exploding in Lac -Megantic, Quebec</a>, on Saturday, July 6.Edward Burkhardt, CEO of Montreal, Maine & Atlantic Railways Inc., speaks on Wednesday, July 10, during a news conference. A train with 72 tanker cars carrying crude oil barreled down the track before derailing and exploding in Lac -Megantic, Quebec, on Saturday, July 6.

(CNN) -- The Montreal, Maine and Atlantic Railway Ltd., the train company involved in the deadly crash last month in Lac-Megantic, Quebec, that left at least 42 people dead, filed for bankruptcy in the United States and Canada, the railway said Wednesday.
The unmanned, runaway 73-car train slammed into the center of Lac-Megantic in the early morning of July 6, and tank cars full of oil exploded and burned in the heart of the commercial district.
The train had been parked in the neighboring Quebec town of Nantes but it rolled into motion after the engineer went to a hotel. The accident is under investigation.