Showing posts with label Toyota lies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Toyota lies. Show all posts
Saturday, January 31, 2015
TOYOTA's Expert LIES UNSUCCESSFULLY, Paid $1.4 MILLION!
Doesn't this beat all?
Thanks go to Trudy Baltazar for documenting TOYOTA'S ANTICS!
Bob Hilliard Startled Courtroom in 1996 Toyota Camry Liability Lawsuit
http://trulinespublishing.com/2015/01/31/bob-hilliard-startles-courtroom-1996-toyota-camry-liability-lawsuit/
Let's not forget that TOYOTA BLAMED THE DRIVER in Oklahoma [Bookout & Schwarz] and couldn't explain SKID MARKS indicating the DRIVER tried to slow the RUNAWAY TOYOTA!
When the jury didn't believe TOYOTA'S LIES, TOYOTA rushed to settle with a confidentiality agreement. We'll never know what lives are worth to TOYOTA!
Friday, January 16, 2015
Toyota Lies about Plastic Pulleys that caused Deaths!
The people were killed because of TOYOTA'S Defective Design:
And TOYOTA LIES? [see comments below]
Trudy Baltazar authored this book to document the fight of strangers to free Koua Fong Lee:
Ms. Baltazar is in the courtroom documenting the trial against TOYOTA and has been commenting elsewhere.
Update of courtroom activity on Thurs., 1-15-15
A toyota
employee gave a deposition on 12-4-14 (they showed the dep in court for us all
to see) stating heat tests were conducted on these 2 plastic pulleys which have
been proven to be defective when exposed to a certain degree & amount of
heat.
The pulleys are part of the throttle body and they control the accelerator
cable. When the upper pulley is working properly, the pulley will release the
accelerator cable when one takes their foot off the gas. I think I mentioned
yesterday the expert mech engr who heated the pulleys to 165 deg and the top
pulley that the accelerator cable goes into binds up against the metal bracket
it’s up against and won't release the accelerator cable. It appears the pulley
gets stuck to the metal bracket/plate.
It took ~7 mins for the pulley to cool
down and release the accelerator cable. Well in the toyota deposition, this
employee of 40+ yrs stated that they had heat tests done on these pulleys for 8
days @ 248 deg F. This expert for the plaintiff’s used a hair dryer for 30 mins
and got the pulley to heat up to 165 deg and the pulley wouldn't function
properly at that temp. Well 3 weeks before toyota employee gave the deposition,
they learned that the heat tests on the plastic pulleys had NEVER been
conducted!
Three weeks later this toyota employee swore in a deposition that the
tests were done. In cross examination, the toyota lawyer asked the expert John
Stilson, "did you take the 1996 Camry for a drive and hook up monitoring
equipment to the pulleys and the metal bracket to see in real life situation if
the pulleys were heating up due to real driving time? Expert's answer, "no,
because I wanted to follow toyota test specification". cross examination ended
not too long after that.
Turns out it’s in toyota’s own 1996 Camry owner’s manual
that (paraphrasing here) ‘If you need to conduct a test to see if a part is
malfunctioning due to heat, use a hair dryer’ and they even show a picture of a
hair dryer.
Thursday, December 4, 2014
Toyota lessons lost on Takata as it resists U.S. recall order
![]() |
Charlene M. Blake (@charleneblake) |
|
JOKE of the day! #Toyota: don't blame anyone for our problems - not...the
media, and certainly not the customer." mobile.reuters.com/article/idUSL3…
| |
“First, never lie, .... “ (The Toyota Way ... )
Toyota lessons lost on Takata as it resists U.S. recall order
By Chang-Ran Kim
TOKYO Thu Dec 4, 2014 4:15am EST
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
(excerpts):
TOYOTA CRISIS BLUEPRINT
Takata's approach is in contrast to Toyota Motor Corp's handling of a
massive recall in early 2010. Toyota was slammed for its initial response to
cases of unintended acceleration in its cars, but got back on track, providing
something of a blueprint for how to steer through such crises.
Toyota insiders said CEO Akio Toyoda was a driving force for transparency
and accountability. "Akio gave me three requirements," Steve St Angelo, then
Toyota's quality chief in North America, told reporters in Japan recently.
"First, never lie, even if it hurts Toyota; second, don't blame anyone for
our problems - not the government, the media, and certainly not the customer.
And third, don't ever, ever put the safety of our customers in jeopardy. If it's
black and white, you take fast action. If you're not sure ... you (err) on the
side of customers' safety," he recalled.
![]() |
Charlene M. Blake (@charleneblake) |
|
Are. You. Kidding. Me. #Toyota Akio Toyoda done opposite! Stonewalling about
ELECTRONIC #SUA & lying to #customers! mobile.reuters.com/article/idUSL3…
| |
Saturday, November 15, 2014
Here come the TOYOTA SHILLS!
"Professional provocateur" ?
Kind description of PAID TOYOTA SHILLS!
What's TOYOTA hiding?
THE TRUTH?
![]() |
Charlene M. Blake (@charleneblake) |
|
#Professional #provocateur UPSET about #defective #Toyota #Corolla #Ruginis case! Attacking #commenters viciously! wpri.com/2014/11/13/fed…
| |
Download the official Twitter app here
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Parris Boyd
Here we go again with another "performance" by the auto industry's little lapdog. Never mind NHTSA's complicity in GM's ignition-switch scandal and Takata's exploding airbags, not to mention NHTSA's refusal to address evidence GALORE - presented by embedded systems expert MIchael Barr - of electronic defects in Toyota's throttle control. The problem is a corporate-controlled government - Repukes n Demagogues alike - incapable of taking action against its murderous, blood-drenched cohorts in the auto industry. I've been blogging about the situation - search "Beware of Toyota. Their next victim may be YOU..."
I am a victim of sudden unintended acceleration and there many more out there like me. We need a better system in place to protect consumers from the lies and cover up of auto makers..
Sudden UnintendedAcceleration is real, it happened to me in 2005. I had purchased a brand new 2004 ES 330 Lexus while sitting at the red light my
car took off like a rocket going through the red light. By the time I realized what was happening my car was going over 100 miles an hour and I realized that I did not have brake and I could hear the accelerator revving. All I was able to do hold on to the wheel trying to avoid hitting anyone. All I could think that my car was going to kill people. I was so fortunate that no one was kill and what eventually happen I end up on the other side of the street hitting a SUV head on totaling both cars.
The dashboard fell on my legs and crushed both legs severely. The SUV driver had some minor damages. As the result of my Lexus suddenly accelerating, I have had 24 surgeries and more in future. My left leg will have to be amputated above the knee since surgery can not do any good anymore and my right ankle will have to be fused since I am in sever pain. I hope Toyota stops the lies and fix those cars rather than blaming the elderly, teens, texting, medical issues or anything else Toyota can come up with except its sudden unintended acceleration in its cars.
