Search This Blog

Translate

Blog Archive

Middleboro Review 2

NEW CONTENT MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW 2

Toyota

Since the Dilly, Dally, Delay & Stall Law Firms are adding their billable hours, the Toyota U.S.A. and Route 44 Toyota posts have been separated here:

Route 44 Toyota Sold Me A Lemon



Showing posts sorted by relevance for query nuclear energy. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query nuclear energy. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, March 17, 2011

U.S. Nuclear Policy Governed by Lobbyists & Campaign Contributions

Nuclear Energy is extremely expensive, riddled with cost overruns and subsidized by U.S. taxpayers.

From a strictly cost/benefit analysis, Nuclear Energy has never made any sense, and that's before we consider the cost of 'waste.'



Consider this -- Nuclear Energy costs

$7,500 per kilowatt to build


That’s more than double the capital costs for solar power and three and a half times the cost for wind.

the most heavily subsidized industry in the energy sector.

In 2005, Congress handed the nuclear power industry $13 billion in federal aid, and two years later went on to approve an additional $20.5 billion in loan guarantees, making U.S. taxpayers the cosigners on loans for new nuclear projects -- half of which are expected to end in defaults.

Wind is already more competitive than electricity generated from new nuclear and coal-fired power plants.


From Democracy Now:

“Serious Danger of a Full Core Meltdown”: Update on Japan’s Nuclear Catastrophe


From the Institute for Southern Studies:


Duke Energy's nuclear ambitions face fallout from Japanese crisis
[worth reading in its entirety]
With the nuclear crisis in Japan growing more alarming by the hour, Duke Energy CEO Jim Rogers appeared before the North Carolina Utilities Commission yesterday to ask for permission to spend an additional $267 million for the planning of two new reactors at its Lee plant in South Carolina. If approved, the request would bring the amount Duke will pay for pre-construction work there to $459 million -- money it's expected to seek to recoup from ratepayers.



INSTITUTE INDEX - U.S. nuclear-powered politics

Amount the nuclear power industry spent on lobbying from 2000 to 2010:
$600 million

Amount the industry spent during that same period on campaign contributions:
nearly $63 million

Amount the Nuclear Energy Institute -- an industry trade group whose members include the company that owns the imperiled Japanese nuclear plant -- spent lobbying the federal government during the past three years:
$6.12 million

Number of federal lobbyists on the NEI's roster:
more than 20

Amount that Atlanta's Southern Company, which has major nuclear investments and is seeking to build new reactors, has spent on federal lobbying efforts each year since 2004:
at least $10 million

Amount that the PAC for Duke Energy, which is also planning to build new nuclear reactors, spent during the 2010 election: $1.45 million

Percent of Duke Energy PAC's money that went to Democrats:
55

Amount of credit line that North Carolina-based Duke Energy recently guaranteed for the upcoming Democratic National Convention in Charlotte: $10 million

Under new Democratic Party rules, amount at which corporate contributions for the convention are supposed to be capped:
$100,000

Amount Duke Energy plans to spend building new reactors that still need state and federal approvals: $11 billion

Date on which the German government called for a "measured exit" from nuclear power and a speedy transition to renewable energy: 3/17/2011

Date on which the Chinese government said it would suspend approvals for nuclear power plants so it can conduct safety checks:
3/16/2011

Since the Japanese crisis erupted last week, number of U.S. lawmakers who have been briefed by NEI lobbyists seeking to head off any restrictions on nuclear power:
about 50

Date on which Energy Secretary Steven Chu said the Obama administration would press ahead with efforts to encourage new reactor construction:
3/16/2011

Total amount the White House is seeking in taxpayer-backed nuclear loan guarantees, $8.3 billion of which have already been set aside already for two new reactors at Southern Co.' s Plant Vogtle in Georgia.:
$54 billion

Amount the nuclear power industry has received in federal subsidies since its inception in 1948:
tens of billions



Problematic design of Japan's imperiled nuclear reactors common in U.S.
The nuclear power disaster triggered by the massive earthquake and tsunami that struck Japan on Friday is worsening by the day and raising concerns about nuclear safety in the United States.


Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Nuclear Industry Welfare

At the top of this page is a 'search' feature that allows review of previous posts.
A search for nuclear, nuclear energy, alternative energy reveals some interesting information some of which is posted below.

Safety concerns aside, Nuclear Energy is too expensive and unfeasible without taxpayer-funded guarantees and exemptions.



The Nuclear Industry is yet one more example of Democracy Bought and Sold with generous campaign contributions and a battalion of lobbyists not serving the public or national interests.




Because Solar and Wind lack the profitability to buy necessary support [translation: politicians], the nation remains paralyzed by archaic energy sources that jeopardize our future.

As the Washington Post article below highlights, ratepayers will be forced to bear the high costs of these dumb decisions.


From Nuclear:

Consider this -- Nuclear Energy costs

$7,500 per kilowatt to buildThat’s more than double the capital costs for solar power and three and a half times the cost for wind.

the most heavily subsidized industry in the energy sector.

In 2005, Congress handed the nuclear power industry $13 billion in federal aid, and two years later went on to approve an additional $20.5 billion in loan guarantees, making U.S. taxpayers the cosigners on loans for new nuclear projects -- half of which are expected to end in defaults.

Wind is already more competitive than electricity generated from new nuclear and coal-fired power plants.



In U.S., nuclear energy loses momentum amid economic head winds, safety issues

Mark Ralston/AFP/Getty Images - Fishermen beside the San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant in north San Diego
County in 2011.


By ,
Published: March 11

Two years after the tsunami that crippled Japan’s Fukushima power complex, the U.S. nuclear industry is facing fundamental and far-reaching challenges to its own future.

Only five years ago, industry executives and leading politicians were talking about an American nuclear renaissance, hoping to add 20 or more reactors to the 104-unit U.S. nuclear fleet.

But today those companies are holding back in the face of falling natural gas prices and sluggish and uncertain electricity demand. Only five new plants are under construction, while at least that many are slated for permanent closure or shut down indefinitely over safety issues.

On Monday, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) reiterated its refusal to issue a license for a new unit at Calvert Cliffs, Md., that a French company had hoped to make the model for a fleet of reactors. A pair of reactors in Southern California are under scrutiny over whether a major contractor and a utility there concealed concerns about potential cracks in the tubes of a steam generator. And nuclear plants in Wisconsin and Florida are closing down because their owners said they cannot compete with less expensive natural-gas-fired electricity.

Industry officials still make the case for nuclear as a domestic source of energy that does not emit greenhouse gases. “Anyone concerned about global warming should acknowledge that if society seriously aspires to be anti-carbon, it also needs to be seriously pro-nuclear,” Thomas F. Farrell, chief executive of Dominion Resources, said at a recent conference in Washington sponsored by the industry newsletter Platts. 

Outrageous and Untrue! This disingenuous comment ignores that Solar and Wind are already CHEAPER than Nuclear. Anyone concerned about Global Warming will work to reduce their consumption first - the best form of Energy available.

But Caren Byrd, executive director of Morgan Stanley’s global power group, said at the same conference that, on an economic basis, “it is hard to make the case for nuclear.”

One illustration of that is a joint venture called UniStar, formed to build half a dozen identical nuclear units modeled on a new reactor planned at the existing Calvert Cliffs site. But the Atomic Energy Act bars foreign companies from having “ownership, control or domination” of U.S. nuclear plants, which became a problem in late 2010 when Constellation Energy gave up its 51 percent stake in the joint venture and left UniStar wholly owned by Electricite de France.

Since then, UniStar has been unable to find another U.S. partner. On Monday, the NRC reiterated that it would not issue a license to UniStar, which had asked the NRC to overturn the prohibition on foreign ownership.

Low natural gas prices are discouraging other nuclear investors and utilities. “The natural gas issue is terrific for the U.S. economy and energy mix,” John J. Reed, chairman of Concentric Energy Advisors, said at a Platts meeting of nuclear executives. “It just isn’t so good for those of you sitting out there today.”

Dominion, the owner of the Kewaunee nuclear plant in Wisconsin, and Duke Energy, owner of Crystal River Unit 3 in Florida, recently announced plans to permanently close these reactors because of economic factors, even though the plants have licenses extending well into the future. Wind and natural gas are cheaper.


The Nuclear Industry consistently has cost overruns that make it no longer competitive, such as these --



The NRC has also been keeping an eye on a pair of new reactors the Southern Co. has been building at its Vogtle complex in Georgia. Financing costs were lowered sharply by a promise of a federal loan guarantee by the Obama administration and by a Georgia state law that allows Southern’s subsidiary, Georgia Power, to pass much of the cost along to ratepayers while the plant is under construction. Most states require a power plant to go online before customers have to pay for it.

