Showing posts with label Toyota's Plastic Pulleys. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Toyota's Plastic Pulleys. Show all posts
Friday, March 13, 2015
Trust the Auto Industry?
The Auto Industry repeatedly CREATES software defects and mechanical problems, delays correcting the problem, jeopardizes lives.....
Koua Fong Lee couldn't stop his RUNAWAY TOYOTA CAMRY and killed these people....
Koua Fong Lee spent time in prison and strangers worked for his release....
All because of a pulley....[see Betsy Benjaminson]
...sore loser TOYOTA is appealing a jury verdict instead of correcting their problem.....
...that other TOYOTA CAMRY OWNERS testified they experienced.
Vehicles don't run properly and you/re supposed to TRUST their newest Super Duper innovation?
2011-2013 Chevrolet Volt Recalled To Upgrade Software & Ensure It Shuts Off
Wednesday, March 11, 2015
Toyota's "Expert" Contradicts Himself
Bob Hilliard Startled Courtroom in 1996 Toyota Camry Liability Lawsuit
By Trudy Baltazar:
Bob Hilliard certainly knows how to deliver a closing argument. Lee Carr of Carr Engineering had been on the stand all morning on this last day of the trial. I missed most of Carr’s testimony due to other commitments, but I was present during Bob’s cross examination of Carr and I heard both closing arguments.
Lee Carr had shown a video during his testimony (he was a witness for the defense (Toyota). Mr. Carrr said his firm had conducted some road tests on their course and they video taped various driver’s reactions to show how people would react when the vehicle they’re driving experiences a stuck throttle. One of the drivers tested was of a 60 yr old female who had supposedly accidentally hit the gas pedal instead of the brake when the car experienced this intentional stuck throttle. The video showed different screen shots all at once: one of the driver’s hands on the steering wheel, one of the driver’s feet showing what the feet were doing, and one showed a view of the course ahead through the windshield.
When Mr. Carrr played the video, he pointed out (with bullet points on the screen at conclusion) that this woman had been “driving along” on the course when they intentionally opened up the throttle on the vehicle. Mr. Carr said this 60 yr old woman had swerved in a zig-zag motion around some cones, but the main focus was on her feet. Suddenly after the throttle supposedly stuck open, the video showed her pumping the gas pedal (instead of the brake). Well Mr. Hilliard used this evidence against Toyota and Mr. Carr in his closing statement. According to Star Tribune who covered this case, Carr Engineering had been retained for $1.4 million for this trial and Carr Engr had received a total of $34 million from car manufacturers over a period of time. I should mention the $1.4 million included the services/testimony of Karl Stopchinksi as well.
When Mr. Hilliard played the video during his closing argument he pointed out the three bullet points in the summary portion of Carr’s video. #1) Mr. Carr said this woman had been “driving along”.
However, Mr. Hilliard pointed out the odometer in the video as we watched the video again. Mr. Hilliard paused the video at the point just prior to the woman pumping the gas pedal – so this would have been just prior to the throttle becoming intentionally stuck open. Well Bob pointed out the odometer showed she was driving 1 mph – yes one mph. Mr. Carr said she had been “driving along”.
2nd bullet point: Mr. Carr said the woman drove in a zig-zag pattern to avoid the cones. As mentioned earlier, one of the screen shots was of the driver’s hands on the steering wheel. Mr. Hilliard asked the jury to watch the driver’s hands ONLY and notice how her hands never move and the steering wheel never moves. In order to move in a zig-zag pattern, you have to turn the steering wheel back and forth some, but it never happened in this video. Her hands remained still and calm and were located on the bottom portion of the steering wheel. Her hands weren’t even in the 10:00 and 2:00 position.