Azar Hadi Brannan
Azar Hadi
Sudden UnintendedAcceleration is real, it happened to me in 2005. I had purchased a brand new 2004 ES 330 Lexus while sitting at the red light my
car took off like a rocket going through the red light. By the time I realized what was happening my car was going over 100 miles an hour and I realized that I did not have brake and I could hear the accelerator revving. All I was able to do hold on to the wheel trying to avoid hitting anyone. All I could think that my car was going to kill people. I was so fortunate that no one was kill and what eventually happen I end up on the other side of the street hitting a SUV head on totaling both cars.
The dashboard fell on my legs and crushed both legs severely. The SUV driver had some minor damages. As the result of my Lexus suddenly accelerating, I have had 24 surgeries and more in future. My left leg will have to be amputated above the knee since surgery can not do any good anymore and my right ankle will have to be fused since I am in sever pain. I hope Toyota stops the lies and fix those cars rather than blaming the elderly, teens, texting, medical issues or anything else Toyota can come up with except its sudden unintended acceleration in its cars.
Azar Hadi Brannan
Azar Hadi
Highway patrol was not able too, remember this case was settled for $10,000,000 out of court.
Case Bookout vs Toyota Mr. Micheal Barr proved that when cars like Toyota/Lexus accelerate there is nothing you can do to stop them due to electronic defects and if you remember Toyota lost this landmark case.
On August 28, 2009, California Highway Patrol Officer Mark
Saylor, his wife, daughter and brother-in-law were killed in an uncontrolled acceleration crash in a 2009 Lexus ES350 in San Diego. Unlike the many deadly Toyota sudden acceleration before, this crash was captured on a 911 call made by Mrs Saylor from the speeding car with a stuck accelerator before it crashed and killed all the occupants. At the time of the crash, NHTSA did not have a single open investigation in Toyota sudden acceleration. Toyota exploited to avoid recalls
until the tragic crash in San Diego in August 2009 that resulted in 4 deaths in a Lexus driven by an experienced highway patrol officer who was unable to bring the vehicle to a stop. But
for the crash being caught on a 911 tape, the recent recalls would not have occurred because the crash would have gone unnoticed like so many before it which the agency blamed on driver error
FRANKOK
Azar Hadi
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Azar Hadi
Case Bookout vs Toyota Mr. Micheal Barr proved that when cars like Toyota/Lexus accelerate there is nothing you can do to stop them due to electronic defects and if you remember Toyota lost this landmark case.
On August 28, 2009, California Highway Patrol Officer Mark
Saylor, his wife, daughter and brother-in-law were killed in an uncontrolled acceleration crash in a 2009 Lexus ES350 in San Diego. Unlike the many deadly Toyota sudden acceleration before, this crash was captured on a 911 call made by Mrs Saylor from the speeding car with a stuck accelerator before it crashed and killed all the occupants. At the time of the crash, NHTSA did not have a single open investigation in Toyota sudden acceleration. Toyota exploited to avoid recalls
until the tragic crash in San Diego in August 2009 that resulted in 4 deaths in a Lexus driven by an experienced highway patrol officer who was unable to bring the vehicle to a stop. But
for the crash being caught on a 911 tape, the recent recalls would not have occurred because the crash would have gone unnoticed like so many before it which the agency blamed on driver error
FRANKOK
Saudi Arabia knows what to do - why not the NHTSA?
I never owned one but am always concerned for friends and family who do.
There should be a push to force Toyota to install brake override on all that have the electronics and code evaluated by the 12 experts - NASA did not have the source code for their review.
From:
http://www.albawaba.com/busine...
Over 141,000 Toyota and Lexus cars recalled over dangers of sudden
acceleration The recall of as many as 141,007 Toyota and Lexus cars has been initiated in the sultanate to install Smart Stop Technology, a brake override system, in
their vehicles to curtail dangers associated with sudden acceleration.
I never owned one but am always concerned for friends and family who do.
There should be a push to force Toyota to install brake override on all that have the electronics and code evaluated by the 12 experts - NASA did not have the source code for their review.
From:
http://www.albawaba.com/busine...
Over 141,000 Toyota and Lexus cars recalled over dangers of sudden
acceleration The recall of as many as 141,007 Toyota and Lexus cars has been initiated in the sultanate to install Smart Stop Technology, a brake override system, in
their vehicles to curtail dangers associated with sudden acceleration.
Azar Hadi
Thank you for your comment and we need more people like you to speak against Toyota and Lexus. You should be worried about friends and families, sudden unintended acceleration has killed and injured over 2000 people in US alone. Why is it that Saudi Arabia values people's life more that US government?
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Ah, professional provocateur is concerned about the Robert & Kathy Ruginis defective Toyota Corolla case! And rightly so as here are the earmarks of a major automotive scandal!
Censorship and critic discrediting is in full force by Toyota $$friends as professional provocateur has pointed out, especially when it concerns evidence of electronic glitches which cause Toyota and Lexus vehicles to become uncontrollable and unstoppable! Why these glitches often cause these vehicles to become airborne just prior to a horrific crash!
Censorship and critic discrediting is in full force by Toyota $$friends as professional provocateur has pointed out, especially when it concerns evidence of electronic glitches which cause Toyota and Lexus vehicles to become uncontrollable and unstoppable! Why these glitches often cause these vehicles to become airborne just prior to a horrific crash!
Azar Hadi
Landmark case Bookout vs Toyota last October where Toyota lost not only had to pay compensatory, but also punitive damages to victims. It was this case that sent Toyota to settlement mode. Over 500 cases going through MEDIATION right now all over US. Some will end up in trial which will show more exposure of the defect that causes accelerations something that Toyota is trying to avoid. It would have been so much cheaper if Toyota/Lexus had done the right thing rather than hiding their sudden unintended acceleration issues and murdering and injuring innocent people..
Azar Hadi
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Azar Hadi
Azar Hadi
I am just wondering where the next job will be for Mr. David Friedman since he is not doing much for the public when comes to Toyota/Lexus sudden unintended acceleration??? I have an idea, I am pretty sure his next job will be a highly paid job at Toyota just like Mr. Christopher Santucci, a revolving door..
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Excellent question, Azar! I know you are especially concerned since you are a Toyota Lexus sudden unintended acceleration victim yourself! You've no doubt watched as former NHTSA regulator Christopher Santucci narrowed the focus of the previous Toyota SUA investigation so that no real steps were taken to uncover and FIX the electronic glitches in the ETCS-i software that Michael Barr later found in the Bookout v Toyota Camry fatal death case. It must be devastating to see a paid NHTSA employee, where our taxes are contributed, allegedly allow Toyota to HIDE the serious safety defects and then go on to be EMPLOYED by the automaker! This seems more than criminal; it seems immoral and unconscionable to me!
Let's watch what Mr. David Friedman does in this very important Toyota Corolla unintended acceleration case! IF he does not open a defect investigation, then consumers need to organize...BIG time! This case has all the earmarks of a serious safety defect in a Toyota that could lead to untold numbers of deaths, injuries, and destruction!