Within months, however, Southern said that as much as $900 million could be added to its subsidiary’s share of the $14 billion cost. An industry consultant, who requested anonymity to preserve his business relationships, said that the contractor put too much space between steel rebar in the foundations at the heart of the new reactors. To resolve the problem, Southern said it created a 1,000-cubic-yard “mock-up” of the site where concrete would be poured.


Worth reading in its entirety:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/2013/03/11/fb6d61c2-715e-11e2-ac36-3d8d9dcaa2e2_story.html

 

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Nuclear Energy: Not A Solution #2

For the last decade, watching the stealth of the nuclear industry and the long overdue eruption of energy and Climate Change on the consciousness of Americans, I have long advocated the necessity of doing the evaluation of the energy issue on a personal level to reach sensible solutions, rather than absorbing and repeating industry PR, like the spin of Entergy.
.
Were weatherization and energy efficiency or renewables (solar or wind or geo-thermal or tidal/wave generation), subsidized at the levels of nuclear or fossil fuels, this would be a Congressional No-Brainer.
.
And were the costs of disposal and decommissioning included, this would be a Congressional Non-Issue.
.
I happened upon an article the clearly explained the chronology of the nuclear public relations and lobbying campaign in Washington Monthly.
.
Excerpts of the massive subsidies, loan guarantees and exemption from liability and major lobbying efforts follow, but it is important to recognize that renewable are cost competitive.
.
Nuclear only makes sense if $7,500 Per Kilowatt makes sense. That does not include disposal and decommissioning.
.
In 2001, the Bush administration took office and began working to overhaul government agencies to make them friendlier to the industry. Layers of NRC regulation were stripped away. At the DOE, the top position in the Office of Nuclear Energy was promoted to an assistant-secretary-level appointment, and a host of new programs were added to promote the resurgence of atomic energy—among them Nuclear Power 2010, under which the government pays half the cost of site selection, planning, and licensing for new nuclear reactors.

The industry, meanwhile, worked to shift public perception, through an aggressive PR campaign that involved, among other things, planting ghostwritten op-eds advocating nuclear energy in local newspapers under the names of prominent local personalities, and setting up front groups that appeared to be independent environmental organizations, such as the New Jersey Affordable, Clean, Reliable Energy Coalition. It also began pressing Congress for subsidies and, starting in 2001, federal loan guarantees. But nuclear advocates made little headway on this front until 2003, when Republicans regained control of the Senate and Domenici was appointed chairman of the Energy Committee. He rehired Alex Flint, who had gone on to work as a nuclear power lobbyist, to direct the committee’s work. Flint spent the next two years wrangling with politicians, often in secret, over a new energy bill.

... [President George W. Bush] signed the Domenici-sponsored Energy Policy Act of 2005 into law. The act fulfilled many of the industry’s key legislative ambitions. Most importantly, it provided unlimited federal loan guarantees to cover up to 80 percent of project costs for next-generation nuclear plants and other "innovative technologies" to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It also included a twenty-year extension of the Price-Anderson Act, which limits the liability of nuclear power plant operators in case of accidents, and $13 billion in direct subsidies for nuclear power, including $2 billion in "risk insurance" to pay extra costs caused by delays in construction and licensing for the first six new reactors.

...in less than a decade, the nuclear power industry had gone from energy pariah to political heavyweight. Its lobbying operation was now among the most formidable on Capitol Hill, thanks to a generous infusion of cash. (Since the mid-1990s, the energy and nuclear power sector has spent at least $953 million lobbying Congress and the executive branch, according to the Center for Responsive Politics—more than any group except the pharmaceutical and insurance industries.) That money helped the industry to meet most of the goals laid out at the 1998 forum and win tens of billions of dollars in new subsidies. All told, the nuclear power sector has secured more than $100 billion in federal support, at least $25 billion of it in the last four years alone, according to the nonpartisan group Taxpayers for Common Sense.
.
That’s far more than renewable energy sources.
.
Nuclear Energy Institute... was estimating $1,100 and $1,500 per kilowatt capacity—roughly on par with natural gas plants and cheaper than coal.
.
In October 2007, Moody’s Investor Services piled on with a report projecting that new reactors would cost $5,000 to $6,000 per kilowatt to build, or up to $12 billion per unit.
.
...Moody’s, ... now predicts
.
new nuclear power plants will cost $7,500 per kilowatt to build.
.
That’s more than double the capital costs for solar power and three and a half times the cost for wind.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

U.S. Nuclear Industry Goes Nuclear

At the prospect of the Japanese Nuclear Disaster, the U.S. Nuclear Industry and its Lobbyists and supporters moved into overdrive to assure Americans that nuclear was somehow SAFE and sensible.

Setting aside all of the realistic safety issues and numerous other arguments AGAINST nuclear energy, Nuclear is ONLY cost effective because the American taxpayers subsidize it.

From Nuclear:

Consider this -- Nuclear Energy costs

$7,500 per kilowatt to build


That’s more than double the capital costs for solar power and three and a half times the cost for wind.

the most heavily subsidized industry in the energy sector.

In 2005, Congress handed the nuclear power industry $13 billion in federal aid, and two years later went on to approve an additional $20.5 billion in loan guarantees, making U.S. taxpayers the cosigners on loans for new nuclear projects -- half of which are expected to end in defaults.

Wind is already more competitive than electricity generated from new nuclear and coal-fired power plants.

When policy makers toss reason, sanity and judicious fiscal decision aside, one can only conclude that the U.S. Nuclear Industry got its $600 million dollars' worth.

The article below, written by Amory Lovins, explains nuclear energy in simple terms:


Nuke nukes
[Click on the link for additional information]
What we can learn from Japan’s nuclear disaster

Cross-posted from the
Rocky Mountain Institute.

As heroic workers and soldiers strive to save stricken Japan from a new horror -- radioactive fallout -- some truths known for 40 years bear repeating.

An earthquake-and-tsunami zone crowded with 127 million people is an unwise place for 54 reactors. The 1960s design of five Fukushima-I reactors has the smallest safety margin and probably can't contain 90 percent of meltdowns. The U.S. has six identical and 17 very similar plants.

Every currently operating light-water reactor, if deprived of power and cooling water, can melt down. Fukushima had eight-hour battery reserves, but fuel has melted in three reactors. Most U.S. reactors get in trouble after four hours. Some have had shorter blackouts. Much longer ones could happen.

Overheated fuel risks hydrogen or steam explosions that damage equipment and contaminate the whole site -- so clustering many reactors together (to save money) can make failure at one reactor cascade to the rest.

Nuclear power is uniquely unforgiving: As Swedish Nobel physicist Hannes Alfvén said, "No acts of God can be permitted." Fallible people have created its half-century history of a few calamities, a steady stream of worrying incidents, and many near-misses [PDF]. America has been lucky so far. Had Three Mile Island's containment dome not been built double-strength because it was under an airport landing path, it may not have withstood the 1979 accident's hydrogen explosion. In 2002, Ohio's Davis-Besse reactor was luckily caught [PDF] just before its massive pressure-vessel lid rusted through.

Regulators haven't resolved these or other key safety issues, such as terrorist threats to reactors, lest they disrupt a powerful industry. U.S. regulation is not clearly better than Japanese regulation, nor more transparent: Industry-friendly rules bar the American public from meaningful participation. Many presidents' nuclear boosterism also discourages inquiry and dissent.

Nuclear-promoting regulators inspire even less confidence. The International Atomic Energy Agency's (IAEA) 2005 estimate [PDF] of about 4,000 Chernobyl deaths contrasts with a rigorous 2009 review of 5,000 mainly Slavic-language scientific papers the IAEA overlooked. It found deaths approaching a million through 2004, nearly 170,000 of them in North America. The total toll now exceeds a million, plus a half-trillion dollars' economic damage. The fallout reached four continents, just as the jet stream could swiftly carry Fukushima fallout.

Fukushima I-4's spent fuel alone, while in the reactor, had produced (over years, not in an instant) more than a hundred times more fission energy and hence radioactivity than both 1945 atomic bombs. If that already-damaged fuel keeps overheating, it may melt or burn, releasing into the air things like cesium-137 and strontium-90, which take several centuries to decay a millionfold. Unit 3's fuel is spiked with plutonium, which takes 482,000 years.

Nuclear power is the only energy source where mishap or malice can kill so many people so far away; the only one whose ingredients can help make and hide nuclear bombs; the only climate solution that substitutes proliferation, accident, and high-level radioactive waste dangers. Indeed, nuclear plants are so slow and costly to build that they reduce and retard climate protection.

Here's how. Each dollar spent on a new reactor buys about two to 10 times less carbon savings, 20 to 40 times slower, than spending that dollar on the cheaper, faster, safer solutions that make nuclear power unnecessary and uneconomic: efficient use of electricity, making heat and power together in factories or buildings ("cogeneration"), and renewable energy. The last two made 18 percent of the world's 2009 electricity (while nuclear made 13 percent, reversing their 2000 shares) -- and made over 90 percent of the 2007-08 increase in global electricity production.