Third bullet point of Mr. Carr’s: she had swerved around some cones. Mr. Hilliard asked us to focus on the screen shot of the course ahead as this woman is supposedly driving. He asked the jury, “do you see any cones anywhere?” There were none that we could see. Was Mr. Carr’s testimony of this video really the truth? Based on what I saw, I would have to say no. Actually, I don’t see how any of Mr. Carr’s testimony can be trusted. By the way, you know how much Mr. Hilliard paid for his two engineers who conducted tests and testified? $55-$65 thousand. -
See more at: http://www.hmglawfirm.com/news/bob-hilliard-startled-courtroom-in-1996-toyota-camry-liability-lawsuit/#sthash.FHQ8VkbJ.dpuf
Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Toyota's Tactics!
Koua Fong Lee went to prison because he was unable to STOP his RUNAWAY TOYOTA CAMRY!
Instead of fixing TOYOTAS.....restoring their reputation for dependability....
TOYOTA hires gaggles of attorneys to flood our courts with nonsense.....
Toyota, told to pay $10.9 million in car crash, wants driver to pay $4 million
- Article by: RANDY FURST , Star Tribune
- Updated: February 17, 2015 - 11:26 PM
The carmaker wants driver Koua Fong Lee to pay $4 million of its $10.9 million settlement.
The Toyota Motor Co., which was ordered by a jury to pay $10.9 million as a result of a fatal accident in St. Paul, has asked U.S. District Judge Ann Montgomery to make Koua Fong Lee pay more than $4 million of the award because the jury found Lee 40 percent at fault in the crash.
Bob Hilliard, the Texas attorney who represented Lee in the federal trial that ended earlier this month, was informed of the motion by a reporter. Hilliard called the proposal “baseless and desperate.”
Hilliard said that Toyota never filed a counterclaim against Lee, 37, the driver of the 1996 Toyota Camry. “They never brought him in as a third-party defendant,” Hilliard said. “They can’t now seek a contribution from him. It’s ridiculous.”
Following a three-week trial and about four days of deliberation, the jury of six men and six women on Feb. 3 found Toyota 60 percent at fault and Lee 40 percent at fault in the June 10, 2006, accident in St. Paul.
Lee’s attorneys argued that two nylon accelerator pulleys became stuck as Lee exited from eastbound Interstate 94 at Snelling Avenue, and despite efforts by Lee to apply the brakes, his Camry gained speed and rear-ended a 1995 Oldsmobile Ciera which was sitting at a stoplight at Snelling and Concordia. Toyota claimed Lee accidentally stepped on the gas pedal rather than the brakes.
The driver of the Ciera, Javis Trice-Adams, and his son, Javis Jr., 9, were killed instantly in the crash.
Devyn Bolton, 6, the daughter of his ex-wife, Bridgette Trice, sustained serious injuries and died more than a year later.
In one motion filed Tuesday, signed by Toyota attorney Bard Borkon, Toyota said that 40 percent of the $10.9 million in damages that Toyota must pay totals $4.076 million. “The $1,250,000 the jury awarded to him would offset some of the $4,076,000, but he would still owe Toyota $2,826,000,” the motion stated, adding that Lee should pay that amount.
Toyota also sought reductions in other payouts awarded to victims of the crash. For example, it said that Bridgette Trice was paid through insurance $1 million for medical expenses for her daughter, and $6,407 in funeral expenses. The $4 million Toyota was ordered to pay Trice and the little girl’s grandmother should be reduced by that amount, the Toyota attorneys wrote.
Similarly they asked that Quincy Adams, the little girl’s grandfather, who was also injured in the crash and received $1.25 million in the jury decision, should have it cut by $77,894 which were medical expenses for which he was already reimbursed.
Jemee Lee, Koua Fong Lee’s daughter, who got $150,000, should have her award reduced by $19,768 that she got through insurance, the Toyota motion said.
Jassmine Adams, who was also in the Ciera, was awarded $4 million for serious leg injuries she sustained that will require more surgery. She should have her payout reduced by $30,000 which she received from Lee’s insurer, the Toyota attorneys said.
The company also asked for several other reductions based on insurance payments.
Minnesota law requires attorneys seeking to have a jury award reduced for collateral payouts must file motions within 10 days of when the judgment is formally entered in court records.
Hilliard, Lee’s attorney, said Tuesday, “It’s amazing the world’s largest car company is now trying to nickel and dime this judgment and go after these very modest-income, working-class people.”