IF a defect investigation is opened and then closed in short order as so many have been done in the past in the Toyota and Lexus sudden unintended acceleration, then a major public backlash needs to occur! This would be blatantly ignoring an on-going serious DEADLY situation in these Corolla vehicles!
Let's watch what Mr. David Friedman does in this very important Toyota Corolla unintended acceleration case! IF he does not open a defect investigation, then consumers need to organize...BIG time! This case has all the earmarks of a serious safety defect in a Toyota that could lead to untold numbers of deaths, injuries, and destruction!
IF a defect investigation is opened and then closed in short order as so many have been done in the past in the Toyota and Lexus sudden unintended acceleration, then a major public backlash needs to occur! This would be blatantly ignoring an on-going serious DEADLY situation in these Corolla vehicles!
Azar Hadi
Thanks Charlene, I am so grateful to see a consumer advocate like yourself spending her precious time working so hard to bring changes about and make unscrupulous auto makers like Toyota/Lexus accountable for their criminal activities. Being blocked by sites who support and get paid by Toyota $$$ to me is simply blood of people who have been killed and injured and I am an example of sudden unintended acceleration who injured badly in a Lexus.
Charlene McCarthy
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Charlene McCarthy
You are welcome, Azar! I have *twenty* years of auto consumer advocacy. When I was involved in the Toyota engine oil sludge debacle, a professional provocateur implied that I had single-handedly created the HOAX back in late 2000.
Well, we all know what ultimately happened there. It was certainly no hoax! There is a May 13, 2002 Automotive News article that highlights my efforts in that serious matter. The oil sludge issue pales in comparison to the Toyota & Lexus electronic throttle control system software defect! I can see why the automaker might be concerned about online dialogue about this potentially deadly defect!
Well, we all know what ultimately happened there. It was certainly no hoax! There is a May 13, 2002 Automotive News article that highlights my efforts in that serious matter. The oil sludge issue pales in comparison to the Toyota & Lexus electronic throttle control system software defect! I can see why the automaker might be concerned about online dialogue about this potentially deadly defect!
Charlene McCarthy Blake
Just by speaking out to those similarly-impacted, you are making a huge difference! Thank you so much for sharing your story! You are FAR FROM ALONE!
What an automaker, particularly one like Toyota which has admitted to hiding defects and not telling the truth, wants least is for vehicle owners to NETWORK to EXPOSE these same problems!
Kudos to your effort to reach out to those who may not yet know the truth!
What an automaker, particularly one like Toyota which has admitted to hiding defects and not telling the truth, wants least is for vehicle owners to NETWORK to EXPOSE these same problems!
Kudos to your effort to reach out to those who may not yet know the truth!
Wednesday, November 5, 2014
Toyota employs GAGGLES of ATTORNEYS to deny justice to consumers.....
...but TOYOTA LIED ABOUT LEATHER?
Not until TOYOTA gets caught with its pants down does TOYOTA amend their illegal business practice....
Toyota Busted for Faux Leather Claims
Published by Nadeem Muaddi
'
We recently inducted Kia Motors into The Hog Ring‘s “Hall of Shame” for duping customers into believing that its popular Sportage SUV is trimmed in genuine leather – when, in fact, it features almost no real leather at all.
Sadly, we must now induct Toyota Motor Corporation for a similar offense.
According to the Herald Sun, a popular Aussie newspaper, the Japanese automaker made false claims about leather interiors in several of its models for approximately four years.
Toyota has been busted by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission for making false claims about leather seats across several car ranges sold between 2005 and 2009.
They were in fact partial or faux leather.
”The ACCC was concerned that consumers were likely to have been misled by these claims. If consumers are prepared to pay a premium to have quality finishes for their car interiors, they are entitled to get what they paid for,” ACCC chairman Rod Sims said.
Toyota issued a statement today apologising to customers: ”Toyota Australia acknowledges the statement from Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. We apologise if any customer felt they were misled as a result of our advertising.” [...]
Toyota says that as soon as it became aware of the issue it changed advertising to ‘leather accent’ or ‘leather accented’. [more]
If Toyota was really interested in honest advertising, it would use clear and obvious terms that customers are already familiar with – like faux or synthetic leather.
http://www.thehogring.com/2013/02/12/toyota-busted-for-faux-leather-claims/
Friday, August 8, 2014
TOYOTA'S CORPORATE PLAYBOOK....Just continue the LIES!
So....you get caught.....
....the wise person changes their behavior.....
....not so TOYODA.....
...BETSY said it best!
O spotted leopard
Betsy Benjaminson exposed TOYOTA'S LIES!
PLEASE make a contribution in whatever amount you can afford to support the TRUTH BEING HEARD:
Can we allow TOYOTA to SILENCE THE
TRUTH and jeopardize lives?
Sunday, June 22, 2014
Discredit! Discredit! Discredit! #2
This beautiful 4-year-old cherub, Lily Quintus, was killed when an OUT-OF-CONTROL TOYOTA SOLARA plowed into her Day Care Center......
Reports indicate that the TOYOTA SOLARA DRIVER attempted to SLOW THE RUNAWAY TOYOTA, left skid marks that are clearly visible in photos and at one point, THE TOYOTA SOLARA became airborne.
ALSO:
In Memorium: Lily Quintas
Will TOYOTA Ever Step Forward?TOYOTA: "....pervasive corporate arrogance...."
In an exclusive interview with ABC News, a former top lawyer for Toyota claims the automaker regularly hid evidence of safety defects from consumers and regulators, and fostered a culture of "hypocrisy and deceit."
"You have to understand that Toyota in Japan does not have any respect for our legal system," said Dimitrios Biller, who worked as managing counsel for Toyota's American operations from 2003 to 2007. "They did not have any respect for our laws."
Biller handled product liability suits while with the company. He claims that when Toyota received poor results in a vehicle rollover test, it ordered a new test in order to receive better results. According to Biller, the company also made a practice of concealing proof of safety problems, and did not disclose information it was obligated to produce
1) Why haven't Professor David Gilbert's and embedded systems expert Michael Barr's findings of an electronic fault without adequate fail-safe in the Toyota ETCS been fully examined?
"You have to understand that Toyota in Japan does not have any respect for our legal system," said Dimitrios Biller, who worked as managing counsel for Toyota's American operations from 2003 to 2007. "They did not have any respect for our laws."
Biller handled product liability suits while with the company. He claims that when Toyota received poor results in a vehicle rollover test, it ordered a new test in order to receive better results. According to Biller, the company also made a practice of concealing proof of safety problems, and did not disclose information it was obligated to produce
With regard to Toyota SUA, sudden unintended acceleration, there remain some very tough questions for Toyota, the NHTSA, and the DOJ to answer:
1) Why haven't Professor David Gilbert's and embedded systems expert Michael Barr's findings of an electronic fault without adequate fail-safe in the Toyota ETCS been fully examined?