Those smarter choices are sweeping the global energy market. Half the world's new generating capacity in 2008 and 2009 was renewable. In 2010, renewables, excluding big hydro dams, won $151 billion of private investment and added over 50 billion watts (70 percent the total capacity of all 23 Fukushima-style U.S. reactors) while nuclear got zero private investment and kept losing capacity. Supposedly unreliable wind power made 43 to 52 percent of four German states' total 2010 electricity. Non-nuclear Denmark, 21 percent wind-powered, plans to get entirely off fossil fuels. Hawaii plans 70 percent renewables by 2025.

In contrast, of the 66 nuclear units worldwide officially listed as "under construction" at the end of 2010, 12 had been so listed for over 20 years, 45 had no official startup date, half were late, all 66 were in centrally planned power systems -- 50 of those in just four (China, India, Russia, South Korea) -- and zero were free-market purchases. Since 2007, nuclear growth has added less annual output than just the costliest renewable -- solar power -- and will probably never catch up. While inherently safe renewable competitors are walloping both nuclear and coal plants in the marketplace and keep getting dramatically cheaper, nuclear costs keep soaring, and with greater safety precautions would go even higher. Tokyo Electric Co., just recovering from $10-20 billion in 2007 earthquake costs at its other big nuclear complex, now faces an even more ruinous Fukushima bill.

Since 2005, new U.S. reactors (if any) have been 100+ percent subsidized -- yet they couldn't raise a cent of private capital, because they have no business case. They cost two to three times as much as new wind power, and by the time you could build a reactor, it couldn't even beat solar power. Competitive renewables, cogeneration, and efficient use can displace all U.S. coal power more than 23 times over -- leaving ample room to replace nuclear power's half-as-big-as-coal contribution too -- but we need to do it just once. Yet the nuclear industry demands ever more lavish subsidies, and its lobbyists hold all other energy efforts hostage for tens of billions in added ransom, with no limit.

Japan, for its size, is even richer than America in benign, ample, but long-neglected energy choices. Perhaps this tragedy will call Japan to global leadership into a post-nuclear world. And before America suffers its own Fukushima, it too should ask, not whether unfinanceably costly new reactors are safe, but why build any more, and why keep running unsafe ones. China has suspended reactor approvals. Germany just shut down the oldest 41 percent of its nuclear capacity for study. America's nuclear lobby says it can't happen here, so pile on lavish new subsidies.

A durable myth claims Three Mile Island halted U.S. nuclear orders. Actually they stopped over a year before -- dead of an incurable attack of market forces. No doubt when nuclear power's collapse in the global marketplace, already years old, is finally acknowledged, it will be blamed on Fukushima. While we pray for the best in Japan today, let us hope its people's sacrifice will help speed the world to a safer, more competitive energy future.

Physicist Amory Lovins is Chairman and Chief Scientist of Rocky Mountain Institute and Chairman Emeritus of Fiberforge, Inc. Published in 29 books and hundreds of papers, he advises governments and major firms worldwide on advanced energy and resource efficiency.


For some interesting information and background about Chernobyl, consider this:
At Chernobyl, it was all under control

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Japan’s Meltdowns Demand New No-Nukes Thinking

Another perspective on nuclear power:

Japan’s Meltdowns Demand New No-Nukes Thinking

http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/japans_meltdowns_demand_new_no-nukes_thinking_20110621/

By Amy Goodman

New details are emerging that indicate the Fukushima nuclear disaster in Japan is far worse than previously known, with three of the four affected reactors experiencing full meltdowns. Meanwhile, in the U.S., massive flooding along the Missouri River has put Nebraska’s two nuclear plants, both near Omaha, on alert. The Cooper Nuclear Station declared a low-level emergency and will have to close down if the river rises another 3 inches. The Fort Calhoun nuclear power plant has been shut down since April 9, in part due to flooding. At Prairie Island, Minn., extreme heat caused the nuclear plant’s two emergency diesel generators to fail. Emergency-generator failure was one of the key problems that led to the meltdowns at Fukushima.

In May, in reaction to the Fukushima disaster, Nikolaus Berlakovich, Austria’s federal minister of agriculture, forestry, environment and water management, convened a meeting of Europe’s 11 nuclear-free countries. Those gathered resolved to push for a nuclear-free Europe, even as Germany announced it will phase out nuclear power in 10 years and push ahead on renewable-energy research. Then, in last week’s national elections in Italy, more than 90 percent of voters resoundingly rejected Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi’s plans to restart the country’s nuclear power program.

Leaders of national nuclear-energy programs are gathering this week in Vienna for the International Atomic Energy Agency’s Ministerial Conference on Nuclear Safety. The meeting was called in response to Fukushima. Ironically, the ministers, including U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Chairman Gregory Jaczko, held their meeting safely in a country with no nuclear power plants. Austria is at the forefront of Europe’s new anti-nuclear alliance.

The IAEA meeting was preceded by the release of an Associated Press report stating that consistently, and for decades, U.S. nuclear regulators lowered the bar on safety regulations in order to allow operators to keep the nuclear plants running. Nuclear power plants were constructed in the U.S. in the decades leading up to the Three Mile Island disaster in 1979. These 104 plants are all getting on in years. The original licenses were granted for 40 years.

The AP’s Jeff Donn wrote, “When the first ones were being built in the 1960s and 1970s, it was expected that they would be replaced with improved models long before those licenses expired.” Enormous upfront construction costs, safety concerns and the problem of storing radioactive nuclear waste for thousands of years drove away private investors. Instead of developing and building new nuclear plants, the owners—typically for-profit companies like Exelon Corp., a major donor to the Obama campaigns through the years—simply try to run the old reactors longer, applying to the NRC for 20-year extensions.

Europe, already ahead of the U.S. in development and deployment of renewable-energy technology, is now poised to accelerate in the field. In the U.S., the NRC has provided preliminary approval of the Southern Company’s planned expansion of the Vogtle power plant in Georgia, which would allow the first construction of new nuclear power plants in the U.S. since Three Mile Island. The project got a boost from President Barack Obama, who pledged an $8.3 billion federal loan guarantee. Southern plans on using Westinghouse’s new AP1000 reactor. But a coalition of environmental groups has filed to block the permit, noting that the new reactor design is inherently unsafe.

Obama established what he called his Blue Ribbon Commission on America’s Nuclear Future. One of its 15 members is John Rowe, the chairman and chief executive officer of Exelon Corp. (the same nuclear-energy company that has lavished campaign contributions on Obama). The commission made a fact-finding trip to Japan to see how that country was thriving with nuclear power—one month before the Fukushima disaster. In May, the commission reiterated its position, which is Obama’s position, that nuclear ought to be part of the U.S. energy mix.

The U.S. energy mix, instead, should include a national jobs program to make existing buildings energy efficient, and to install solar and wind-power technology where appropriate. These jobs could not be outsourced and would immediately reduce our energy use and, thus, our reliance on foreign oil and domestic coal and nuclear. Such a program could favor U.S. manufacturers, to keep the money in the U.S. economy. That would be a simple, effective and sane reaction to Fukushima.

Denis Moynihan contributed research to this column.

Amy Goodman is the host of “Democracy Now!,” a daily international TV/radio news hour airing on more than 900 stations in North America. She is the author of “Breaking the Sound Barrier,” recently released in paperback and now a New York Times best-seller.

© 2011 Amy Goodman

Distributed by King Features Syndicate

Saturday, October 12, 2013

Atomic Energy - Unnecessary, Uneconomic, Uninsurable, Unevacuable and Unsafe

Vermont Yankee, Pilgrim Nuclear in Plymouth [operated by Entergy] and other plants are of the same General Electric design and age as Fukushima.

They can no longer compete with Alternative Energy.




Consumer advocate Ralph Nader. (photo: Meet the Press)
Consumer advocate Ralph Nader. (photo: Meet the Press)

Atomic Energy - Unnecessary, Uneconomic, Uninsurable, Unevacuable and Unsafe

By Ralph Nader, Reader Supported News
12 October 13

t has been over two years since the earthquake and tsunami that brought about the nuclear reactor crisis in Fukushima -- the largest nuclear disaster since Chernobyl in 1986. The situation at the six plants is still grim. Four of the reactors are damaged. Hundreds of tons of contaminated groundwater are reportedly seeping into the ocean every day. Nearly 83,000 people were displaced from their homes in the approximately 310 square mile exclusion zones. On Wednesday October 9, an accident resulted in six workers being doused in radioactive water. Accidents and mishaps at the Fukushima site are regular occurrences. Japan's Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has now asked the world community for help in containing the ongoing Fukushima disaster, as it continues to spiral out of control.