A Toyota spokesman said the company’s attorneys would not comment.
The lawyers also filed a motion asking for a hearing before Montgomery on April 22 or as soon thereafter that it can be scheduled.
THE PAID TOYOTA SHILLS ARE AT WORK!
How do you know who's a TOYOTA SHILL?
THE TOYOTA SHILLS resort to:
NAME CALLING
INTRODUCE FALSE ACCUSATIONS [such as Koua Fong Lee was intoxicated, when in fact, he was returning from church and no evidence of such has ever been presented]
MISREPRESENT THE FACTS or MAKE UP THEIR OWN
Continue to repeat the same lies
and much else clearly revealed in their comments
Thanks Toyota! You just made my next car purchase easy. I'll be sticking with Honda. Shut up and pay the damages. Trying to reduce the judgment to family members who lost their loved ones by nickel and diming this and that (and to Toyota it is nickel and diming) just convinced me.
For those that don't like it ....guess what??? This is America. In America juries are the finders of fact. The jury spoke. You may not like their decision, but you also weren't privy to much of the information which they had
For those that don't like it ....guess what??? This is America. In America juries are the finders of fact. The jury spoke. You may not like their decision, but you also weren't privy to much of the information which they had
NHTSA still has no documentation on suggested repair or maintenance on any of this equipment for 1996 camry's. The only thing close is a recall on cruise control acceleration with a recall date 10 yrs before this accident occurred. That recall makes no reference to breaks [sic] not working or not being able to auto turn off cruise control.
These 1996 camry's are almost 20 yrs old now. Every time this story comes up, I feel bad for everyone involved. But the party I get upset with is NHTSA. They've had ample time to put this issue to rest. Either there is a problem or not. They are the ones that have to use science, engineering, and facts to prove a problem does exist and to what extent.
These 1996 camry's are almost 20 yrs old now. Every time this story comes up, I feel bad for everyone involved. But the party I get upset with is NHTSA. They've had ample time to put this issue to rest. Either there is a problem or not. They are the ones that have to use science, engineering, and facts to prove a problem does exist and to what extent.
What poor PR on Toyota's part. My last three cars I purchased were Toyotas. I've lost a lot of respect for Toyota with their tactics in this case. I think I'm done buying Toyotas.
gutshot 5ptsFeatured
Ok folks, this is tactical. Toyota is upping the ante to force a settlement that will vacate the verdict. It does not give a rip about this case except for the bad precedent it sets for many other cases. Google res judicata/collateral estoppel.
JohnnyRockran 5ptsFeatured
I will never buy another Toyota as long as I live, or at least until I see some of Toyota's "top brass" agree to spend 60% of Mr. Lee's time in prison behind bars.
csjohn1 5ptsFeatured
As a Toyota Camry owner, Toyota's actions/inactions are shameful. Sorry, Toyota, you lost me as a customer.
csjohn1 5ptsFeatured
@aqualungman "Tort Reform" is nothing less that a GOP gift to corporations. Limit liability on malpractice and misfeasance only encourages bad behavior. Tell me aqualungman, if your brand new regulator failed because of design or manufacturing flaws and you suffered irrecoverable brain damage would a gross limit on compensation be okay with you and your caregivers? We should not protect corporations from liability. GAD!!
codger1016 5ptsFeatured
I have owned several Toyotas in the past. Never again.
Mtka 5ptsFeatured
@codger1016 I have owned 3 Toyota Corollas. I have been driving the current one for 18 years. At 103,000 miles it is starting to show a little rust around the back wheel wells. The body will go long before the engine does.
That said, I am rethinking which brand to go with in the future.
Toyota - do the right thing and foot the entire bill. This man spent two years away from his young family. He has paid enough. Don't tarnish your image any further.
berrymom 5ptsFeatured
That said, I am rethinking which brand to go with in the future.
Toyota - do the right thing and foot the entire bill. This man spent two years away from his young family. He has paid enough. Don't tarnish your image any further.