2) Why hasn't Dr. Antony Anderson's logical debunking of NHTSA's 1989 driver error determination of SUA been considered?
3) Why haven't the Toyota internal documents of Toyota Whistleblower, Betsy Benjaminson, been acknowledged and accepted as evidence in Toyota's criminal investigation? Toyota engineers admit concern about the "ghost in the machine" and the unpredictability of the performance of the ETCS.
4) Why are the Toyota owners both the field-testers and fail-safe applicators for their own vehicles' questionably-designed ETCS?
5) Most importantly, how many more deaths have to occur before someone takes charge of permanently eliminating the unacceptable risks to both the Toyota drivers and those they encounter on the roads and highways?
Consistent with TOYOTA'S CORPORATE PLAYBOOK that the LEMON LADY arbitrarily called CHAPTER 2, yup!
Discredit!
Discredit! Discredit!
Behind the scenes, Toyota played hardball with critics. A public relations manager named Masami Doi had spelled out the approach in a December email. "There are at most around 10 people who are the sources of negative tone communications. If they can be suppressed, I think we will be able to manage it somehow. Like you said, let's go with an intention of destroying each individual person's ability to oppose us, one by one…."
– David Hechler, Is Toyota Telling The Truth About Sudden Acceleration (emphasis supplied)
Monday, June 9, 2014
Toyota cover-up worse than GM coverup
Toyota cover-up worse than GM coverup
I was pretty shocked when I read this: "...the company hid from federal regulators a second cause of unintended acceleration in its vehicles: a sticky gas pedal. The problem was caused by plastic material inside the pedal that could cause the accelerator to become stuck in a partially depressed position. The pedals were installed in several models, including the Camry, the Matrix, the Corolla and the Avalon.
"...For several months, Toyota received more evidence of the pedal problem and quietly made plans to address it without informing federal safety officials as required by law. Concerned that federal officials would learn about these plans, the company canceled the change in pedal design and communicated that change orally rather than in writing, so there would be no paper trail. After more instances of sticky pedals came to the company’s attention in 2009, executives decided to disclose the issue to federal regulators and issue a new recall. But the deception did not end there. After the recall was completed, the company produced an inaccurate timeline and submitted it to federal regulators and Congress, making it appear as if the company had acted quickly to address the sticky-pedal issue.
“Rather than promptly disclosing and correcting safety issues about which they were aware, Toyota made misleading public statements to consumers and gave inaccurate facts to members of Congress,” Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. said at a news conference announcing the settlement.
LINK: Toyota reaches $1.2 billion settlement to end probe of accelerator problems - The Washington Post
"...For several months, Toyota received more evidence of the pedal problem and quietly made plans to address it without informing federal safety officials as required by law. Concerned that federal officials would learn about these plans, the company canceled the change in pedal design and communicated that change orally rather than in writing, so there would be no paper trail. After more instances of sticky pedals came to the company’s attention in 2009, executives decided to disclose the issue to federal regulators and issue a new recall. But the deception did not end there. After the recall was completed, the company produced an inaccurate timeline and submitted it to federal regulators and Congress, making it appear as if the company had acted quickly to address the sticky-pedal issue.
“Rather than promptly disclosing and correcting safety issues about which they were aware, Toyota made misleading public statements to consumers and gave inaccurate facts to members of Congress,” Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. said at a news conference announcing the settlement.
LINK: Toyota reaches $1.2 billion settlement to end probe of accelerator problems - The Washington Post
Who knew that driving a Toyota or Lexus could result in jail time and worse if a sudden unintended acceleration accident occurred? Toyota said all this is over because the recall has been done and it has paid its $1.2 billion fine. THINK again if you believe that claim! The real problem currently is ELECTRONIC SUA and accidents are happening daily. Many of these involve vehicles in parking lots when braking is initiated. Storefront crashes and crashes-into-buildings/homes are reported. Toyota finds the vehicle faultless...no code stored and EDR (black box) shows no braking. However, Toyota and Lexus drivers report the vehicle "taking off" or "having a mind of its own." These same vehicles have been reported going airborne from a standstill starting point in a parking lot!
Here are the critical issues:
Sloppily-designed Toyota electronic throttle system software (see Michael Barr's findings) equals RUNAWAY---a.k.a. sudden unintended acceleration----Toyota and Lexus vehicles.
Worse? The electronic fail-safe---a.k.a. the way to stop the runaway---is also rendered ineffective at the time of the SUA glitch (Michael Barr, embedded software expert).
Translation? Your runaway Toyota or Lexus is not going to stop until something stops it!
Even worse? Your Toyota or Lexus EDR---a.k.a black box---is going to record inconsistent, unreliable data (see Dr. Antony Anderson's findings).
Problem? You will be CHARGED for any deaths or injuries to others as a result of an accident your runaway vehicle causes based on the faulty EDR results and an assumption of "driver pedal misapplication."
More of a problem? You may go to JAIL or prison if the EDR erroneously shows that you are not braking---which it has for others more often than not. Essentially, you will be deemed not telling the truth or confused in media coverage because Toyota will say its EDR is accurate---even though it admitted this data was unreliable previously.
Even a bigger problem? If there is any chance a detail comes out that supports the driver, the media will take sides with the automaker and support your character assassination publicly. Are you on prescription meds or any medications? Are you an older citizen? Are you a woman and older? Bingo! Elderly pedal misapplication, according to media and Toyota.
Don't worry...all your skeletons will be dug up as Toyota goes full steam ahead to escape blame for faulty electronics! Just keep track of all these mysterious vehicles-into-homes and storefront crashes and read the headlines. Read the PR propaganda supporting driver error.
Toyota's $$ goes far and wide...even to the heart of the very agency commissioned to protect your SAFETY! The DOJ and NHTSA are still looking the other way---a.k.a. protecting corporate interests. They do not want to open up the ELECTRONIC sudden unintended acceleration issue as then there will be a public cover-up scandal which rivals the best---or worst---of them.
All the above doesn't factor in the so far little-known in the U.S. whistleblower, Betsy Benjaminson. She's has copies of hundreds of internal Toyota documents. Many of these show clear evidence of concern over an electronic throttle system problem---a.k.a. "ghost in the engine"---and the lack of fix for it. Betsy has a blog where she has posted some of the evidence. She's been the feature of several articles and a podcast interview outside the U.S. Google her name to find.
Toyota, the media, and the government seem to be handling each new suspicious runaway vehicle accident---a.k.a. driver states pressing brake when the vehicle takes off, becomes airborne, has a mind of its own, etc.---on a case-by-case basis. Apparently, there is the hope that each case will blow over with little public attention. There is hope, too, that the public buys into the PR machine working overtime with law enforcement and media to BLAME the vehicle driver. SUA victim = SCAPEGOAT.
As far as Toyota is concerned, it is DONE with the topic of sudden unintended acceleration. Period. It got the free pass with a huge U.S. Government fine---a.k.a. permission not to face the music regarding ELECTRONIC SUA. Floor mats, pedals, driver error...done DEAL.