Earlier this week, I participated in a panel discussion in New York City called "The Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Accident: Ongoing Lessons." The event featured notable long-time experts on nuclear technology discussing the crisis in Fukushima and the current state of the heavily subsidized nuclear industry in the United States. The panel participants were former U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Commissioner and later Chairman Peter Bradford, former NRC Chairman Dr. Gregory Jaczko, former Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan, and nuclear engineer, Arnie Gundersen.
Mr. Bradford presented a detailed power point that showed how competing forms of energy already are leading to the decline of the nuclear industry.
 
The panel discussed safety concerns regarding the Indian Point nuclear power plant located about 30 miles from New York City. Indian Point has long been rife with safety problems and its location near an earthquake fault is a source of great concern for many New York residents. You can view Tuesday's event, in its entirety, here.
 
In the 1960s, The Atomic Energy Commission determined that a class-nine nuclear power plant accident could contaminate an area the size of Pennsylvania and render much of it uninhabitable. A nuclear disaster at Indian Point would threaten the entire population of New York City and its outlying metropolitan area. The continued existence and operation of Indian Point is like playing a game of Russian Roulette with the lives and homes of the nearly 20 million people who live within a 50 mile radius of the plant. Consider the difficulty New Yorkers have simply commuting to and from their workplaces during rush hour and imagine the horror of a mandatory evacuation due to a nuclear emergency at Indian Point. The NRDC estimates that a serious accident could, in addition to massive casualties, "cost ten to 100 times more than Fukushima's disaster" which would be in the trillions of dollars.
 
If Indian Point were closed today, there is enough surplus energy capacity to last the state until 2020 as alternative energy sources are developed and deployed. Governor Andrew Cuomo has called for the shutdown of Indian Point, as did Hillary Clinton during her time in the Senate. A main reason is that an emergency evacuation of the population up to 50 miles around these two nukes is impossible.
So what's the delay? Mainly resistance from the nuclear industry and a compliant regulatory agency.
 
The NRC has faltered in its watchdog role by acting to protect and even bolster the dangerous, expensive and unnecessary nuclear industry. The industry's last claim is that it avoids greenhouse gases. But as physicist Amory Lovins says, if the investment in nuclear plants was shifted to renewables and energy conservation, it will produce less demand and more environmentally benign BTUs by far, and with more jobs.
 
Anti-nuclear advocates have warned against potential dangers such as earthquakes for decades. Although a new nuclear power plant has not been ordered and built in the United States since 1974, there are currently 65 nuclear plants operating 100 reactors in the United States -- many of them aging, many of them near earthquake faults, many of them still not in compliance with NRC fire prevention regulations, all of them significant national security risks. Under President Obama, the first two nuclear reactors since 1978, were authorized to be built at the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant in Georgia. (Panel participant Dr. Gregory Jaczko was the lone dissenter in the 4-1 NRC approval vote.)
 
To truly understand the cost of nuclear energy, one must consider the absurdity of the nuclear fuel cycle itself. It begins with uranium mines and their deadly tailings, then the fabrication and refinement of the fuel rods, the risky transport of these rods to the multi-shielded dome-like plant where they are installed, and then firing up the plant so it goes critical with a huge amount of radioactivity. Dealing with volatile nuclear reactions requires flawless operation. And then there is the storage and guarding of hot radioactive wastes and contaminated materials that persist for 250,000 years. No permanent site has been located and licensed for that lengthy containment.
What is the end purpose of this complex and expensive chain of events? Simply to boil water -- to generate steam to turn turbines to produce electricity.
 
With all the technological advancements in energy efficiency, solar, wind and other renewable energy sources, surely there are better and more efficient ways to meet our electricity needs without burdening future generations with deadly waste products and risking the radioactive contamination of entire regions should anything go wrong.
 
It is telling that Wall Street, which rarely considers the consequences of gambling on a risk, will not finance the construction of a nuclear plant without a full loan guarantee from the U.S. government. Nuclear power is also uninsurable in the private insurance market. The Price-Anderson Act of 1957 requires taxpayers to cover almost all the cost if a meltdown should occur.
 
No other industry that produces electricity poses such a great national security risk should sabotage or malfunction occur. No other means of generating power can produce such long-lasting catastrophic damage and mayhem from one unpredictable accident. No other form of energy is so loaded with the silent violence of radioactivity.
 
Nuclear energy is unnecessary, uninsurable, uneconomic, unevacuable and most importantly, unsafe.
 
The fact that it continues to exist at all is a result of a ferocious lobby, enlisting the autocratic power of government, that will not admit that its product is unfit for use in the modern world. Let us not allow the lessons of Fukushima to be ignored.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Presidential Debates and Energy Efficiency

During the Presidential debates ENERGY was briefly mentioned. Kate Galbraith expanded the subject in the NYT --
.
“Each and every one of us can start thinking about how can we save energy in our homes, in our buildings,” Mr. Obama said. His administration, he said, would incentivize Detroit to make more fuel-efficient cars, and would also be “making sure that you are able to weatherize your home or make your business more fuel efficient”.
.
Mr. Obama was responding to a question about what sacrifices his administration would ask American to make during tough economic times. It is a clever answer, because the trick to energy efficiency, of course, is that it is not actually a sacrifice. Unlike more expensive green investments like a Prius or solar panels, adding insulation to your house or sealing leaky windows can actually save money in the near term.
.
In Single Sentences, I comment on
.
Mohler-Faria noted that
conservation efforts at Bridgewater State College
have reduced the school’s energy consumption by
28 percent —
proving that green environmental initiatives, are “also a
major economic engine for the state of Massachusetts.”
.
Potentially, that's 30% IN YOUR POCKET. That's like a tax cut, if you just reduce your energy expenses.
.
Unfortunately, Ms. Galbraith links to an article promoting NUCLEAR energy which destroys her credibility on the topic and clearly indicates her lack of research.
.
It might also be suggested that the NYT consider some of the current reports about the industry.
.
I'm wondering how the radioactive shipment from Pilgrim in Plymouth to Yankee in Vermont magically increased in radioactivity. Is this the fishes and loaves again or just that Entergy owns both plants?
.
Federal nuclear inspectors are looking into why a shipment of lead shielding from the Pilgrim nuclear station in Plymouth to the Vermont Yankee nuclear power plant had higher than allowed radiation levels.
.
The lead shielding is used to protect workers during refueling outages. Both Pilgrim and Yankee are owned by Entergy.
.
“(Workers) checked it thoroughly before it left Pilgrim,” said Neil Sheehan, spokesman for the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. In Plymouth, radiation levels were below federal limits, he said.
.
It can only be suggested that she read Forget Nuclear or Nuclear Illusion.
.
Clearly, the issue deserves more than sound bytes, but CONSERVATION and ENERGY EFFICIENCY are dirty words to Republicans and the right wing media who poo pooed their efficacy.
.
If energy costs were removed from your household budget, isn't that like a raise in pay or a tax cut?
.
It can only be suggested that RMI (Rocky Mountain Institute) has long been promoting the concept and includes a wealth of information.
.
Energy efficiency has often been seen as the ugly sister to renewable energy, but there is nothing ugly or unglamorous about saving money, reducing energy costs and lowering emissions. While the market tends to focus on investment in renewables as a means of cutting carbon, there is growing evidence that investing in ‘negawatts’, a term coined to describe a megawatt of power avoided or saved from use on the energy grid, will provide a better return.
.
The opportunity for energy efficiency investment is immense - the International Energy Agency calls it the ‘fifth fuel’ after oil, coal, gas and nuclear. Energy Efficiency News
.
As a footnote: the energy issue ranks so far down the list of important issues, that the Middleboro Bored of Selectmen couldn't include a Green Committee on the Warrant for the Special Town Meeting scheduled for October 20th. They did manage to include sick leave buy back for a deceased employee that was voted at the ATM. So much for leadership, transparency and competence. Just leave it all to a new town manager.

Tuesday, July 15, 2014

AMENDED: GOP-controlled House takes shot at Cape Wind


In the upper left-hand corner of this page, there's a SEARCH feature - type in a subject and pertinent articles are found.

The GOP Propaganda Machine continues to misrepresent SOLYNDRA.

PLEASE educate yourselves if you suffer under this Dirty Energy Delusion!

NUCLEAR ENERGY is 100% TAXPAYER GUARANTEED because private capital markets  no longer consider NUCLEAR ENERGY a viable option! NUCLEAR ENERGY is financially a DUD!



FUKUSHIMA speaks for itself!

PILGRIM NUCLEAR POWER PLANT in Plymouth, owned by ENTERGY, the SAME DESIGN, the SAME AGE as FUKUSHIMA, is filled with SPENT NUCLEAR FUEL!


From Nuclear:

Consider this -- Nuclear Energy costs

$7,500 per kilowatt to build
That’s more than double the capital costs for solar power and three and a half times the cost for wind.



Phew! Ya just can't get rid of Ron Beaty and his Tea Bagger Extremism! [Note comment below.]

Even the Closeted Tea Bagger Charlie Baker figured out that most folks favored Cape Wind and changed his position....at least for now.