@codger1016 I've never owned one, and certainly won't now. There is nothing wrong with letting your pocketbook speak for your moral values. It's no longer about the quality of the vehicles; it is about the honor and integrity of the management of Toyota.
rshackleford 5ptsFeatured
rshackleford 5ptsFeatured
JUST MY OPINION....AT THE MOMENT!
Why did Toyota OK the use of nylon pulleys in something so extremely important as the accelerator cable routing? A hint: they can MELT and WARP plus become brittle after heating and cooling over many years time.
I want to ask that question to the engineer that proposed and had the design approved. Were metal pulleys just that much more expensive?
I want to ask that question to the engineer that proposed and had the design approved. Were metal pulleys just that much more expensive?
@aqualungman Two minutes of research shows that engineering grade nylon (called "Nylon 6-6") has a melting temperature of 516F. And, if the engineering grade was not used, that temp is much lower.
That is the MELTING point. I bet warping (due to softening of the nylon) occurs at a much lower temperature, especially with a tensioned wire/cable wrapped around a portion of it is causing physical stress.
PLUS, all critical parts are supposed to have a "safety factor" of 3 (three). So, 516/3 is 172F. That part should never reach or exceed 172F.
Also, while cleaning, I found a pair of 20 year old Bauer "Turbo" (all plastic bodied) hockey skates. They used to easily support every bit of torque my 225 lbs could put into them. But, when I picked one up, the nearly 1/4" thick plastic ankle area broke apart into pieces. It had dried out and become brittle. And they have been in the basement for years at a stable temperature, not inside a vehicle's engine bay.
That is the MELTING point. I bet warping (due to softening of the nylon) occurs at a much lower temperature, especially with a tensioned wire/cable wrapped around a portion of it is causing physical stress.
PLUS, all critical parts are supposed to have a "safety factor" of 3 (three). So, 516/3 is 172F. That part should never reach or exceed 172F.
Also, while cleaning, I found a pair of 20 year old Bauer "Turbo" (all plastic bodied) hockey skates. They used to easily support every bit of torque my 225 lbs could put into them. But, when I picked one up, the nearly 1/4" thick plastic ankle area broke apart into pieces. It had dried out and become brittle. And they have been in the basement for years at a stable temperature, not inside a vehicle's engine bay.
JUST MY OPINION....AT THE MOMENT!
Wednesday, February 4, 2015
"How can you trust Toyota?"
When Justice Isn’t Justice: Jury Finds Toyota Guilty of Design Defect in ’96 Camry But Only 60% At Fault
And then there's the WHISTLE BLOWER that TOYOTA is trying to silence....do you wonder WHY?
Bob Hilliard's good question: "How can you trust Toyota?"
Doesn't there seem to be an increasing erosion of TOYOTA BRAND CREDIBILITY?
The Jury got part of it right!
JUST MY OPINION .... AT THE MOMENT!
Friday, January 30, 2015
Prison For a Defective TOYOTA?

Release of Koua Fong Lee
ABC NEWS: Toyota Driver Koua Fong Lee Released from Prison; No New Trial for Deadly CrashCNN NEWS: Minnesota Judge Frees Minnesota Man
WCCO NEWS: Judge Frees Koua Fong Lee...Charges Dismissed
The Koua Fong Lee Story
Koua Fong Lee came to America with his family from a Thailand refugee camp in 2004, looking for a better life and an education. Instead, Mr. Lee has been serving an 8-year prison sentence for criminal vehicular homicide, following a 2006 car crash that killed three people.Koua Fong Lee was returning home from church on June 10, 2007. He was driving a 1996 Toyota Camry. His pregnant wife sat beside him. His 8-year-old daughter, his brother and father sat in the backseat. He was traveling from Minneapolis to his home in St. Paul. The radio was off and he was not talking on a cellphone. He exited I-94 eastbound onto the Snelling Avenue exit ramp traveling at 50-55 mph. He took his foot off the accelerator and applied the brake as he approached the intersection of Concordia and Snelling Avenues. The brakes did not slow the Camry. Mr. Lee yelled to his family ”brakes not working!”