Toyota's well-orchestrated smoke screen continues aided and abetted by our very own safety regulatory agency. Can't beat that! The sky's the limit now...think of all the untoward consequences for Toyota owners, not to mention the driving public.
Toyota is #1 in numbers of sudden unintended acceleration events. BUT...it is not alone! This is an industry-wide phenomenon and not one automaker wants the public knowledgeable about ELECTRONIC sudden unintended acceleration.
Here are the critical issues:
Sloppily-designed Toyota electronic throttle system software (see Michael Barr's findings) equals RUNAWAY---a.k.a. sudden unintended acceleration----Toyota and Lexus vehicles.
Worse? The electronic fail-safe---a.k.a. the way to stop the runaway---is also rendered ineffective at the time of the SUA glitch (Michael Barr, embedded software expert).
Translation? Your runaway Toyota or Lexus is not going to stop until something stops it!
Even worse? Your Toyota or Lexus EDR---a.k.a black box---is going to record inconsistent, unreliable data (see Dr. Antony Anderson's findings).
Problem? You will be CHARGED for any deaths or injuries to others as a result of an accident your runaway vehicle causes based on the faulty EDR results and an assumption of "driver pedal misapplication."
More of a problem? You may go to JAIL or prison if the EDR erroneously shows that you are not braking---which it has for others more often than not. Essentially, you will be deemed not telling the truth or confused in media coverage because Toyota will say its EDR is accurate---even though it admitted this data was unreliable previously.
Even a bigger problem? If there is any chance a detail comes out that supports the driver, the media will take sides with the automaker and support your character assassination publicly. Are you on prescription meds or any medications? Are you an older citizen? Are you a woman and older? Bingo! Elderly pedal misapplication, according to media and Toyota.
Don't worry...all your skeletons will be dug up as Toyota goes full steam ahead to escape blame for faulty electronics! Just keep track of all these mysterious vehicles-into-homes and storefront crashes and read the headlines. Read the PR propaganda supporting driver error.
Toyota's $$ goes far and wide...even to the heart of the very agency commissioned to protect your SAFETY! The DOJ and NHTSA are still looking the other way---a.k.a. protecting corporate interests. They do not want to open up the ELECTRONIC sudden unintended acceleration issue as then there will be a public cover-up scandal which rivals the best---or worst---of them.
All the above doesn't factor in the so far little-known in the U.S. whistleblower, Betsy Benjaminson. She's has copies of hundreds of internal Toyota documents. Many of these show clear evidence of concern over an electronic throttle system problem---a.k.a. "ghost in the engine"---and the lack of fix for it. Betsy has a blog where she has posted some of the evidence. She's been the feature of several articles and a podcast interview outside the U.S. Google her name to find.
Toyota, the media, and the government seem to be handling each new suspicious runaway vehicle accident---a.k.a. driver states pressing brake when the vehicle takes off, becomes airborne, has a mind of its own, etc.---on a case-by-case basis. Apparently, there is the hope that each case will blow over with little public attention. There is hope, too, that the public buys into the PR machine working overtime with law enforcement and media to BLAME the vehicle driver. SUA victim = SCAPEGOAT.
As far as Toyota is concerned, it is DONE with the topic of sudden unintended acceleration. Period. It got the free pass with a huge U.S. Government fine---a.k.a. permission not to face the music regarding ELECTRONIC SUA. Floor mats, pedals, driver error...done DEAL.
Toyota's well-orchestrated smoke screen continues aided and abetted by our very own safety regulatory agency. Can't beat that! The sky's the limit now...think of all the untoward consequences for Toyota owners, not to mention the driving public.
Toyota is #1 in numbers of sudden unintended acceleration events. BUT...it is not alone! This is an industry-wide phenomenon and not one automaker wants the public knowledgeable about ELECTRONIC sudden unintended acceleration.
Thursday, May 8, 2014
Toyota Unintended Acceleration - Engineering Ethics
Below is a MUST WATCH video!
This is the 'Saylor Family' crash that TOYOTA settled with a confidentiality agreement after years of delays....TOYOTA blamed the dealership that got the 'confidentiality agreement' removed.
TOYOTA settled for $10 MILLION. Why would they do that?
Published on May 8, 2014
This is the 'Saylor Family' crash that TOYOTA settled with a confidentiality agreement after years of delays....TOYOTA blamed the dealership that got the 'confidentiality agreement' removed.
TOYOTA settled for $10 MILLION. Why would they do that?
Published on May 8, 2014
This video is created by engineering student at the American University of Beirut to present an engineering ethics case as a final project for their course ENMG 504.
Saturday, April 26, 2014
Easter Sunday and TOYOTA: Let's Go Places!
The TOYOTA LEXUS crash described in the article below has all the hallmarks of TOYOTA'S SUDDEN UNINTENDED ACCELERATION problem that TOYOTA has refused to address/correct, blamed on floor mats, sticky pedals and driver error.
At least 21 were injured, 18 people were taken to local hospitals.
TOYOTA continues to give new meaning to their ad campaign.....
FROM: Mysterious Lexus crash. '02-'06 Camrys still not recalled.
http://www.jrn.com/fox4now/news/Driver-in-Fort-Myers-church-crash-identified-256015171.html?lc=Tablet
At least 21 were injured, 18 people were taken to local hospitals.
TOYOTA continues to give new meaning to their ad campaign.....
FROM: Mysterious Lexus crash. '02-'06 Camrys still not recalled.
Worth reading in its entirety!
Victims of Fort Myers church crash speak out
Julian Glover
CREATED Apr. 21, 2014 - UPDATED: Apr. 21, 2014
FORT MYERS, Fla. – Victims in a Fort Myers crash, where a car smashed into a church Sunday night, are speaking out as police identify the driver accused of causing the chaos.
“Something went POW,” yelled Crismane Mathurn, as she recounted the events of Sunday night.
Mathurn was one of more than 200 other churchgoers, packed inside the Second Haitian Baptist Church during the time of the crash.
Others described the sound of the impact as “deafening.”
“She described it as Haiti, when the earthquake happened – the sound effect,” said Patti Louis.
Louis says both of her parents were inside of the church for the annual Easter concernt, when a 2006 Lexus sedan, driven by Marie Ange Masson went crashing into the building, according to Fort Myers Police.
Police say Masson claims there was a mechanical malfunction, telling police that she attempted to press the break and park the car when it accelerated.
31-year-old Masson is not being charged criminally at this time, but police say the investigation remains active.
FOX 4 exclusively spoke to the owner of the car involved in the crash, he says the car had no known issues.
“There’s nothing wrong with the car,” said Asker Joram, “The break is alright…tires alright…nothing.”
18 people were transported to several area hospitals, four of the injured went as trauma alerts.
The age of the injured ranged from six-years-old to 88-years-old.