This is partisanship at its worst and shortchanges our future with myths and misstatements.





 
Just when Cape Wind officials thought it was safe to go back in the water, federal lawmakers have fired another, albeit largely symbolic, shot across the bow of the controversial project.
 
In a vote last week the GOP-controlled House approved an energy and water appropriations bill that included a measure to bar a $150 million federal loan guarantee for the offshore wind farm planned for Nantucket Sound.
The move came amid a flurry of activity surrounding the project in the past week, including the hiring by its primary opposition group of a Harvard law professor quoted in the federal court decision the group is now appealing and an expected vote today on a lease option for Cape Wind at port facilities in Rhode Island.
 
Although the Alliance to Protect Nantucket Sound, a project opponent, has been in touch in the past with members of Congress about the problems the organization sees with Cape Wind, group president Audra Parker said she didn't have any direct contact with U.S. Rep. Randy K. Weber Sr., R-Texas, about the amendment he proposed to specifically prohibit funding for Cape Wind through the energy and water bill. The bill, including the amendment, passed 253-170, largely along partisan lines.
 
"I think there's concern about Cape Wind and its economic impacts and its risks, particularly after Solyndra," Parker said about the solar energy giant that failed three years ago after receiving $535 million in loans from the Department of Energy.
 
Although the program is not the same one the department used to conditionally approve a $150 million loan guarantee for Cape Wind on July 1, opponents of the project and Republican critics of the Obama administration have used Solyndra's failure to criticize support for Cape Wind, which previously had asked for nearly $2 billion from the same program that was used by Solyndra.
 
Cape Wind spokesman Mark Rodgers called the House vote a "narrow partisan reaction that has no chance of being enacted into law."
 
Others, including some Republicans, have agreed, citing the unlikelihood that the Senate would take up the bill or that the president would sign it.
 
U.S. Rep. William Keating, D-Mass., issued a statement after voting against the bill, saying its passage was another example of Republicans siding with the oil and gas industry and seeking "to undermine the development of offshore renewable energy."
 
"Cape Wind represents more than a fight for federal funding; it will be a first-of-its-kind project that will mark the entrance of the United States as a producer of offshore renewable energy into the global playing field," Keating said.
 
That is, of course, if the project survives the continued though largely unsuccessful legal challenges against it.
 
The alliance last week announced its decision to hire noted constitutional lawyer and Harvard Law School professor Laurence Tribe to represent the organization in appealing the dismissal of a lawsuit that contended state regulators' approval of an above-market contract to sell power from the project to NStar violated two clauses of the U.S. Constitution.
 
U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns found on May 2 that the plaintiffs, who had sued officials at the state Department of Public Utilities and the state Department of Energy Resources, were barred from doing so under the 11th Amendment to the Constitution, which restricts lawsuits in federal court against a sovereign state for past actions.
 
But in a statement released by the alliance Tribe said the decision, which didn't address the underlying merits of the case, relied on and quoted a treatise he wrote on the Constitution to reach a conclusion he and the Supreme Court dispute.
 
Follow Patrick Cassidy on Twitter: @PCassidyCCT


http://www.capecodonline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20140715/NEWS/407150325/-1/NEWSLETTER100



  • Beaty for State Senate

  •  
    ...as the ONLY ACTIVIST STATE SENATE CANDIDATE for the Cape & Islands District, I have long opposed the outrageously expensive and environmentally detrimental BOONDOGGLE known as the Cape Wind Project...simply search the archives of the Cape Cod Times to document this fact. Thank you Congress! RON BEATY
     
     
     
    The entire region suffers from elevated respiratory problems, elevated childhood asthma as a consequence of geography and living Down Wind from Dirty Energy, such as that from which the Dirty Energy Koch Brothers derive their wealth.

    One need only consider the poor air quality and health consequences, exacerbated by heavy summer traffic, clearly visible, to understand the importance of CLEAN ENERGY.

    When one factors in the Taxpayer Funded Subsidies provided to Dirty Energy, Wind Energy is a BARGAIN!

    Might I add that those are DIRTY ENERGY TAXPAYER-FUNDED SUBSIDIES that Republicans have repeatedly refused to repeal? [Folks, you are subsidizing DIRTY ENERGY & the Koch Brothers with your tax dollars!]

    It is only the Regressive Party that stymies and opposes CLEAN ENERGY!

    The rest of the world is LEADING in CLEAN ENERGY!
    It's time for the U.S. to LEAD!

    Next thing ya know, Ron Beaty's gonna tell us there's no such thing as Global Warming that we can all see!
     
     
     

    Saturday, April 14, 2012

    Stop the Nuclear Industry Welfare Program



    Based solely on the economics, it's time to re-think our flawed Energy Policy and its excessive taxpayer cost.

    'Wealthy nuclear corporations recently secured access to $18.5bn in taxpayer-backed loan guarantees.'

    Stop the Nuclear Industry Welfare Program
    By Bernie Sanders and Ryan Alexander, Reader Supported News
    13 April 12

    The US is facing a $15 trillion national debt, and there is no shortage of opinions about how to move toward deficit reduction in the federal budget. One topic you will not hear discussed very often on Capitol Hill is the idea of ending one of the oldest American welfare programmes – the extraordinary amount of corporate welfare going to the nuclear energy industry.

    Many in Congress talk of getting "big government off the back of private industry". Here's an industry we'd like to get off the backs of the taxpayers.

    As, respectively, a senator who is the longest-serving independent in Congress and the president of an independent and non-partisan budget watchdog organisation, we do not necessarily agree on everything when it comes to energy and budget policy in the US. But one thing we strongly agree on is the need to end wasteful subsidies that prop up the nuclear industry. After 60 years, this industry should not require continued and massive corporate welfare. It is time for the nuclear power industry to stand on its own two feet.

    Nuclear welfare started with research and development. According to the non-partisan Congressional Research Service, since 1948 the federal government has spent more than $95bn (in 2011 dollars) on nuclear energy research and development (R&D). That is more than four times the amount spent on solar, wind, geothermal, biomass, biofuels, and hydropower combined. But federal R&D was not enough; the industry also wanted federal liability insurance too, which it got back in 1957 with the Price-Anderson Act. This federal liability insurance programme for nuclear plants was meant to be temporary, but Congress repeatedly extended it, most recently through 2025. Price-Anderson puts taxpayers on the hook for losses that exceed $12. 6bn if there is a nuclear plant disaster. When government estimates show the cost for such a disaster could reach $720bn in property damage alone, that's one sweetheart deal for the nuclear industry!

    R&D and Price-Anderson insurance are still just the tip of the iceberg. From tax breaks for uranium mining and loan guarantees for uranium enrichment to special depreciation benefits and lucrative federal tax breaks for every kilowatt hour from new plants, nuclear is heavily subsidised at every phase. The industry also bilks taxpayers when plants close down with tax breaks for decommissioning plants. Further, it is estimated that the cost to taxpayers for the disposal of radioactive nuclear waste could be as much as $100bn.

    Even with all of those subsidies, the private sector still will not agree to finance a new nuclear plant, so wealthy nuclear corporations recently secured access to $18.5bn in taxpayer-backed loan guarantees. Maybe the Wall Street banks agree with the Congressional Budget Office, which estimated the risk of default on nuclear loans at above 50%. The nuclear industry's financial troubles are not new. In the 1960s and 1970s, 100 reactors were cancelled because of cost overruns. Things were so bad Forbes called it "the largest managerial disaster in business history". Despite this history, some want to dramatically increase federal loan guarantees for nuclear plants.

    It is shocking that the nuclear industry continues to receive so much federal support at a time of record debt. Of course nuclear subsidies benefit some of the wealthiest and most powerful energy corporations in America, which may explain the persistence of nuclear welfare. For example, Exelon, which takes in $33bn in revenue annually, is the leading operator/owner of nuclear reactors in the US. Entergy [owner of Pilgrim], with revenues of more than $11bn annually, is the second largest. Together, these two companies own or operate almost one-third of US reactors, and based on their revenue they are doing pretty well. Why do they need endless federal welfare for their industry year after year? Will it ever end?

    Well, as secretary of energy Steven Chu confirmed at a recent Senate hearing, without federal liability insurance and loan guarantees, no one would ever build a new nuclear plant. Whether you support nuclear energy or not, we should all be able to agree that with record debt, we cannot afford to continue to subsidise this mature industry and its multibillion-dollar corporations. If the nuclear industry believes so fervently in its technology, then it and Wall Street investors can put their money where their mouth is. Let's let them finance it, insure it, and pay for it themselves.

    Saturday, July 8, 2017

    Atomic Bellyflop: The US's First "21st Century Nuclear Reactor" Fails, Shuts Down After Five Months



    This Clown is in charge!