Mr. Lee continued to pump and press the brake pedal. The Camry would not slow but instead continued to accelerate. He moved from the most left lane of the ramp to the center lane, avoiding vehicles traveling in front of him. He then moved from the center lane to the far right lane of the ramp to avoiding hitting other vehicles traveling and stopped on the ramp. Mr. Lee continued to pump and press the brake pedal during these maneuvers. The was no place for him to go as he approached the intersection. The signal light was red and cars were stopped at the intersection. One was stopped in the far right lane and the other about two vehicle lengths off the intersection in the center lane. Mr. Lee observed a space between the two stopped vehicles. He attempted to negotiate his vehicle through the space. As he split the two vehicles, he sideswiped the vehicle in the center lane. The force of the initial collision redirected his vehicle into the rear driver-side of the second vehicle stopped in the far left lane. Mr. Lee's Camry recoiled back from the collision and then accelerated forward across the intersection of Snelling and Concordia. Mr. Lee struck the rear driver-side of another vehicle that was traveling northbound on Snelling. Mr. Lee's Camry came to rest against a fence across the intersection. Two people in the second vehicle struck by Mr. Lee's Camry died at the scene and another young girl died a year and a half later. Three others were seriously injured.
Investigators calculated that Mr. Lee's car was traveling 70 to 90 miles an hour when it slammed into the back of a stopped Oldsmobile, instantly killing Javis Adams, 33, and his 10-year-old son, Javis Adams Jr. Another passenger, 6-year-old Devyn Bolton, died from her injuries more than a year later.
After examining the vehicle, a mechanic found nothing wrong with the brakes. Prosecutors argued that Lee stepped on the gas, not the brake, and a jury agreed, convicting him of criminal vehicular homicide and sentenced him to 8 years in prison.
Lee fired his attorney following his conviction and retained Minneapolis Attorney Brent S. Schafer to represent him at the sentencing phase of the case. Schafer filed extensive documentation with the judge who would be sentencing Lee. Schafer requested and argued that Lee serve only 1 year in jail rather than several in prison, as required by Minnesota law. Following a lengthy sentencing hearing, the Judge disagreed with Schafer and sentenced Lee to spend 8 years in prison.
Attorney Brent S. Schafer says his client has always focused on the brakes as the problem. "He could only explain what happened in that he tried to apply the brakes and it didn't work and that the vehicle would only accelerate up the ramp," Schafer said.
In January of 2010, Schafer reopened the Lee case after numerous Toyota recalls for sudden unintended acceleration (SUA). Schafer teamed-up with a well known products liability attorney, Robert Hilliard of Corpus Christi, Texas. Together Schafer and Hilliard promised Lee that they would do whatever it took to gain his release and a new trial. Schafer soon discovered that Lee was not the only owner of a 1996 Toyota Camry that had accelerated out-of-control.
After Lee's story was reported in newspapers and news programs such as CNN, MSNBC, Good Morning America and World News Tonight, Schafer was flooded with letters, e-mails and calls from people all over the country who had experienced the same SUA as described by Lee. Schafer said, "It was at this point in time when I was absolutely convinced that there was an innocent man in prison."
This was a defective prosecution caused by a defective car." Schafer collected affidavits from over 50 late-model Toyota drivers throughout the United States, each one describing an experiencing during which their Toyota would accelerate out-of-control.
In April of 2010, Schafer and Hilliard filed a Petition for Post Conviction Relief seeking a new trial for Lee based upon the new evidence of SUA, the ineffective assistance of trial counsel and improper/wrong expert testimony during trial. In July, a Ramsey County District Court Judge granted Lee's request for a hearing to determine whether he was entitled to a new trial. The hearing was scheduled to begin on August 2, 2010.