None of the injuries appeared to be life-threatening. None of the patients needed to go into surgery. Most of the injuries were sprains and cuts.
Rescuers used car jacks to lift the vehicle off of people who were trapped.
Many loved ones of those pinned in the wreckage got a call that would even shake the most religious.
“I just asked if my mom was dead or not,” said Dufils Sherilus.
One woman seen heading back to the hospital this morning to visit a family member says she was treated for back and neck pain but was later released.
Today, families of those involved in the crash are thanking a divine being for minimizing what could have been a tragedy to an accident.
“He was sitting in that row (where the car crashed) and then he just sat moved back, because my mom sat behind him...he went to sit with my mom,” said Louis, “Thank God he did get up.”
The Fort Myers Police Department estimates upwards of $10,000 in damage was done to the building in the crash.
http://www.jrn.com/fox4now/news/Driver-in-Fort-Myers-church-crash-identified-256015171.html?lc=Tablet
Thursday, April 24, 2014
The TOYOTA SCAM and Corporate Media CoverUp
The Second Anniversary of owning a TOYOTA LEMON has safely come and gone with the TOYOTA LEMON parked on the property of ROUTE 44 TOYOTA, the TOYOTA dealership that SOLD ME THE LEMON.
This is a simple reminder of some of the ROUTE 44 TOYOTA LEMON history.....
More Than A LEMON......
My Friend at Beware of Toyota. Their next victim may be YOU... has written more that you might want to check out....
Mysterious Lexus crash. '02-'06 Camrys still not recalled.
NASA physicist warns of unintended acceleration risk in '02-'06 Camrys
NASA physicist targets Toyota's electronic throttle control
Wednesday, April 9, 2014
Don't Fault Me Because TOYOTA Lied!
TOYOTA paid $1.2 BILLION to Get Out of Jail Free!
It's a pittance since TOYOTA has a cash nestegg of $60 BILLION.
The LEMON LADY's posts seem to attract some dedicated, but not so smart TOYOTA employee who believes he knows more than a NASA physicist or the software geeks who studied TOYOTA's flawed software.
To those dedicated employees: Your loyalty is impressive, but you clearly need to inform yourselves [and avoid posting vulgarity since that's the best you can do!].
PLEASE READ: The DOJ documents and other information is available on this link:
Center for Auto Safety

WASHINGTON — Efforts to conceal the extent of dangerous car defects at Toyota Motor Corp. were so pervasive, prosecutors say, that an exasperated employee at one point warned that ‘‘someone will go to jail if lies are repeatedly told.’’
Yet no one has gone to jail, nor is anyone likely to.
Last week, the Justice Department socked the car company with a $1.2 billion penalty but brought no criminal charges against individual executives, an unsatisfying resolution for consumer activists who say prison is the best deterrence for corporate malfeasance.
Prosecutors say they had little choice, in part because of constraints with evidence and the challenge of gathering testimony and information from witnesses abroad.
The same internal memos and public statements that buttressed the case against the corporation might well have been inadmissible as evidence against individuals. And it can be hard to prove the person whose name is on a damning document was responsible for the misstatements or knew that they were wrong, experts say.
While the case against the company may be overwhelming, personal responsibility for misstatements ‘‘is more difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt,’’ said Stephen Saltzburg, a law professor at George Washington University.
Preet Bharara, US attorney for the Southern District of New York, whose office brought the case, said last week that while he had not foreclosed the possibility of criminal charges against individuals, he expected the settlement to be the end of the matter.
When lawbreakers live outside the country, ‘‘there are problems of evidence and problems of proof,’’ Bharara said when asked about the prospect of prosecuting individuals. Evidence that can be brought into play against a corporation, he said, might not be admissible against specific people.
Toyota, which acknowledged it hid information about defects, said that in the four years since the recalls, it had ‘‘made fundamental changes to become a more responsive and customer-focused organization, and we are committed to continued improvements.’’
The penalty is the largest of its kind ever brought against an auto company, according to the Justice Department. The department also filed a wire fraud charge against Toyota that the government says it will dismiss in three years if the company complies with terms of the settlement. Even so, some consumer advocates fear a monetary penalty alone generally doesn’t do enough.
‘‘While $1.2 billion is an enormous number, it is going to be very easily absorbed by the company,’’ said Jack Gillis, public affairs director for the Consumer Federation of America. ‘‘So shouldn’t there have been some personal culpability among the decision makers?’’
Court documents accuse Toyota of intentionally withholding information about problems that could make some of its cars accelerate out of control. One such problem, involving ill-fitting floor mats, attracted negative attention for the company following a 2009 car crash in San Diego that killed a family of four.
Prosecutors say Toyota made public statements that were misleading or false and key information about the extent of the problems was never disclosed. For example, they point to an inaccurate timeline the company provided to Congress on when it learned about a problem with sticky gas pedals that could cause unwanted acceleration. They also cite misleading disclosures to regulators and a 2009 online statement assuring the public that the ‘‘root cause’’ of one of the problems had been addressed.
When engineers found that gas pedals could stick, they told their parts supplier to start making a redesigned version and to scrap any pedals with the old design. But management canceled the fix and instructed the engineers not to tell the supplier in writing so there would be no paper trail, prosecutors said.
Under federal rules of evidence, prosecutors would have had a better chance of introducing those statements as evidence against the corporation than against an individual.
‘‘They would have to pinpoint some individual who wrote those statements knowing they were false,’’ said Paul Rothstein, a Georgetown University law professor. ‘‘That would be hard to do, even if they could pinpoint who actually composed the statement.”
General Motors Co. is facing a separate federal criminal probe in New York over delays in recalling small cars with a deadly ignition switch problem. It’s unclear whether any individuals are being investigated.
http://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2014/03/25/toyota-case-shows-hard-prosecute-execs/9OdTxlOZ2TfafZomUNUAdP/story.html
It's a pittance since TOYOTA has a cash nestegg of $60 BILLION.
The LEMON LADY's posts seem to attract some dedicated, but not so smart TOYOTA employee who believes he knows more than a NASA physicist or the software geeks who studied TOYOTA's flawed software.
To those dedicated employees: Your loyalty is impressive, but you clearly need to inform yourselves [and avoid posting vulgarity since that's the best you can do!].
PLEASE READ: The DOJ documents and other information is available on this link:
Center for Auto Safety
Toyota case shows it’s hard to prosecute execs
Rules of evidence, witnesses abroad made jail unlikely
By Eric Tucker
| Associated Press March 26, 2014
Susan Walsh /Associated Press
Attorney General Eric Holder (right) and the US attorney in New York, Preet Bharara, discussed the $1.2 billion settlement with Toyota at a news conference last week.WASHINGTON — Efforts to conceal the extent of dangerous car defects at Toyota Motor Corp. were so pervasive, prosecutors say, that an exasperated employee at one point warned that ‘‘someone will go to jail if lies are repeatedly told.’’
Yet no one has gone to jail, nor is anyone likely to.