    Vermont Yankee Cooling Tower Collapse


    Wednesday, 05 July 2017 09:09

    Atomic Bellyflop: The US's First "21st Century Nuclear Reactor" Fails, Shuts Down After Five Months


    JULIA TRAVERS OF ENVIRONEWS ON BUZZFLASH AT TRUTHOUT



    On March 23, 2017, after less than six months of operation, the Tennessee Valley Authority's (TVA) Watts Bar 2 nuclear power unit (Watts Bar 2) was shut down. Failing components in the condenser caused America's first 21st Century nuclear reactor to cease functioning, and as of July 3, it remains shut down.
    "Nuclear technology is very unforgiving… The nuclear industry is very optimistic about its projections of performance. This is more evidence that they need to temper that optimism," David Lochbaum, Director of the Nuclear Safety Project at the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), told The LA Times.
    Lochbaum was specifically referencing the importance of the condenser, which cools down the steam used to drive the unit's generating turbines. The unit will now be offline until sometime this summer, preventing it from providing electricity during peak demand in the TVA service region.
    "We have a team of workers currently evaluating the extent of the condition within the condenser at Watts Barr 2 and we have already begun repairs that should allow us to return the unit to service sometime this summer," Jim Hopson, Manager of TVA Public Relations told EnviroNews.
    Hopson also said there was no risk of radioactive material entering the environment due to the condenser failure. "The condenser is not a part of the nuclear side of the plant," he continued. "The condenser is on the power generation side, which is completely separate, so there are no radiological concerns, whatsoever."
    Watts Barr 2 has been under construction for 43 years and contains an unusual amalgamation of old and new technology. However, TVA said it carried out extensive refurbishments and upgrades to the unit, which has an estimated cost of $6.1 billion. The last new nuclear unit to come online in the U.S. was the Watts Bar Unit 1 in 1996, which returned to power production on May 9 after an 18-month maintenance outage.
    According to Utility Dive, another safety concern for the Watts Bar station that may be a cofactor in the current shutdown is the high number of service interruptions coupled with safety and regulatory issues alleged by company personnel. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) recorded 33 allegations for TVA in 2016 — the highest in the country.
    In March, 2016, the NRC found Watts Barr had a "chilled" working environment. The Office of the Inspector General (OIG) hired NTD Consulting Group, a firm with nuclear industry expertise, to re-assess the situation. In April of 2017, the firm reported, "management behaviors that include harassment, intimidation, retaliation and discrimination."
    Nuclear industry expert and former nuclear engineer, executive and whistleblower Arnie Gundersen discussed TVA's safety failings with EnviroNews as well:
    For years, the safety culture at TVA has been a threatening one for people of conscience. At one point at the TVA Bellefonte construction site, an unknown TVA employee dropped a blot on the hardhat of an NRC inspector in an attempt to injure him. The NRC should have shut the construction down, but did nothing! TVA covered up new safety culture issues at Watts Bar 2 so it could be licensed, and now suddenly thinks that a 'timeout' to change the safety culture will change things? [It's] like finding your spouse has been cheating on you for 20 years and thinking a timeout will solve the problem! This timeout is too little, too late.
    Gunderson, a former reactor operator himself, added, "Nuclear power plants are risky enough if people on the staff have integrity, but all is for naught with a weak safety culture."
    TVA, an enterprise owned by the federal government, stated Watts Barr 2 is designed to help "generate enough clean electricity to power 4.5 million homes." The nuclear industry's claims that nuclear power is safe and clean do not sit well with many environmentalists. From the infamous Three Mile Island accident of 1979, to the deadly Chernobyl disaster of 1986, to the recent 2011 Fukushima meltdowns, numerous dangers and calamities are historically tied to nuclear power. Reporter Michael Hiltzik of The LA Times wrote of the Watts Barr 2 shutdown, "With every episode like this, the industry moves one step further away from making the case for its survival."
    The EnviroNews USA Editorial Board expressed in April of 2017, that nuclear power is neither clean, safe or, as is sometimes claimed, "carbon-free." The Board wrote that every stage of the production and cleanup of nuclear energy is costly and carries risk for contamination:
    An examination of nuclear energy from point A, where the drill bit hits the ground in the initial quest for uranium, to the process of uranium enrichment and zirconium-clad fuel rod production, on to energy generation, power plant dismantlement, nuclear waste disposal and finally uranium mine remediation, nuclear power presents anything but a clean and green energy paradigm.
    The issue of nuclear waste is a dangerous one for the U.S., which does not possess a functioning permanent nuclear waste storage facility. The contested and unused Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Repository (Yucca Mountain) has been on hold for 23 years, but the Trump Administration is now seeking to reinvigorate it. The partially constructed facility was designated without scientific vetting, and the site has since been found to be seismically active as well as positioned over an aquifer.
    "Deep geologic disposal is the only alternative [for nuclear waste storage], in an area proven to be free of water," Gundersen previously told EnviroNews. "Yucca has water seeping in, and has been proven to let waste seep out in a short period of time."
    Nuclear Power into the Future
    New "generations" of nuclear reactors are still under development. Most of the reactors in use today are Generation II or III light-water reactors (LWRs), AKA thermal reactors. The European Commission on Energy explains, "they require the energetic neutrons released in fission to be slowed down to thermal energies… before they can initiate further fission events and therefore maintain the chain reaction."
    Some Generation IV designs, of which there are none in operation today, vary in that they "burn" fuel without slowing down the electrons, and so are known as fast neutron reactors (FNRs). These machines can theoretically convert depleted uranium (DU) into plutonium, which the reactor can then use as fuel. According to the World Nuclear Association, an international task force is currently developing multiple Generation IV reactors for potential deployment between 2020 and 2030.
    While these models are designed to be more compact and efficient, the production of plutonium generally rings alarm bells, as it is the most common material used in making nuclear and hydrogen weapons. Plutonium is also one of the most carcinogenic substances in existence. A reactor that breeds more plutonium than it needs to run is known as a "breeder reactor."
    The TerraPower nuclear technology company founded and chaired by Bill Gates is in the process of developing Generation IV fast reactors. As EnviroNews reported in 2016, Gates sees the heaps of depleted uranium improperly stored at U.S. sites as potential power sources for the reactors, while critics say his plan is too risky.
    According to E&E News, in 2016, TerraPower received a $40 million Department of Energy (DOE) research grant to develop a molten chloride fast reactor (MCFR). Chris Levesque, President of TerraPower, said this new design has eliminated nuclear proliferation risks by sealing the plutonium in the reactor, "where the heat and lethal radiation will keep it safe and producing energy for the lifetime of the power plant."
    Physicist and Senior Scientist at the Union of Concerned Scientists, Ed Lyman, shared his concerns about this plan with E&E News:
    There's a plutonium glut around the world, particularly in the United States, so no one needs to breed plutonium. Reactor vendors have changed their marketing strategy to say they can actually burn up wastes. Of course, that's not really true, either.
    Ken Luongo, President of the Partnership for Global Security and former non-proliferation expert for the DOE under Clinton, spoke on the future of nuclear energy and breeders at the 2016 Advanced Reactor Summit and Showcase in D.C. Along with giving suggestions for improved nuclear design safety and international security, he recommended:
    [The] international community should oppose advanced reactors fuel cycles that are designed for the specific purpose of breeding surplus plutonium for future use in nuclear reactors. [And, it] should oppose the stockpiling of separated plutonium and the use of uranium fuel enrichments that exceed 20%.
    The World Nuclear Association declared in 2015 that 1,000 new nuclear power plants would be needed by 2050 to combat CO2 buildup and adhere to the Paris Climate Agreement (Paris Accord). However, Gundersen, writing inTruthOut in 2016, used data from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), the World Nuclear Association and Lazard Financial Advisory and Asset Management to calculate that the proposed 1,000 plants would only reduce "6.1 percent of the total CO2 released to the atmosphere in 2050," and would cost $8.2 trillion. The debate over the future of nuclear energy in the U.S. endures.