On Tuesday, August 3, 2010 during the second day of an evidentiary hearing, two more victims of sudden acceleration testified that their vehicles sped out of control just like Koua Lee’s 1996 Toyota Camry. Expert witnesses also testified about important key facts -- reasons his lawyers say Koua Lee should be given a new trial. “From the moment Lee stepped out of the vehicle and was interviewed by the police officer at the scene he said he was pushing the brakes,” said defense attorney Bob Hilliard. “He said that through trial and his lawyer stood up and told the jury the exact opposite.” In the original trial, his attorney told a jury that Lee may have simply been confused. That he mistakenly pressed the gas when he thought he was hitting the brake. But Lee never gave his attorney permission to make that statement. “This is your lawyer telling the jury that you’re wrong,” said Hilliard. “That his client is wrong,”
Samuel Sero, a forensic engineer testified that Lee’s Toyota Camry was equipped with ABS brakes at the time of the accident. But the jury that convicted Lee of criminal vehicular homicide was told the car did not have anti-lock brakes. “That’s a big deal because they had to show the brakes were functioning properly so they put on testimony that Mr. Lee’s brakes were working and he said he was braking. If that was true he would have stopped.” Hilliard says, that would explain why there were no skid marks at the scene. A technical witness who inspected the car back in April testified the tail lights showed the brakes were being applied at the time of the crash. “Everybody, even the state’s experts agree that light, when you look at it today right now, shows that the light was on at the time of impact,” said Hilliard.
On August 5, 2010, the morning of the final day of the trial, the Ramsey County Attorney offered to release Mr. Lee and allow him to go home. However, the County Attorney would not agree to reverse the convictions and give Mr. Lee a clean criminal record. Accepting the offer would return Mr. Lee to his wife and four children but he would arrive back home a convicted felon on probation for nearly 15 years and a person not eligible for a driver's license for the next 10 years. Mr. Lee declined the offered. Later that day Lee sat quietly and watched Schafer stand before the Judge and lay out in detail the new evidence and other legal reasons that entitled Mr. Lee to a new trial.
At approximately 5:00 p.m. on August 5, 2010, in a highly anticipated decision by a Ramsey County, Minnesota Judge, Koua Fong Lee was granted a retrial and released from prison! Later that day, the Ramsey County Attorney announced that they would not be retrying Mr. Lee.
See the back-story on the Koua Fong Lee Toyota Case below:
ABC News Special Report with Brian Ross--Part 1ABC News Special Report with Brian Ross--Part 2
CNN Minnesota Man Jailed for Fatal Toyota Accident...Defective Toyota?
- See more at: http://www.schaferlawfirm.com/noteworthy-cases/koua-fong-lee-toyota-case/#sthash.zJ398r65.dpuf
Jury asks to see video of Toyota accelerator test
Ba Boom! Expert in Koua Fong Lee v Toyota trial -- Lee "stepped on brakes"
Jury asks to see video of Toyota accelerator test
- Article by: RANDY FURST , Star Tribune
- Updated: January 29, 2015 - 9:01 PM
Members want to view tests done on Camry’s throttle control box.
Jurors deliberating the liability case involving Toyota Motor Corp. indicated Thursday that they wanted to look at video that was played during the trial in U.S. District Court in Minneapolis.
They finished their first full day of deliberations Thursday and will resume at 9 a.m. Friday.
Toyota is accused in a lawsuit of installing a defective accelerator system in its 1996 Camry, causing a crash in 2006 in St. Paul that resulted in the deaths of three people and a prison term for the Camry’s driver, Kuoa Fong Lee. Lee, his family and relatives of the victims have sued for damages.
Jurors asked for viewing equipment so they could watch two versions of a video of a test by John Stilson, an Illinois-based automotive consultant hired by Lee’s attorneys. The videos showed Stilson using a hair dryer to heat up the throttle control box that controls acceleration of the Camry.
The jurors were given an edited video shown at the trial and a longer, unedited version.
Stilson contends that when heated, two nylon pulleys in the accelerator system got stuck. Toyota attorneys argued that Stilson did not conduct the tests properly.
The crash occurred June 10, 2006, when the Camry struck an Oldsmobile Ciera at the end of the Snelling Avenue exit off eastbound Interstate 94. Killed were the Ciera’s driver, Javis Trice-Adams, 33, and his son, Javis Adams Jr., 9. His daughter Devyn Bolton, 6, was paralyzed and later died.