Prosecutors say they had little choice, in part because of constraints with evidence and the challenge of gathering testimony and information from witnesses abroad.
While the case against the company may be overwhelming, personal responsibility for misstatements ‘‘is more difficult to prove beyond a reasonable doubt,’’ said Stephen Saltzburg, a law professor at George Washington University.
Preet Bharara, US attorney for the Southern District of New York, whose office brought the case, said last week that while he had not foreclosed the possibility of criminal charges against individuals, he expected the settlement to be the end of the matter.
When lawbreakers live outside the country, ‘‘there are problems of evidence and problems of proof,’’ Bharara said when asked about the prospect of prosecuting individuals. Evidence that can be brought into play against a corporation, he said, might not be admissible against specific people.
Toyota, which acknowledged it hid information about defects, said that in the four years since the recalls, it had ‘‘made fundamental changes to become a more responsive and customer-focused organization, and we are committed to continued improvements.’’
The penalty is the largest of its kind ever brought against an auto company, according to the Justice Department. The department also filed a wire fraud charge against Toyota that the government says it will dismiss in three years if the company complies with terms of the settlement. Even so, some consumer advocates fear a monetary penalty alone generally doesn’t do enough.
‘‘While $1.2 billion is an enormous number, it is going to be very easily absorbed by the company,’’ said Jack Gillis, public affairs director for the Consumer Federation of America. ‘‘So shouldn’t there have been some personal culpability among the decision makers?’’
Court documents accuse Toyota of intentionally withholding information about problems that could make some of its cars accelerate out of control. One such problem, involving ill-fitting floor mats, attracted negative attention for the company following a 2009 car crash in San Diego that killed a family of four.
Prosecutors say Toyota made public statements that were misleading or false and key information about the extent of the problems was never disclosed. For example, they point to an inaccurate timeline the company provided to Congress on when it learned about a problem with sticky gas pedals that could cause unwanted acceleration. They also cite misleading disclosures to regulators and a 2009 online statement assuring the public that the ‘‘root cause’’ of one of the problems had been addressed.
When engineers found that gas pedals could stick, they told their parts supplier to start making a redesigned version and to scrap any pedals with the old design. But management canceled the fix and instructed the engineers not to tell the supplier in writing so there would be no paper trail, prosecutors said.
Under federal rules of evidence, prosecutors would have had a better chance of introducing those statements as evidence against the corporation than against an individual.
‘‘They would have to pinpoint some individual who wrote those statements knowing they were false,’’ said Paul Rothstein, a Georgetown University law professor. ‘‘That would be hard to do, even if they could pinpoint who actually composed the statement.”
General Motors Co. is facing a separate federal criminal probe in New York over delays in recalling small cars with a deadly ignition switch problem. It’s unclear whether any individuals are being investigated.
http://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2014/03/25/toyota-case-shows-hard-prosecute-execs/9OdTxlOZ2TfafZomUNUAdP/story.html
Wednesday, March 19, 2014
What's a 'GET OUT OF JAIL, FREE' card worth?
$1.2 BILLION for TOYOTA!
There are many who took great personal risk to stand up to TOYOTA's criminal conduct, many who analyzed the flaws.
TOYOTA attempted to discredit 'experts,' conceal the TRUTH of their CRIMINAL CONDUCT.
More will be written......
Will TOYOTA ever take steps to 'make amends'?
Consider the case of Koua Fong Lee:
Jailed Toyota driver deserves punitive damages
Thursday, February 27, 2014
The Courage to Uncover TOYOTA's lies......
Betsy Benjaminson uncovered the tangled web of lies contained in TOYOTA's own documents, dispelling TOYOTA's public denials.....
Ms. Benjaminson paid a steep personal price for DOING THE RIGHT THING and saving lives!
We will never know the injuries and lives saved because of Ms. Benjaminson's heroism...what we do know is what TOYOTA destroyed.....
Below is an interview on Israeli television, Ms Benjaminson's comments are in English:
http://flix.tapuz.co.il/v/watch-4352876-.html
Consumers owe a great debt to Ms. Benjaminson for her conscience and her courage in stepping forward and revealing TOYOTA's lies.
Ms. Benjaminson paid a steep personal price for DOING THE RIGHT THING and saving lives!
We will never know the injuries and lives saved because of Ms. Benjaminson's heroism...what we do know is what TOYOTA destroyed.....
Below is an interview on Israeli television, Ms Benjaminson's comments are in English:
http://flix.tapuz.co.il/v/watch-4352876-.html
Consumers owe a great debt to Ms. Benjaminson for her conscience and her courage in stepping forward and revealing TOYOTA's lies.
Monday, February 10, 2014
TOYOTA Lies and Media Cover Up
Documents from TOYOTA indicate that TOYOTA was fully aware of the SOFTWARE and HARDWARE problems that caused SUDDEN UNINTENDED ACCELERATION in 2002, yet refused to correct it.
[See Toyota allowed people to die]
TOYOTA continued to produce vehicles that INJURED or KILLED innocent victims!
Betsy Benjaminson heroically stepped forward, exposing TOYOTA's LIES and COVER-UP:
Behind the scenes, Toyota played hardball with critics. A public relations manager named Masami Doi had spelled out the approach in a December email. "There are at most around 10 people who are the sources of negative tone communications. If they can be suppressed, I think we will be able to manage it somehow. Like you said, let's go with an intention of destroying each individual person's ability to oppose us, one by one…."
– David Hechler, Is Toyota Telling The Truth About Sudden Acceleration (emphasis supplied)
According to this story, some of the NASA scientists who worked on the February 2011 report that DOT Secretary Ray LaHood proclaimed an exoneration of Toyota electronics were so disturbed by the way they were forced to “investigate,” they refused to sign the final product.
Ya gotta love this horse manure being spread by the media:
The Japanese company has maintained the electronic throttle control system was not at fault, blaming ill-fitting floor mats and sticky gas pedals.
Prosecutors have increasingly turned to such agreements in recent years as a means of forcing companies to accept responsibility while avoiding the potentially crippling consequences of federal criminal convictions.
[See Toyota allowed people to die]
TOYOTA continued to produce vehicles that INJURED or KILLED innocent victims!
Bulletin: Feds probe deadly Toyota crash in NH that killed Harvard professor, 3 others
“The settlement is for people who suffered an economic loss, but we lost human
beings — husbands, fathers, daughters,” said Colleen Krause whose husband,
Stephen, was killed in 2009 when a speeding Toyota Highlander crossed the center
line on Route 202 in New Hampshire and hit his rented Chevrolet head-on. “It’s
good news, but it doesn’t bring back my husband.”
The driver of the Highlander, Harvard biostatistics professor Stephen Lagakos, also died in the crash, along with his wife and mother, who were passengers in his vehicle.
The driver of the Highlander, Harvard biostatistics professor Stephen Lagakos, also died in the crash, along with his wife and mother, who were passengers in his vehicle.