    Thursday, October 15, 2015

    CapeCodToday: SHNS: Nuclear plant closure plans turn up heat on state's energy debate




    Nuclear plant closure plans turn up heat on state's energy debate

    Officials come to grips with potential adverse impacts of closure
    - See more at: https://www.capecodtoday.com/article/2015/10/14/226594-Nuclear-plant-closure-plans-turn-heat-states-energy-debate#sthash.cUINkLwe.dpuf

    Hampered by heightened federal oversight of its operations and low natural gas prices, the owners of Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station, which began operations in 1972, announced plans Tuesday to close the Plymouth facility by 2019, jolting the regional electricity market, spurring new calls for renewable energy, and forcing Massachusetts officials to think about long-term plant decommissioning and plans for spent nuclear fuel.
    The announcement Tuesday morning by Louisiana-based Entergy Corp. triggered a wave of reactions. Pilgrim workers urged Entergy to reconsider, citing 600 jobs and the plant's role in covering about 12 percent of the state's electricity needs. Gov. Charlie Baker said the closure could mean an energy shortage and promoted his hydro energy plans. Solar energy, transmission, and other power industry officials said they were ready to fill voids. Sen. Edward Markey urged Entergy to devote the resources needed to remove spent nuclear fuel from an "overcrowded" pool. And officials began coming to grips with potential adverse impacts in the area where Pilgrim is located.
    Pilgrim generates 680 megawatts of electricity, or enough to power more than 600,000 homes.
    "It's a temporary blow," South Shore Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Peter Forman told the News Service. "It's going to be a blow to Plymouth. It's going to be a blow to the energy supply."
    Entergy said shale gas production had dropped natural gas prices and "significantly" affected Pilgrim's revenues. Entergy blamed a $40 million reduction in Pilgrim revenues on a drop in current and forecast power prices of about $10 per megawatt hour.
    But Pilgrim also faced higher operational costs in connection with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's announcement in September that they will increase oversight of the plant after inspectors raised concerns about findings associated with the performance of a safety relief valve. The NRC findings stem from a special inspection at the plant following its unplanned shutdown in January. Entergy estimated up to $60 million in direct costs associated with enhanced NRC inspections, not including costs that might arise due to inspections.
    Pilgrim was expected to incur after-tax net losses ranging from $10 million to $30 million for 2015, 2016, and 2017, before taking into consideration plans to close the plant or costs associated with testing the plant for "impairment" in connection with the NRC's heightened oversight.
    Entergy said Pilgrim would close by June 1, 2019, with the exact timing to be determined during the first half of 2016 following talks with ISO-New England, the region's electric grid operator.
    Rep. Thomas Golden (D-Lowell) said he shares concerns about lost jobs and tax revenues in the Plymouth area. Pilgrim's closure will take a significant energy source offline and raises the stakes for ongoing energy policy talks. "Four years gives us some time," Golden told the News Service. "I don't think there's reason to panic today."
    While calling Pilgrim's closure "something that has to be taken into serious consideration sooner rather than later," Golden said he favors continuing a "very slow approach" on energy policy.
    "I don't think it's something we can rush," he said. "We still have committee hearings going on. The members of the House are weighing in very, very heavily. This is something we need to get right. I really believe it is the issue of the decade-plus."
    Golden identified energy storage as a potential "big game changer," and said policymakers are likely to be dealing for years with changes in energy technology.
    Entergy indicated state energy proposals influenced its decision.
    In addition to citing wholesale energy market "design flaws" that adversely affect prices paid for nuclear energy, Entergy also said Pilgrim's performance had been "undermined by unfavorable state energy proposals that subsidize renewable energy resources at the expense of Pilgrim and other plants." Entergy also described as "detrimental" proposals to provide "above-market prices to utilities in Canada for hydro power" and a state agency order that the company said would further lower natural gas prices and reliance on the fuel.
    "The decision to close Pilgrim was incredibly difficult because of the effect on our employees and the communities in which they work and live," Leo Denault, Entergy chairman and CEO, said in a statement. "Our people at Pilgrim are dedicated and skilled, a wonderful blend of young professionals and seasoned, experienced veterans, who for decades have been generating clean power and contributing millions of dollars of economic activity to the region. But market conditions and increased costs led us to reluctantly conclude that we had no option other than to shut down the plant."
    A decommissioning process will follow the plant's closure. Entergy said there was $870 million in a Pilgrim decommissioning trust as of Sept. 30, 2015, "representing excess financial assurance of approximately $240 million for license termination activities above NRC-required assurance levels."
    Future NRC filings will address funding for spent fuel management, "which will be required until the federal government takes possession of the fuel and removes it from the site, per its current obligation." Entergy said it does not anticipate additional funding.
    Gov. Charlie Baker said the decision to close Pilgrim did not surprise him given what was known about its finances and the safety upgrades that were needed, and pledged to stay involved with Entergy, the NRC and ISO New England as the closure moves forward.
    "On some level it creates a certain sense of urgency around our hydro proposal, which would make it possible for use to generate significant megawatts to serve that baseload loss on a go-forward basis and to do so in a way that would be competitive and cost effective for business and families in New England," Baker told reporters Tuesday morning.
    Baker said hydropower holds the potential to more than replace the energy that will be lost when Pilgrim closes. "That's one of the reasons I want to test the water on hydro, pun intended," Baker said. "There's thousands of megawatts of relatively affordable clean renewable energy coming from hydro providers all over the northeast and in Canada and we should test the waters with them and see how much power they think they can generate to support our baseload requirements."
    Asked how quickly hydropower could be put online given opposition to transmission projects like Northern Pass through the White Mountains of New Hampshire, Baker said, "It all depends on when the legislation would pass that would make it possible for us to test the market and see what's out there. There are four or five different routes between New York and the New England states that can get down into the New England region and connect, from a transmission point of view. Actually, I was surprised at how many options were available to us. There are a lot more than just the Northern Pass."
    Baker said his administration has talked to Pilgrim about its 600 employees and understands the "vast majority" will be put on "retention agreements" with some working through the plant's closure before they retire and others moving to other Entergy facilities.
    "We'll work very hard to make sure that anybody else who's left at the end of that two- or three-year period has options to pursue if they want to stay here and continue to work," Baker said.
    While workers urged Pilgrim to reconsider closure, Baker said, "The only scenario under which I would be willing to even consider aggressively advocating for Pilgrim to stay open would be if they deal with all the safety issues that have been raised over the course of the last several years."
    Reactions began pouring in following Tuesday morning's news.
    -- Gov. Charlie Baker's statement:
    "Our Administration will work closely with Pilgrim's leadership team and federal regulators to ensure that this decision is managed as safely as possible, and we will continue to work with ISO and the other New England Governors to ensure that Massachusetts and New England has the baseload capacity it needs to meet the electric generation needs of the region. Losing Pilgrim as a significant power generator not only poses a potential energy shortage, but also highlights the need for clean, reliable, affordable energy proposals which my administration has put forward through legislation to deliver affordable hydroelectricity and Class-I renewable resources. The closure of Pilgrim will be a significant loss of carbon-free electricity generation and will offset progress Massachusetts has made in achieving the 2020 greenhouse gas emission reduction goals, making it more challenging to hit these targets. I look forward to working with the legislature to make our proposal for clean, base-load generation law, as it represents a diversified and balanced approach that will be needed to achieve the commonwealth's greenhouse gas goals."
    Sen. Edward Markey:
    Markey noted that Pilgrim was in the NRC's Column 4, or the"least safe rating for an operating reactor," and said Entergy operates the only other two U.S. reactors with that rating.
    "The rating means that Pilgrim has had multiple and repetitive safety problems that require increased NRC oversight," he said in a statement. "Restoring a reactor from Column 4 back to normal levels of NRC oversight is estimated to cost more than $100 million."
    Markey added, "While nuclear energy was once advertised as being too cheap to meter, it is increasingly clear that it is actually too expensive to matter. Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station is just the latest example of how nuclear power simply cannot compete in the current energy market. And alongside the economic conditions that Entergy blames this closure on, there also have been decades-long and repetitive operational safety and security concerns with the facility that have contributed to this announcement. The remaining period of operation of Pilgrim needs to be with the utmost attention to safety and security, and must include rigorous oversight by the NRC to ensure that Entergy has and is spending the resources needed.
    "As the plant moves towards permanent shut down, priority must be given and special attention paid to worker assistance and transition training. The workers at Pilgrim are committed, skilled and valuable and have been an important part of economic activity in the region. The NRC must also ensure Entergy dedicates adequate financial and technical resources to remove the spent nuclear fuel from the overcrowded spent fuel pool and decommission the reactor quickly. We cannot allow the public to pay the price if Entergy comes up short on the bill to safely close this plant.
    "With this announcement we must also recognize that the time is now in New England and around the nation to rapidly transition towards the safe, affordable clean energy of wind, solar and geothermal power and continue to invest in energy efficiency and making the vehicles on our roads even more fuel efficient."
    -- U.S. Rep. William Keating of Bourne:
    "Entergy's shutdown announcement was not surprising given their unwillingness to deal with current safety standards. This announcement marks the next phase where great scrutiny is necessary to make sure Entergy is responsible for maintaining proper safety standards throughout the closure process -- something they failed to do during their operations. To this end, Entergy must maintain their skilled workforce at Pilgrim, where workers are both trained and experienced in addressing emergencies. They also must cooperate with the Town of Plymouth and federal officials on waste removal and storage issues. I have already begun coordination and oversight efforts, including at all levels of government involved, and will continue to monitor Entergy's decommissioning plan."