Advertisement: Replay Ad
![]() |
Ads by ZINC
|
If jurors find the Camry was not defective, Toyota wins. If they find it was defective they must decide if the car’s design “was a direct cause of the plaintiffs’ injuries.” If they find it was, they must decide if Lee was negligent.
Depending on those answers, the jury may have to assess what percentage of blame, totaling 100 percent, must be attributed to Toyota Motor Corp. and to Lee.
They must also decide any damages for Trice-Adams’ daughter Jassmine, who was injured in the crash. If Toyota is deemed at fault, the jury can award damages to Lee, to the other passengers in the Camry and to Devyn Bolton’s mother and grandmother, Bridgette Rice and Carolyn Trice.
They must also consider damages for Quincy Adams, Bolton’s grandfather.
Friday, January 16, 2015
Toyota Lies about Plastic Pulleys that caused Deaths!
The people were killed because of TOYOTA'S Defective Design:
And TOYOTA LIES? [see comments below]
Trudy Baltazar authored this book to document the fight of strangers to free Koua Fong Lee:
Ms. Baltazar is in the courtroom documenting the trial against TOYOTA and has been commenting elsewhere.
Update of courtroom activity on Thurs., 1-15-15
A toyota
employee gave a deposition on 12-4-14 (they showed the dep in court for us all
to see) stating heat tests were conducted on these 2 plastic pulleys which have
been proven to be defective when exposed to a certain degree & amount of
heat.
The pulleys are part of the throttle body and they control the accelerator
cable. When the upper pulley is working properly, the pulley will release the
accelerator cable when one takes their foot off the gas. I think I mentioned
yesterday the expert mech engr who heated the pulleys to 165 deg and the top
pulley that the accelerator cable goes into binds up against the metal bracket
it’s up against and won't release the accelerator cable. It appears the pulley
gets stuck to the metal bracket/plate.
It took ~7 mins for the pulley to cool
down and release the accelerator cable. Well in the toyota deposition, this
employee of 40+ yrs stated that they had heat tests done on these pulleys for 8
days @ 248 deg F. This expert for the plaintiff’s used a hair dryer for 30 mins
and got the pulley to heat up to 165 deg and the pulley wouldn't function
properly at that temp. Well 3 weeks before toyota employee gave the deposition,
they learned that the heat tests on the plastic pulleys had NEVER been
conducted!
Three weeks later this toyota employee swore in a deposition that the
tests were done. In cross examination, the toyota lawyer asked the expert John
Stilson, "did you take the 1996 Camry for a drive and hook up monitoring
equipment to the pulleys and the metal bracket to see in real life situation if
the pulleys were heating up due to real driving time? Expert's answer, "no,
because I wanted to follow toyota test specification". cross examination ended
not too long after that.
Turns out it’s in toyota’s own 1996 Camry owner’s manual
that (paraphrasing here) ‘If you need to conduct a test to see if a part is
malfunctioning due to heat, use a hair dryer’ and they even show a picture of a
hair dryer.
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Toyota's Plastic Pulleys
Toyota denies fault for fatal St. Paul crash
By Elizabeth Mohr
POSTED: 01/08/2015 12:01:00 AM CST
http://www.twincities.com/localnews/ci_27285687/toyota-driver-debate-fatal-st-paul-crash-trial
--------------------------------------------------------
Trudy Groppoli Baltazar
So, I have to say my favorite statement by Bob Hilliard during his opening statement on Thursday in this lawsuit. He showed the Toyota testing specification for when Toyota tested their 1996 Camry LE before determining if it was safe or not. The test was specifically for the Accelerator Control System (ACS). The ACS that Toyota tested all contained metal pulleys which control the accelerator cable.
Well as it turns out, Koua's '96 Camry has plastic pulleys. Toyota never tested the ACS units with plastic pulleys. Unreal.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

