Betsy Benjaminson heroically stepped forward, exposing TOYOTA's LIES and COVER-UP:
Behind the scenes, Toyota played hardball with critics. A public relations manager named Masami Doi had spelled out the approach in a December email. "There are at most around 10 people who are the sources of negative tone communications. If they can be suppressed, I think we will be able to manage it somehow. Like you said, let's go with an intention of destroying each individual person's ability to oppose us, one by one…."
– David Hechler, Is Toyota Telling The Truth About Sudden Acceleration (emphasis supplied)
According to this story, some of the NASA scientists who worked on the February 2011 report that DOT Secretary Ray LaHood proclaimed an exoneration of Toyota electronics were so disturbed by the way they were forced to “investigate,” they refused to sign the final product.
Ya gotta love this horse manure being spread by the media:
The Japanese company has maintained the electronic throttle control system was not at fault, blaming ill-fitting floor mats and sticky gas pedals.
Toyota in Talks on Final Settlements Over Car Recalls
By JACLYN TROP and BEN PROTESS
Toyota is moving to resolve the last major legal issues related to the unintended acceleration of its vehicles, which has already cost it billions of dollars and prompted the recall of millions of cars in 2009 and 2010.
In one case, Toyota is nearing a deal with the Justice Department to settle a criminal investigation over the way the automaker disclosed complaints stemming from the sudden acceleration of its vehicles, according to two people with knowledge of the talks.
The discussions, with the criminal division of the United States attorney’s office for the Southern District of New York, are the culmination of a roughly four-year investigation.
The Securities and Exchange Commission is also involved, focusing on whether Toyota fully disclosed the potential financial impact of the vehicle problems.
The news of the possible deal was first reported by The Wall Street Journal.
Toyota officials on Sunday said that no agreement had been reached, but that a settlement was one of the final hurdles the automaker must clear as it strove to put its prolonged legal troubles in the past.
“Toyota continues to cooperate with the U.S. attorney’s office in this matter,” said Carly Schaffner, a spokeswoman. “In the nearly four years since this inquiry began, we have made fundamental changes to become a more responsive and customer-focused organization, and we are committed to continued improvements.”
Separately, Toyota is in talks to settle hundreds of state and federal lawsuits filed against it claiming wrongful death and personal injury. The automaker announced in December it was entering negotiations to settle the lawsuits, two months after it lost a landmark case in an Oklahoma court.
The jury in that case found that a Toyota Camry’s electronic throttle system was defective in a 2005 crash that killed one woman and injured another.
The defeat came after Toyota won its first three sudden-acceleration trials, and analysts said that the losing verdict was the catalyst for Toyota to pursue a settlement of its remaining cases.
A lawyer involved in the settlement talks, who requested anonymity because he was not authorized to speak publicly, said that of the 400 or so cases remaining, “a significant number have been settled,” with the remainder to be negotiated in February and March. The ones not settled will go to mediation in April and May, the lawyer said.
Toyota’s efforts to resolve its legal issues come as the automaker says it expects to reach record profits this year in an increasingly competitive automotive landscape, said Alec Gutierrez, senior analyst at Kelley Blue Book.
“While Toyota’s quality was once unquestioned, they now face renewed competition from the domestics, Koreans and their traditional Japanese counterparts that now produce vehicles of similar or arguably superior quality for the money,” Mr. Gutierrez said.
Industry watchers said the protracted timeline of Toyota’s sudden-acceleration troubles and legal issues continued to create negative publicity.
A settlement with the Justice Department could exacerbate Toyota’s struggles to settle its remaining cases and would be “another reminder of the earlier difficulties that tarnished its reputation,” said Carl W. Tobias, a professor who specializes in product liability at the University of Richmond School of Law.
The publicity surrounding a settlement “will increase the pressure on Toyota to settle the wrongful death and personal injury cases for more than Toyota might have paid, had it settled those claims earlier,” he said.
Last week, the automaker said it would stop selling certain models of its cars in response to claims that nearly 30,000 new Toyotas were equipped with faulty or malfunctioning heated seats.
“It is striking how every time that Toyota seems to be emerging from its sudden-acceleration problems stretching back more than five years, some new difficulty appears,” Mr. Tobias said.
Toyota Nears $1 Billion Deal to End Probe
Auto Maker, U.S. Prosecutor in Talks to Settle Investigation Involving Recall Disclosures
They are also looking into possible mail and wire fraud violations connected to those allegedly false disclosures, these people said. It is a federal crime to make false statements to a government agency.
A settlement that tops $1 billion would be one of the largest government fines ever extracted from an auto maker.
A Justice Department spokesman declined to discuss the specifics of any pending settlement.
"This is a landmark case because the auto industry has bobbed and weaved and done everything possible to avoid criminal sanctions forever," said Joan Claybrook, who led NHTSA from 1977 to 1981.
In February 2010, NHTSA said the agency had confirmed that five people in two incidents had died as a result of accidents involving claims of unwanted acceleration.
In the ensuing three years, Toyota was fined four times by NHTSA for a total of $66.2 million for failing to report safety defects to the government in a timely manner. Three of those fines were related to issues concerning unwanted acceleration.
Toyota said in November 2013 that it had received two subpoenas each from the Securities and Exchange Commission and Manhattan federal prosecutors in February and June 2010 related to "unintended acceleration and certain financial records," according to regulatory filings. Toyota also disclosed investigators interviewed Toyota and non-Toyota witnesses and said it was cooperating with officials.
The status of the SEC investigation is unclear. A spokesman for the SEC declined to comment. A spokesman for NHTSA referred questions to the Justice Department and declined to comment.
Toyota stepped up efforts to resolve outstanding claims related to the issue after it lost a wrongful-death civil case in Oklahoma last October. That verdict was seen by legal observers on both sides of the battle as complicating Toyota's legal prospects in future cases.
The auto maker moved overnight to settle that suit for an undisclosed amount after the jury ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, but before they could award punitive damages.
After the Oklahoma trial, Toyota entered into talks to settle the outstanding personal injury and wrongful death suits stemming from unwanted acceleration issues, according to attorneys involved in the litigation. Those talks are continuing, these people say.
Prosecutors' settlement with Toyota is expected to include a criminal deferred prosecution agreement with the car maker, according to several people familiar with the negotiations.
The precise terms of the agreement that is being considered with Toyota are unclear, but such agreements generally place a company facing prosecution under probation for a set number of years, during which time the company has to fulfill certain compliance obligations to avoid criminal charges.
In taking on Toyota, prosecutors are going after an industry that watchdog groups have long complained is given too free a ride from regulators and from legal scrutiny for safety issues.
Toyota has made structural changes to the company and says it has installed new quality control measures as part of its response to the crisis. It brought outsiders onto its board for the first time including the first ever American.
Toyota close to $1 billion deal to settle U.S. probe: WSJ
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



