    -- Senate President Stanley Rosenberg said he wasn't surprised by Entergy's decision, citing a pattern among New England nuclear facilities.
    "Totally predictable," Rosenberg told reporters in his office. "I lived through the closure of Yankee Rowe and Vermont Yankee and the exact same pattern. These plants were built with a life expectancy of about 40 years. The company fights to get an extension of another 10 or 20 years. They get it and then they actually do the engineering studies and they find that the plant actually can't live that long without spending a tremendous amount of money."
    While Gov. Baker said he hopes the closure will bring a sense of "urgency" to his hydroelectric bill to address the loss of capacity, Rosenberg said the Senate is waiting for the House to act after House Speaker Robert DeLeo indicated a desire to produce an omnibus energy bill this session.
    "More green, more conservation and if we have to move forward with infrastructure we need the right kind of infrastructure, and if we're going to move forward with pipelines we need the right size in the right place," Rosenberg said.
    While the Senate waits, Rosenberg said Energy Committee Co-Chair Sen. Benjamin Downing has pulled together a small group of senators to study all the issues involved, including capacity, reliability and price. An aide to Rosenberg said Sen. Daniel Wolf, of the Cape and Islands, is among those involved.
    Rosenberg agreed that additional natural gas capacity could provide reliability at a good price point, but said there might be other options as well. Asked about those who believe the House will include an off-shore wind component to any bill, Rosenberg said, "I think off-shore wind is a great idea," and added that enhanced conservation could help offset the cost of green energy sources like wind.
    -- House Speaker Robert DeLeo issued a statement:
    "Unfortunately, this announcement does not come as a surprise. Pilgrim has posed both a financial and safety concern for the Commonwealth for quite some time now. Pilgrim's closing will certainly play a major role in the House's energy policy discussions moving forward. I continue to be in conversations with Chairs [Thomas] Golden and [Brian] Dempsey regarding energy legislation and hope to speak with them soon about Pilgrim's closing, as well as the local delegation."
    -- Attorney General Maura Healey's statement:
    "The Attorney General's Office has long advocated for increased safety standards at the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station. My primary concern now is that Entergy initiates a safe and orderly closure of the Pilgrim plant, and that it invests the proper resources to do so. I'm concerned as well that measures are in place to support workers. Today's announcement also highlights the need for a long-term federal solution to the storage of spent nuclear fuel at the facility and across the country. I am as convinced as ever that the solution to our long-term energy needs must include a broad portfolio of sources that meets our environmental, jobs and cost goals for all residents."
    -- Craig Pinkham, Acting President, UWUA369:
    "The Pilgrim nuclear plant provides more than 600 jobs and millions in tax revenues for our region. According to a UMass study earlier this year, Pilgrim has a total economic effect worth $225 million annually in Massachusetts. The plant provides 17 percent of the electrical power to Massachusetts - essentially heating and lighting the City of Boston. Pilgrim is by far the largest sources of Green, non-carbon producing energy in this region.
    "For all these reasons, Entergy needs to sharpen its pencil, go back to the drawing board, work with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the people who know this plant best - the utility workers - and come back with a plan to keep this plant running affordably and safely. It is not acceptable to walk away from a resource this valuable, and this important to our energy supply and to our economy, simply because it is going to require an investment to maintain its viability.
    "Gov. Baker, officials at the New England power grid - ISO-NE - and our state and federal legislative delegations need to tell Entergy to work harder to find a way to keep this resource up and running, safely and economically."
    -- Jack Clarke, Mass Audubon:
    Clarke said achieving greenhouse gas emission reduction targets under the state's Global Warming Solutions Act "becomes more challenging" with Pilgrim closing. At 14 percent now, Clarke noted the law calls for a 25 percent reduction below statewide 1990 emission levels by 2020 and 80 percent below 1990 levels by 2050.
    "Now with the price of natural gas continuing to drop, industry complaints of pipeline congestion, and Massachusetts not yet lifting the solar net-metering cap, the need for offshore wind increases," Clarke wrote in an email to the News Service. "Decommissioning will also be of concern especially as climate-change induced sea-level rise, and stronger coastal storms threaten the outdated Pilgrim Nuclear Station along the fragile and eroding Plymouth shoreline."
    -- South Shore Chamber of Commerce President Peter Forman told the News Service the news was "not completely surprising given the declining profitability of plants with energy costs coming down."
    "It is concerning to us on two fronts," he told the News Service in a phone interview. "One obviously is going to be the future energy supply and costs to the state and the other is the local impact to Plymouth itself. We have to be concerned about welfare of all the towns in the area when we're looking at economic development. This is going to have some negative impact on the town."
    Forman said goals now are to ensure an orderly and safe shutdown and ensure that Entergy deals with spent fuel on the site and properly decommissions the plant. He also raised the possibility that Entergy would use the site for a non-nuclear power generation facility to take advantage of existing transmission infrastructure.
    "We supported relicensing a few years ago but understood it is going to be reaching the end of its usable cycle at some time in the foreseeable future," Forman said.
    -- New England Power Generators Association President Dan Dolan:
    "Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station has long served Massachusetts consumers and those across the region. With its announced closure, New England's power generators stand ready to continue providing safe, environmentally-responsible, reliable and competitively-priced electricity for consumers. Already, more than 1,800 megawatts of new power plants, enough to serve approximately 1.3 million households, are under construction and under development including nearly 1,000 megawatts in Massachusetts alone. Notably, all of these new plants are entering the market without a ratepayer-backed contract or special subsidies. Thousands of megawatts of additional new facilities are also competing to come into the marketplace to replace retiring units.
    "Unfortunately, programs to subsidize particular technologies or resources and other out of market actions have led to undervaluing the services many generators provide. These actions serve to undermine power plant economics and contribute to the premature retirement of some facilities. To provide affordable, competitive pricing the open electricity markets in New England must continue to be refined without further subsidies and interventions that pick winners and losers.
    "With the retirements of a number of power plants over just a few years, it is clear that New England's electricity system is going through a time of unprecedented change. Despite that, 2015 has seen some of the lowest wholesale electricity prices in over a decade, reliability of the system is sound and carbon dioxide emissions from power plants have been cut by nearly 50 percent since 2005. At the same time, billions of dollars of new investment are flowing into the region without ratepayer guarantees or subsidies. These markets are working."
    -- Ed Krapels of Anbaric Transmission, a Massachusetts company that has built transmission lines and has proposals to bring wind and hydro power from Vermont and New York to southern New England, said Pilgrim's plan "adds to the urgency for investment in clean energy infrastructure. Clean energy resources are available; now is the time to invest in the transmission infrastructure that can deliver that energy to our homes and businesses."
    -- Vote Solar is working on state solar energy legislation in Massachusetts and has pushed solar bills in California, Colorado, Florida, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania. Its regional manager Seth Garren said in a statement, "The Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station closure announcement is yet another indication that Massachusetts needs a new energy future. It begs the question: why are we allowing the solar industry to wither under needless net metering caps when we need that clean, renewable energy and economic development so urgently. It should also be noted that the solar industry employs 12,000 workers in Massachusetts with plans to grow if net metering caps are lifted - a ready answer for the loss of jobs at Pilgrim that cannot be replaced by Hydro Quebec or natural gas pipelines."
    -- New England Clean Energy Council President Peter Rothstein, whose group represents regional business, said in a statement:
    "The closure of Pilgrim Nuclear Power Plant is a significant loss of the Commonwealth's non-emitting electricity generation. However, there are large amounts of in-region large-scale clean energy resources that can be used to meet the Commonwealth's electricity needs, while achieving its climate goals - especially energy efficiency, solar, wind and other resources that qualify as Class I under Massachusetts Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS). Onshore wind also can be combined with hydro from within New England and Canada to provide clean deliverable energy.
    "NECEC believes this is an opportunity for the Commonwealth to act on pending legislation that will enable distribution utilities to solicit additional long-term contracts for RPS Class I eligible resources, potentially in conjunction with hydro to facilitate the development of cost-effective transmission to deliver the power to customers.
    "In addition to grid-scale renewables, distributed energy resources, notably solar, have demonstrated that they have a role to play in filling the gap. However, solar remains on hold in Massachusetts due to the net metering cap, which must be lifted immediately to ensure that solar development continues to flourish in Massachusetts and solar customers can take advantage of federal tax credits scheduled to expire at the end of 2016."
    -- Nuclear Matters, a nuclear industry and business group, said Pilgrim generates 12 percent of the state's electricity and 79 percent of the state's "emission-free" electricity.
    "The premature closure of Pilgrim due to low wholesale power prices that do not adequately reward existing nuclear energy plants for generating clean, reliable power is disappointing. To continue down a path where plants like Pilgrim - and the rest of the existing nuclear fleet - are not properly valued is simply untenable and deprives communities of important economic benefits such as price stability for consumers. Its closure will clearly hamstring Massachusetts' ability to meet the emissions targets set forth by the Environmental Protection Agency's recently finalized Clean Power Plan to reduce carbon emissions and ensure a cleaner energy future for the country."
    - See more at: https://www.capecodtoday.com/article/2015/10/14/226594-Nuclear-plant-closure-plans-turn-heat-states-energy-debate#sthash.cUINkLwe.dpuf